10 Ohio Amish Markets To Stock Up On Homemade Thanksgiving Pies, Bread, And Side Dishes
Thanksgiving dinner sounds wonderful until you realize how much cooking needs to happen before everyone sits down. The pies need baking, the bread needs to be fresh, and somehow all those side dishes have to make it onto the table while they’re still warm.
Luckily, Ohio has Amish markets that can make the holiday preparations a whole lot easier.
Picture shelves filled with golden apple pies, fresh loaves of bread, homemade noodles, and jars of preserves that taste like something your grandmother would have made. The smell of cinnamon and freshly baked dough alone could convince you to buy more than you planned.
Ohio’s Amish communities have a long tradition of preparing hearty meals with recipes passed down through generations. Their markets are wonderful places to find holiday favorites without spending all day in the kitchen.
And with Thanksgiving approaching, knowing where to find those homemade treats could be your smartest holiday decision yet.
1. Walnut Creek Cheese
One stop can cover half your holiday list. This marketplace brings a bakery, deli, creamery, cannery, and gift shop under one roof.
It is a lot like a small village for food lovers. The shop sits at 2641 State Route 39 in Walnut Creek. Rolling hills and farms surround it. The land once belonged to the area’s first Amish settler.
Cheese is the star here, but the bakery shelves deserve a long look. Fresh breads and baked goods fill the cases. Pick up a pie or two for the dessert table.
Side dishes get help from the Copper Kettle Cannery. Its canned goods include apple butter barbecue sauce and hot pepper relish. A spoonful of relish can wake up a plain plate of turkey.
The deli adds sliced meats and cheeses for the pre-dinner snack tray. Fresh cuts like pork chops, steaks, and chicken are also on hand. Bulk foods and fresh produce round out the shopping list.
Inside, the decor feels nostalgic, with antique touches everywhere. The goods reflect the work of local Amish and Mennonite families.
Save room for homemade custard from the creamery before heading home. Sugarcreek is a short drive away. That makes a nice second stop on the same trip.
2. Hershberger’s Farm And Bakery
Kettle corn has a sneaky way of pulling people off the road. The sweet smell drifts out and steers visitors straight inside. Soon the cart is full of pie.
This farm stop is found at 5452 State Route 557 in Millersburg. The road is a scenic byway with gentle hills.
A barn with goats on the roof makes the photo stop easy. Bakers here make breads, pies, cookies, muffins, and donuts every day. The famous fry pies come in 13 flavors. Apple, peach, raspberry, and chocolate are just a few.
Cinnamon rolls and cheesecake are popular too. They make a fine surprise for guests who arrive early. Hide them if you want any left for dinner.
Side dish helpers fill the shelves as well. Jams, jellies, and apple butters are ready for rolls and biscuits. Fresh seasonal produce can cover the vegetable dishes.
Homemade candy adds a sweet bonus for the kids’ table. The shop is also a peek at a working Amish farm. A petting area with farm animals keeps little shoppers happy. Buggy rides add a bit of old-time fun. Turn the errand into a small outing for the whole family.
3. Troyer Country Market
A front porch full of produce is a good sign. Seasonal items often greet shoppers before they reach the door. Inside, the whole Amish Country pantry waits.
You will find this market at 5201 County Road 77 in Millersburg. It sits near the corner of County Road 77 and State Route 39, close to Berlin. The setting is the heart of a region known for rich traditions.
Pies lead the way for Thanksgiving. Black raspberry, apple, pecan, and lemon are all sold. Fry pies remain a steady favorite.
Breads and cookies fill more shelves. Pound cakes are available for a simple dessert. A plate of assorted cookies helps when the pie runs out.
Homemade soups are made from scratch in many flavors. They are handy for the day before the big meal. Nobody wants to cook two big dinners in a row.
Appetizers are covered with cheeseballs, dips, and spreads made from scratch. Jams, jellies, and fruit butters are popular gifts. They also dress up a basket of warm rolls.
Dessert after dessert is possible here. The shop offers homemade ice cream in 32 hand-dipped options. A scoop on warm pie is a fine holiday tradition.
4. Ashery Country Store
Few store names carry as much history as this one. The word Ashery connects to old lye production and cheese making in the area. The site itself once held original asheries and a cheese factory.
Today the store is at 8922 State Route 241 in Fredericksburg. It sits between Mount Hope, a major auction center, and the town of Kidron.
Rolling hills and charming shops surround the drive. The mood is friendly and family oriented. The business focuses on handmade and local products. That makes it easy to shop close to home.
Home-cooked foods are the draw for a holiday list. Pies and cookies are ready for the dessert table. Sandwiches and soups help feed helpers on prep day.
Stock the pantry with dried foods in bulk. Baking supplies and fresh ground nut butters are also here. Locally made cheeses and deli meats can fill a snack board.
Handmade jams and snacks add extra flavor. They also make easy thank-you gifts for hosts. Homemade frozen custard waits for the end of the trip. The store is large, so give yourself time to wander. A list will keep you focused. A cooler will keep the custard happy.
5. Miller’s Bakery
Yeast, cinnamon, and sugar make a powerful welcome. The scent fills the air long before the first bite. This bakery has been at it since 1967.
That makes it the oldest bakery in Holmes County. You will find it at 4280 Township Road 356 in Millersburg.
The back roads between Charm and Berlin lead the way. The setting is quiet and rustic. This part of the state is known for calm countryside. Log cabins out back even offer overnight stays.
Everything is made from scratch. Doughnuts, cream sticks, twists, and apple fritters line up beside pies and tarts. The fruit-filled cheese tarts are a best-seller and a one-of-a-kind treat.
