These 16 Pie Shops In Tennessee Make You Feel Like You’re At Grandma’s House

I love the quiet joy of biting into a slice of pie that tastes like it came from my grandmother’s kitchen, and Tennessee has a wealth of spots that deliver that cozy comfort. Join me as I wander through small towns and city corners, chasing flaky crusts, cinnamon whispers, and the kind of filling that makes you close your eyes.

Each place on this list felt like a visit to someone’s warm, welcoming house, and I can’t wait to tell you which pies made me sigh with satisfaction.

1. Lynnville Fried Pie Company

Opening a paper bag from Lynnville Fried Pie Company is like finding a handwritten note in an old recipe box – unexpected and warm. Their fried pies are golden pockets of nostalgia that crack gently when you bite, releasing steam and fruit that tastes bright and true.

I always tell friends to try the berry mix first, because it balances sweetness with a hint of tartness that feels like summer on the porch.

The shop sits at 121 Mill St, Lynnville, TN 38472, and the building’s simplicity makes the pies the star. Service is friendly and casual, the kind where you chat about flavors and leave with a dozen because resistance is futile.

Expect a short line on weekends and a happy grin when you take your first bite.

2. Pie Sensations

The aroma that hits you walking into Pie Sensations feels like the kitchen of an aunt who always keeps desserts ready. Their pies are robust and generous with filling, and the crust has a satisfying balance of tender and flaky that crumbles just enough to leave buttery specks on your chin.

I recommend the coconut cream slice for its lush texture and the way toasted coconut lifts each forkful into something decadent without being cloying.

This charming bakery is located at 26 Public Square, Columbia, TN 38401, where the downtown bustle makes grabbing a pie a delightful ritual. The staff is unhurried and proud of the recipes, and you can watch pie assembly through the window on slower afternoons.

Bring company or a big appetite; these pies beg to be shared.

3. Pie R Square

Pie R Square has that energetic, community-minded vibe where locals pop in for coffee and a slice while catching up on neighborhood news. Their pies have a homey heft and a comforting depth of flavor, like a well-told family story passed down over Sunday supper.

I gravitate toward their seasonal fruit pies, where each bite highlights the fruit rather than masking it with too much sugar.

You can find this spot at 4403 Dayton Blvd, Red Bank, TN 37415, tucked into a friendly commercial strip. The counter service is quick and conversational, perfect for a midday treat.

If you time it right, you might snag a fresh-from-the-oven piece and watch the filling still shimmer as it cools.

4. The Original World Famous Pie Lady

Walking into The Original World Famous Pie Lady, you feel the theatrical pride of someone who has perfected a craft and loves to share it. The pies have a straightforward charm – honest fillings, dependable crusts, and an unpretentious sweetness that keeps people coming back.

I always find the pecan pie irresistible for its rich, nutty depth and well-balanced caramel notes that don’t overwhelm the palate.

The shop is located at 426 E Main St, Jackson, TN 38301, a classic downtown address where the pie counter often hums with loyal customers. Expect warm banter while you pick out a slice, and don’t be surprised if you leave with more than you planned; these pies are the sort you regret not buying later.

5. Katie Pie And Sons Country Kitchen

Katie Pie and Sons Country Kitchen serves pies that feel like a Sunday afternoon at your grandmother’s table, complete with the kind of buttery crust that practically begs for a second helping. The emphasis here is comfort: generous fillings, classic recipes, and a welcoming environment that invites lingering over coffee.

I often recommend the banana cream because it hits the sweet spot between smooth custard and ripe banana brightness.

You’ll find this homestyle refuge at 2407 Pulaski Hwy, Columbia, TN 38401, where the aroma of baked goods drifts into the parking area. Staff treat regulars like family, and pies are rotated often to showcase seasonal goods.

It’s the perfect stop after a long drive or a little detour for dessert lovers.

6. Gluten Free Goose, A Bakery

Gluten Free Goose surprised me with pies that prove gluten-free doesn’t mean flavor-free or texture-poor. Their crusts have surprising flakiness and the fillings are rich enough to satisfy even picky pie purists.

I always advise trying a fruit pie to see how they coax tang and sweetness out of fresh ingredients while keeping the structure intact.

This Nashville spot is located at 6601 Sugar Valley Dr #115, Nashville, TN 37211, and it’s a haven for those avoiding gluten but not dessert. The staff are knowledgeable about dietary needs, and the cozy seating makes it easy to linger over tea.

Expect thoughtful ingredient choices and a selection that rotates with seasonal produce.

7. The Three Mothers Cuisine & Bakery

The Three Mothers Cuisine & Bakery blends savory and sweet traditions into pies with personality and generosity. Their pies lean toward hearty, filled-to-the-brim slices that recall communal family meals and neighborhood potlucks.

I often pick a fruit pie to appreciate how their fillings maintain structure without being overly dense, so each forkful feels balanced and comforting.

Located at 1002 Memorial Blvd, Murfreesboro, TN 37129, this bakery sits amid a bustling stretch of shops and eateries. Servers are unhurried and attentive, and the display case often features rotating daily specials.

If you’re passing through town, treating yourself here feels like a small celebratory stop.

8. Merridee’s Breadbasket

Merridee’s Breadbasket is a beloved spot where pies feel artisanal yet comfortably familiar, like a family recipe refined by practice. Their crusts are expertly layered and the fillings use high-quality ingredients that sing without masking subtleties.

I find their seasonal fruit pies particularly memorable because each one highlights the fruit’s natural character, balanced with just enough sweetness to feel indulgent but not cloying.

