We Ranked The 10 Best Pizza Places In Florida And Here Is Who Made The Cut
Great pizza rarely announces itself with a fancy sign. Sometimes it hides behind a counter where the slices barely fit on the plate.
Florida has a sneaky talent for dough, and this list proves it. Square pans, thin folds, and tangy sourdough rounds all earned a place here.
Would you eat a slice inside a parked van? Would a birria calzone tempt you after midnight?
Some of these kitchens keep the ovens hot long after most towns go quiet. Others fire their pies in wood ovens that leave a gentle smoky edge.
I love how each stop argues for its own perfect crust. Every owner here clearly has strong opinions about cheese.
How far would you drive for the right slice? Across Florida, the answer might surprise you.
1. Lazy Moon Pizza
Weekend nights in east Orlando don’t wind down early here. On Fridays and Saturdays, the doors stay open until 2:30 in the morning.
That late schedule suits the crowd, which includes college students, groups of friends, and tourists. Slices are giant, so one might be a whole meal.
The menu leans creative. You’ll find the Garden Grazer and Treehugger for vegetable lovers, plus The Buff Pizza for people who want something with a kick.
Calzones get plenty of attention too. Birria Calzone, Hawaiian Calzone, Classic Calzone, and a vegan Veggie Calzone all sit on the list.
That’s a wide lineup for a counter-service spot.
There’s a full vegan menu and a full vegetarian menu, so mixed groups can order without drama. The Down Home Slice is a vegan option that sounds like comfort food on a plate.
Jason’s Mom sauce is one of the house calling cards. It’s a name that makes you want to ask about the story behind it.
The place also works for game time. It’s good for watching sports, and there’s a bar onsite along with free wi-fi.
Outdoor seating is available, and dogs are allowed. Parking is free, with a lot and street spots, so you can skip the circling-the-block routine.
Reservations aren’t accepted, so just show up. Weekend evenings are the busiest stretch, and Sunday mornings are the calmest.
Pick your timing and grab a slice that needs both hands.
Address: 11551 University Blvd, Orlando, FL 32817
2. Santoro’s Pizzeria
A slice that stands up straight is a small miracle. Santoro’s has built its name on a crust with real crunch.
The pizza here is thin and crispy, with flavorful sauce and fresh vegetables on top. Classic and specialty pies share the menu with fries and hearty subs.
Then there’s the Square E-I-E-I-O Meat Lover, a name that sounds like a barnyard sing-along. It’s a square pie, so the corners come with their own appeal.
Sides cover a lot of ground. Garlic knots, mozzarella sticks, zeppoles, and a plain calzone make it easy to build a spread.
Chicken parm and a breakfast sandwich round out the options.
Vegetarians have a full menu to browse. A house salad is vegan, so there’s something green for everyone.
The room is casual and trendy, with counter service and a mix of college students, groups, and visitors. Outdoor seating is there when the Tampa weather behaves.
Hours run from 11 in the morning to 9 at night, stretching to 10 on Fridays and Saturdays. Friday evening is the busiest time.
Dogs are welcome outside. Reservations aren’t taken, so this is a first-come kind of place.
A lunch combo of a cheese slice, a specialty slice, and a drink has been a draw. Ask what’s current when you get to the counter.
Address: 1329 W Cass St, Tampa, FL 33606
3. Pizza Box
Mondays are for rest here, because the doors are closed. The rest of the week, the wood-fired oven gets to work on Central Avenue.
Pizza Box focuses on unique wood-fired pies in a modern, relaxed room. The crust comes out crisp with a lightly smoked flavor.
Toppings lean fresh, and the sauce has a tangy edge. Cheeses are part of the story too.
Kam’s Classic Pizza and the Margherita sit on the menu next to meatballs. Becky’s Dessert Pizza is a sweet way to end the meal, and it’s vegetarian.
The seasonal salad is vegan, and the full vegan menu gives plant-based eaters plenty to choose from. There’s table service, so you can settle in rather than hover at a counter.
Live music is listed among the highlights, and the crowd is family-friendly. The place is also LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safe space.
Curbside pickup and delivery are both offered. Outdoor seating is available, and dogs can join you outside.
