This Beloved Ohio Pie Shop Is Worth A Road Trip For Its Homemade Cream Pies And Ever-Changing Flavors

A buckeye pie. A butterscotch meringue.

A French silk pie loaded with Oreos and mint. One small Ohio bakery sells nothing but pie, and the name tells you exactly that.

The case holds fruit pies, cream pies, and seasonal flavors that keep shifting. Then there are savory pot pies you can bake at home for dinner.

Dessert and supper from one counter sounds like a parenting win to me.

I like how focused the whole idea is. No cupcakes, no muffins, no distractions, just crust and filling in many forms.

Pie sizes run small, medium, and large, so a family can try a few without committing to one giant flavor. The tricky part is choosing.

Which one goes home with you first?

A Westerville Bakery That Commits Fully To One Dessert

Some shops hedge their bets with a little of everything. Just Pies Inc goes the other direction and sells, well, pies.

The family-owned bakeshop sits on the north side of the Columbus area in Westerville, Ohio. It’s known as a mom-and-pop outpost for fruit pies, cream pies, and seasonal flavors.

That narrow focus makes a visit easy for families. Kids can scan one case of pies and point, instead of wandering through rows of cookies and breads.

Savory pies share the spotlight too. Pot pies come up often when people talk about this place, which makes it more than a dessert stop.

The shop also sells pies fresh or frozen. That flexibility helps when you’re driving in from Dayton, Cleveland, or Cincinnati and need something that survives the trip home.

Westerville is an easy drive from downtown Columbus, so it fits nicely into a weekend in central Ohio. You can pair a pie run with errands, a park, or a visit with relatives nearby.

Think of it as a specialty shop with a simple promise. Pick a pie, take it home, and argue later about who gets the last slice.

That part is unavoidable.

Roots That Reach Back To North High Street

Long before the Westerville storefront, Just Pies had a location on North High Street in Columbus. Longtime customers have followed the bakery from that spot to its current home.

The North High Street shop later closed. The Westerville location carried on, and some families have been buying pies here for more than a decade.

That kind of staying power says a lot about a small business. Plenty of bakeries come and go, but a pie-only shop that keeps customers across a move has clearly earned trust.

Many fans describe the atmosphere as a throwback. One comparison that pops up is the classic neighborhood bakery many adults remember from childhood.

For parents, that memory angle is half the fun. You get to introduce your kids to the sort of place you might have loved at their age.

The shop stays family-owned, which shows in the friendly service many customers mention. Small details like that matter when you’re herding little ones through a doorway.

History here isn’t about plaques or old photos. It’s about recipes and routines that keep central Ohio families coming back season after season, pie box in hand.

Cream Pies Worth Planning A Whole Saturday Around

Key lime, lemon meringue, butterscotch meringue, peanut butter. The cream pie lineup at Just Pies Inc reads like a greatest-hits list of classic diner desserts.

Key lime gets plenty of attention. One fan who had sampled pies in Key West rated this version just as good or better, praising the tart and creamy balance.

Butterscotch meringue earns its own loyal following. It has been compared to a beloved mom’s homemade version, which is about the highest compliment a pie can receive.

Then comes the Ohio favorite. The buckeye pie blends chocolate and peanut butter, a nod to the state’s famous candy, and some folks even enjoy it semi-frozen.

Specialty pies show up too. A French silk with Oreos and mint has appeared in the case, giving chocolate fans something playful to grab.

Kids who don’t love fruit tend to gravitate toward cream pies. Chocolate and peanut butter usually win over picky eaters in seconds.

Want key lime with whipped topping instead of meringue? That option has been available with an advance order, so plan ahead if your crew has strong opinions.

Fruit Fillings That Shift With The Calendar

Peach, blueberry, rhubarb, triple berry, bumbleberry. Fruit pies make up a huge part of what this bakery does, and the variety keeps things interesting.

Strawberry rhubarb draws curiosity from first-timers. Peach and blueberry also come up often, and one young fan reportedly counts blueberry as her top pick.

Apple crumb has its admirers as well. It’s a dependable choice when you want something familiar after a long Ohio drive.

Seasonal pies rotate through the case, so the lineup can look different from one visit to the next. Some customers notice new options nearly every time they stop in.

Around the holidays, pumpkin and pecan join the party. Many families pick up Thanksgiving pies here, so expect that season to stay busy.

Fruit pies come in fresh or frozen form. A frozen pie can wait in your freezer for a birthday or Sunday dinner later in the month.

A little advice for families: let each kid pick a small fruit pie. You’ll avoid squabbles and turn dessert into a taste test.