For the dinner table, look at the breads. Twelve varieties are available. White, wheat, cinnamon raisin, oatmeal, and garden bread are all on the list.
Noodles are also a specialty. They pair well with a big pot of broth and a mashed potato mountain. Bulk foods and canned goods, including jams, are sold as well.
Fry pies are highly regarded here, so grab a few. They disappear fast once guests arrive. Buy extras and hide a couple.
6. Dutch Valley Market
Wooden shelves have a way of making grocery shopping feel calmer. Here they hold local treasures and authentic flavors. The store is clean, organized, and easy to move through.
Find it at 1411 Old Route 39 NE in Sugarcreek. The market sits in the heart of Amish Country. Sugarcreek is called the Little Switzerland of Ohio because of its Swiss heritage.
Baked goods are the main event. Cinnamon rolls, breads, and cookies are baked on site. Gluten-free items are part of the lineup too.
Pies come in many styles. Traditional pies, fry pies, and Amish-made fruit and meat pies are all sold. Donuts and whoopie pies add sweet fun.
The yeast breads are made without preservatives or fillers. That is great news for sandwich leftovers. German chocolate cake and pumpkin rolls are also offered. Pennsylvania Dutch favorites round out the shelves. Pick a few for a taste of tradition. They help the table feel special.
Nearby attractions make the trip easy to extend. Schrock’s Heritage Village and the World’s Largest Cuckoo Clock are close. Shop first, then see what chimes.
7. Swiss Village Bulk Foods
Almost 6,000 products can make a baking list feel simple. This bulk store stocks spices, baking essentials, and plenty more. Amish families and other shoppers come for good value.
You can find it at 309 S Broadway St in Sugarcreek. It is just a few blocks from the quaint downtown. The town is known for Swiss and German roots and chalet-style buildings.
Start in the baking aisles. Mixes include gingerbread cake and whole wheat pizza dough. Those are handy shortcuts when the kitchen gets busy.
Cookies, bars, and pies are available as well. Roll butter is a popular item. It melts nicely on warm dinner rolls.
The deli counter helps with appetizers. Freshly sliced meats and cheeses are ready to go. Specialty cheeses, dips, and spreads join them.
A small restaurant serves sandwiches and ice cream. It is a nice break between aisles. The store aims to make everyone feel welcome.
Walnut Creek, Berlin, Charm, and Millersburg are all a short drive away. That makes this a smart first or last stop. Fill up the pantry before heading on.
8. Mary Yoder’s Amish Kitchen
Noodles over mashed potatoes sounds like a hug on a plate. That is the kind of comfort served here. It is classic Pennsylvania Dutch style fare.
The kitchen sits at 14743 N State St in Middlefield. This is Northeast Amish Country, in Geauga County.
The area is the center of the world’s fourth-largest Amish community. The place combines a full-service restaurant, bakery, and gift shop. That gives you more than one reason to stop. Eat first, then shop.
Date nut pudding is another notable dish. It makes a different kind of dessert for a holiday crowd. Try it for inspiration.
The bakery adds freshly made treats to the visit. Details on each item vary, so ask at the counter. The staff can point you to what is ready.
The gift shop is handy for small hostess presents. Pair a treat with a card and you are set. It is an easy way to say thanks.
Middlefield is a good option for shoppers in the northeast. You do not have to drive far south to enjoy Amish cooking. A good meal makes errands feel lighter.
9. The Amish Market
A red barn full of pie is hard to resist. This indoor farmers market lives in a restored barn. Exposed beams and lantern lighting set a rustic mood.
It sits at 6121 South Ave in Boardman, just off South Avenue in the Mahoning Valley. Downtown Youngstown is only minutes away. The market operates on weekends, so plan ahead.
Fifteen Amish vendors share the space. They focus on baked goods, deli items, smoothies, and produce. A communal seating area and small cafe corner make a good rest stop.
Signature items include buttery Amish apple pie and crusty rye bread. Seasonal strawberry jam is mentioned too.
Fry pies and pretzel wraps are popular picks. The bread choices are wide. Artisan bread, light rye, and Italian focaccia are all on offer.
Dessert loaves, maple syrup butter tarts, and maple shortbread cookies sweeten the list.
For the holiday plate, look for cranberry orange chutney and cranberry jam. They are made for turkey sandwiches the next day. Fresh produce and homemade preserves fill out the basket.
The market offers a taste of Pennsylvania Dutch tradition close to the city. You do not need a long drive to enjoy it.
10. Keim Family Market
Some markets start small and just keep growing. This one began as a roadside stand in the mid-1980s. Today it is a full Amish-owned and operated shop.
You will find it at 2621 Burnt Cabin Rd in Seaman. It sits along State Route 32, the Appalachian Highway, in southern Ohio hill country.
The area is called Edge of Appalachia, with rock-ribbed hills, deep valleys, and rushing creeks. Amish families settled in Adams County in the early 1970s. The shop feels like something from Little House on the Prairie.
Handmade furniture and sundries add to the charm. Baked goods are described as mouth-melting. Homemade creme horns are a highlight. Pies, breads, cookies, and pastries fill the cases.
Side dish helpers are easy to find. Canned goods, jams, and jellies line the shelves. Pickled vegetables and other bottled foods are here too.
The meat and cheese section has cheese curds and cured and smoked bacon. Bulk foods, spices, and baking ingredients are also stocked.
That covers a lot of the holiday cooking list. Plan some time for the scenery on the way. The drive is part of the fun. Bring a cooler for the trip home.