Reservations are accepted, which helps on Saturday evening, the busiest time. Parking can be tricky downtown, though free street spots and paid garages and lots are around.
Sunday hours are short, from 3 to 8 in the evening. Plan ahead and you’ll catch the oven at its best.
Address: 923 Central Ave, St. Petersburg, FL 33705
4. Carmines Pie House
Chicago and New York don’t usually share a menu, but they do in Jacksonville. Carmines Pie House runs both styles out of its Riverside spot.
The Chicago Stuffed Pizza Pie is the deep-dish side of things. If you want something lighter, New York Thin Cheese brings a crisp crust and a classic fold.
Calzones get the Chicago treatment too, with a Chicago Baked Calzone on the list. The Boca Raton White Pie Chicago is a creamy-sounding option without red sauce.
Beyond pizza, the menu includes Jumbo Rooster Wings, zucchini fries, and a Greek Islands Salad. Tiramisu is there for dessert, and the place is known for a great one.
Vegans and vegetarians both have full menus. Kids get their own menu, and high chairs are available.
The pub vibe is casual and fun, with a bar onsite. Dine-in, curbside pickup, delivery, and catering are all offered.
Dogs are allowed, including on the outdoor seating. Free parking is available in a lot and on the street.
Sunday, Friday, and Saturday evenings draw the biggest crowds. Weekday mornings are much quieter.
Reservations aren’t accepted, so arrive with a little patience. A table here is worth the short wait, especially if you’re torn between two styles.
Address: 2677 Forbes St, Jacksonville, FL 32204
5. Satchel’s Pizza
Where else can you eat pizza in a van? Satchel’s offers outdoor seating in one, or on an arty patio.
The place is quirky from front to back. A gift shop sits on site, and a vintage 3D viewer is used for the dessert menu.
Artwork by the owner decorates the space, which gives it a funky, visual feel. The vibe is laid-back, and there’s plenty of seating.
Thin-crust pies and calzones are the stars. You can order by the slice or by the pie, with more than 20 toppings to choose from.
The menu lists The Satch-Pan Pizza, a Large 18 Pizza, and a Large Satch Salad. Healthy and organic dishes are part of the offerings.
Both full vegan and full vegetarian menus are available. A bar sits in the back, and live music is a highlight.
Families are welcome here. Kids get their own menu, and the place is good for kids’ birthdays.
Dogs are allowed inside and out. Gender-neutral restrooms are available too.
Plan around the schedule, since it’s closed Sunday and Monday. Friday evening and Saturday afternoon are the busiest times, while Tuesday is calmer.
Reservations aren’t accepted, so it’s first come, first served in this Gainesville original.
Address: 1800 NE 23rd Ave, Gainesville, FL 32609
6. Momo’s Pizza – Market Street
Size matters at this counter. Momo’s sells pizza by the pie or by a huge slice.
Generous is the word for those slices. Fresh ingredients and a flavorful crust make the pies stand out.
A mushroom cap on a slice gets special attention for being hearty and fresh. Fast service keeps the line moving.
The menu includes a meat pizza, a spinach calzone, and bread sticks. Vegan and vegetarian menus are both full, so nobody has to settle.
An extensive beer menu is part of the draw. A bar is onsite, and the setting is easygoing.
College students, families, groups, and tourists all show up. Kids have a menu, and high chairs are available.
Outdoor seating gives you another option. Dogs are allowed outside.
Reservations are accepted, which is handy for bigger groups. Free parking is available, and there’s usually plenty of it.
Hours run from 11 in the morning, with closing times between 9 and 10 at night depending on the day. Friday and Saturday evenings are the busiest.
Located in the Market Street area of Tallahassee, this spot is a solid pick when you want a big slice and no fuss. Bring an appetite.
Address: 1410 Market St Ste C1, Tallahassee, FL 32312
7. Sky’s Pizza Pie
A 24-inch pepperoni pie is a statement. At Sky’s, that big round is a favorite.
The menu focuses on New York-style pizzas and calzones. Counter seating gives the place an easygoing feel.
Beyond pizza, the list includes a Queen B Stromboli, a Pizza Dog, and a City Pie. Lasagna Pie is another curious option.