Pot Pies That Handle Dinner For You

Dinner and dessert from the same pie shop? That’s a combination tired parents can appreciate.

Just Pies Inc offers a range of savory pies alongside its sweet ones. Chicken, white meat chicken, turkey, beef, vegetarian, and broccoli and cheese have all been part of the lineup.

Many of these pies come frozen, ready to bake at home. One family reported baking a 10-inch beef pie in about 90 minutes plus a short rest, then enjoying a night with no dinner prep.

Heat-and-eat family-size pot pies have also been available. They make a smart grab before a busy week of school, practices, and homework.

Opinions on the savory side vary more than on the sweets. The turkey pot pie gets steady praise, while the chicken version draws mixed reactions about seasoning and filling.

That’s useful to know with picky eaters. Starting with turkey or broccoli and cheese might be the safer bet for skeptical kids.

A small pot pie can feed two adults, so sizing matters. Check the options at the counter and plan portions around your crew.

Small, Medium, Large, And No Sugar Added

Sizing might sound boring, but it’s a big deal here. Just Pies Inc sells small, medium, and large pies, which makes sampling way less stressful.

A small pie is perfect for a couple or a tiny household. Families can grab two or three small ones and let everyone vote on a favorite.

The large pies are built for gatherings. Holiday dinners, church potlucks, and family reunions across Ohio all benefit from one big pie in the middle of the table.

Here’s another helpful touch. The shop has carried a selection of no sugar added pies, which can work for relatives watching their sugar.

Those options let more people at the table join dessert. Grandparents and kids can enjoy pie together without anyone feeling left out.

Because pies come fresh or frozen, you can also mix timing. Eat one tonight and save another for the weekend.

Popular flavors can sell out, so arriving earlier in the day may help. One devoted fan even joked about not wanting to spread the word for exactly that reason.

A Friendly Counter That Feels Like Your Old Neighborhood Bakery

Clean shelves and a tidy case set the tone at this bakery. Many customers describe the store as consistently neat.

Friendly staff come up again and again too. That matters when you’ve got kids pressing noses to the glass and asking about every flavor.

The space is more grab-and-go than sit-down. Plan to pick your pies and head off to a park, a picnic, or home.

Pi Day on March 14 brings a special kind of buzz. Lines have formed that day, with staff assembling specialty pies to keep up.

Holiday seasons can also get busy in central Ohio. Thanksgiving week is a pie shop’s big moment, so plan ahead if you need one then.

Kids usually love a store with one clear mission. Choosing between buckeye and blueberry feels like a real decision to a seven-year-old.

Grandparents tend to enjoy it too. Butterscotch meringue and lemon meringue feel like old-fashioned treats that span generations easily.

It’s a cozy, focused stop that suits families, couples, and anyone trying to win the next potluck.

Hours, Parking, And Getting There Without A Hitch

Mark your calendar first. Just Pies Inc is open Tuesday through Saturday from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., and it’s closed Sunday and Monday.

Hours can change around holidays or seasonally, so double-check before a long drive. Showing up on a Monday with hungry kids would be a rough surprise.

You’ll find the bakery at 736 Northfield Rd #1, Westerville, OH 43082. The spot sits north of Columbus, an easy hop for central Ohio families.

Parking sits right out front, which keeps things simple with strollers or car seats. The location is described as easy to reach.

From downtown Columbus, the drive usually takes around 20 to 25 minutes depending on traffic. Families coming from Dayton or Mansfield can make a comfortable day trip of it.

A cooler bag is a smart move for frozen pies. Ohio summer heat won’t do a cream pie any favors in the back seat.

Prices vary by size and flavor, so check at the counter. Arriving in the morning gives you the best shot at popular flavors before they sell out.

Why A Pie-Only Stop Earns A Spot On Your Ohio Itinerary

Simple wins sometimes. Just Pies Inc proves that one thing done with care can carry a whole bakery for years.

Families get plenty to work with here. Cream pies, fruit pies, seasonal flavors, and take-home pot pies cover dessert and dinner in one stop.

Flexible sizes and frozen options make it practical. You can taste-test small pies or stock the freezer for a busy Ohio week.

The savory side draws mixed opinions, especially the chicken pot pie. Sweet pies, particularly cream flavors like buckeye and key lime, seem to be the safest bet.

I can’t imagine a better excuse for a weekend drive to Westerville. Grab a pie, find a park, and hand out forks.

Timing helps, so aim for a weekday or Saturday morning. Remember the shop stays closed Sundays and Mondays.

Bring a cooler and a short list of flavors to try. Then leave room to change your mind once you see the case.

In the end, this little bakery feels like a gift to Ohio pie lovers. Your only real problem is picking just one.