This Franklin bakery is at 110 4th Ave S, Franklin, TN 37064, in a charming downtown that encourages slow wandering. The cafe has a relaxed atmosphere and friendly staff who seem genuinely proud of their work.

If you want a pie to pair with coffee and conversation, this is a reliable, delicious choice.

9. Julia’s Homestyle Bakery

Julia’s Homestyle Bakery lives up to its name with pies that embrace simplicity and heart, the kind that remind you of a family kitchen table. Their pies are straightforward and honest, with crusts that have a little crumble and fillings that taste like they were stirred with care.

I always recommend sampling a cream pie to appreciate the smooth textures and comforting sweetness that feel like dessert hugs.

Find Julia’s at 1911 Medical Center Pkwy B, Murfreesboro, TN 37129, where the modest storefront hides reliably excellent baked goods. The staff are warm and efficient, and it’s common to see locals picking up pies for celebrations.

It’s exactly the kind of place that makes you smile when you walk out with a box.

10. Simply Pure Sweets

Simply Pure Sweets has a light, friendly approach to pies where presentation and flavor both get thoughtful attention. Their pies often showcase bright fruit and clean flavors that taste fresh rather than heavy, and the crusts have a tender flake that complements without overpowering.

I find their lemon and custard styles especially approachable for those who prefer a fresher, less saccharine dessert.

Located at 128 N Church St, Murfreesboro, TN 37130, this spot fits neatly into the downtown rhythm and makes a lovely stop after wandering the square. Staff members are helpful with pairings and portion suggestions, and the small storefront encourages takeaway or a quick counter seat.

It’s a pleasant find for a lighter slice of pie.

11. Baked on 8th

Baked on 8th delivers pies that are both creative and rooted in comfort, offering a mix of classic favorites and modern twists that still feel familiar. Their crust work is dependable and fillings are thoughtfully balanced, making each slice satisfying without being overly rich.

I especially appreciate their seasonal rotations, which highlight local produce and inventive flavor combos that keep me curious on repeat visits.

The bakery sits at 1512 8th Ave S, Nashville, TN 37203, in a lively neighborhood perfect for a pastry crawl. Service is friendly and efficient, and the display of pies often tempts with new limited-time offerings.

It’s a great stop if you want artisanal pies with personality and steady comfort.

12. Oflow

Oflow offers pies that feel contemporary yet warmly familiar, with an eye for texture and seasonal ingredients that elevate simple recipes. Their approach often includes subtle twists that don’t distract from the core pleasure of a good pie, and the balance of filling-to-crust usually lands just right.

I often order a slice that pairs bright fruit with a buttery crust because the contrast highlights both elements beautifully.

Located at 115 N Maple St, Murfreesboro, TN 37130, Oflow is a neat addition to local dessert options and serves a clientele that appreciates thoughtful baking. Expect clean presentation, efficient service, and a case that rotates with fresh ideas.

It’s a satisfying stop for curious palates seeking comfort with nuance.

13. The Grey Flower Deli

The Grey Flower Deli surprises with pies that feel crafted with deli-level attention to ingredient pairing and balance. While known for savory options, their sweet pies hold their own, bringing a restrained sweetness and thoughtful textures to the table.

I like that their pies don’t try to compete with bold flavors; instead they complement the deli’s inviting menu and make a satisfying finale to a hearty lunch.

This deli-bakery is found at 10849 London Ln, Apison, TN 37302, where the charming local vibe encourages relaxed meals and lingering bites. Staff are friendly and you can often find daily specials that include pie slices.

It’s a delightful hybrid of savory and sweet that feels like a neighbor’s recommendation come to life.

14. HomeStyle Bakery

HomeStyle Bakery lives up to its name with pies that feel like they were baked in a familiar kitchen, right down to the comforting aroma that greets you at the door. Their crusts are sturdy yet tender, and fillings are generous without being overly sweet, so each bite feels genuinely comforting.

I typically choose a classic fruit pie here because the flavors are straightforward, honest, and deeply satisfying.

You can visit at 2709 Murfreesboro Pike, Antioch, TN 37013, a practical location that draws regulars and visitors alike. The staff treat customers like neighbors and packaging is simple and reliable for take-home indulgence.

If you’re craving a pie that reads like a memory, this place often hits that sweet spot.

15. Chattanooga Bakery Inc

Chattanooga Bakery Inc is famous for breads and pies that feel rooted in long-standing culinary tradition, and there’s a pride in their reliably hearty approach. Their pies have a satisfying weight and depth, with fillings that are rich and flavors that linger pleasantly.

I recommend trying a signature variety so you can taste the bakery’s well-honed sense of balance and texture in one memorable slice.

The facility is located at 900 Manufacturers Rd #101, Chattanooga, TN 37405, and has a reputation that extends around the region. Expect a bustling, efficient environment and friendly staff who know their customer favorites.

It’s a solid stop for classic pies that aim to please and comfort in equal measure.

16. Magpies Bakery

Magpies Bakery in Knoxville has a devoted following for good reason – their pies combine excellent technique with bold, bright flavors that still feel friendly. The crusts are flaky and the fillings are often fruit-forward, letting quality ingredients shine.

I tend to pick a seasonal fruit pie to enjoy how they highlight freshness alongside skilled pastry work.

You’ll find Magpies at 1201 N Central St, Knoxville, TN 37917, in a neighborhood that values artisanal baking. The staff are earnest and enthusiastic, and their display case is tempting on any visit.

If you want a pie that pairs craft baking with nostalgic comfort, this place consistently delivers.