Wings come two ways, classic or boneless. Hot Knots are vegetarian, and a veggie pizza is on the menu.
Friendly, upbeat staff are part of the draw. The room has spacious seating and a bar.
Both full vegan and full vegetarian menus are available. Kids get their own menu and high chairs.
Outdoor seating is offered, along with delivery and takeout. Draft beer is part of the lineup.
It’s closed on Sundays. The rest of the week, doors open at 11 in the morning.
Friday and Saturday evenings are the busiest times. Parking can be somewhat difficult to find, though a lot and street spots are available.
Reservations aren’t accepted. This Pensacola favorite rewards those who come early.
Address: 5559 N Davis Hwy A, Pensacola, FL 32503
8. DNY Pizzeria
Two big pizza cities meet in Fort Lauderdale. DNY covers Detroit and New York styles under one roof.
That mix is a rare find. Detroit squares and New York slices rarely share a kitchen.
House-made vegan and gluten-free options are a major part of the story. The place offers both a full vegan and a full vegetarian menu.
Garlic knots are on the menu in a vegetarian version. Comfort food is the theme, and quick bites are easy to grab.
The room is casual, and tourists often stop by. Counter service and dine-in are both options, with outdoor seating available.
Catering, curbside pickup, and delivery are offered too. Dogs are allowed outside, and the place is good for kids.
Check the schedule before you go. Monday through Thursday, it opens at 5 in the evening.
Friday and Saturday hours stretch from noon to 1 in the morning. Late-night food is part of the draw.
Sunday runs from noon to 9 in the evening. Parking is easy, with a free lot and plenty of spots.
For people who want a New York-style pie with a plant-based twist, this stop is worth the drive across Broward County.
Address: 3327 E Oakland Park Blvd, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33308
9. Tralia Pizza
Hot honey and sourdough make a sweet, spicy pair. Tralia Pizza builds on that idea in Sarasota.
The kitchen specializes in sourdough-crust and Detroit-style pizzas. The sourdough crust is thin and crisp, with a good crunch.
Detroit options include Detroit Marinara No Cheese and Detroit Spinach and Artichoke. The Detroit style comes with an ample amount of cheese.
The menu goes beyond pizza. Ricotta Meatballs, a Chicken and Burrata Sando, and Veal and Burrata Parm give it an Italian-American spin.
Polenta Fried Chicken adds a twist. Rigatoni and Cacio E Pepe Fries are vegetarian options.
Wings are on the list as well, including a hot honey-mustard style. Brunch is offered too.
A bar sits onsite, and the setting is casual and quiet. Table service and reservations make it easy to plan a night out.
Groups and tourists are a good fit. Kids are welcome too.
Hours run from 11 in the morning, until 10 most nights and 11 on Fridays and Saturdays. Thursday through Saturday evenings are the busiest.
Free parking is available, and there’s usually plenty of room. Delivery and takeout are options when you’d rather stay in.
Address: 6566 Gateway Ave, Sarasota, FL 34231
10. Carmelo’s Pizzeria
Old city, big slice. Carmelo’s sits on W King Street in St. Augustine, serving hearty pies.
The Ortolana pie gets plenty of love. It’s topped with fresh mushrooms, spinach, tomatoes, and large ricotta blobs.
New York-style pizza is the main event. The sauce tastes rich and fresh, and the pepperoni is flavorful.
Carmelo’s Supreme Pizza and a Stuffed Carmelo’s Slice show off the bigger side of the menu. Stromboli, calamari, and mozzarella sticks fill out the list.
Garlic knots and a Greek salad are vegetarian choices. Kids can order spaghetti and marinara.
The room is casual and cozy, with counter service and table service. A bar is onsite, and the place is good for watching sports.
Groups, college students, and tourists all fit right in. Outdoor seating and dogs outside add flexibility.
Hours run from 11 in the morning until 10 most nights, and 11 on Fridays and Saturdays. Friday and Saturday evenings draw the biggest crowds.
Parking can be somewhat difficult to find in this part of town. Free street spots, a free lot, and paid parking are all around.
Reservations aren’t accepted, so be ready to wait on busy nights.
Address: 146 W King St, St. Augustine, FL 32084