The Tennessee Pie Shop Where Every Bite Feels Like It Came Right Out Of Grandma’s Kitchen

Every bite of pie feels like a warm hug straight from grandma’s kitchen. The sweet aroma of fresh-baked pastries fills the air, instantly sparking memories of homemade desserts and cozy family moments.

Flaky, buttery crusts cradle rich, flavorful fillings that range from classic chocolate cream and coconut to seasonal specials that surprise and delight. The welcoming atmosphere invites guests to linger, sip a cup of coffee, and savor every mouthful.

Attentive staff add a personal touch, making each visit feel special and memorable. At Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Tennessee, traditional baking meets comfort and nostalgia, creating an experience where every bite delights both the palate and the heart.

A Cozy Little Shop With A Lot Of Heart

Pulling up to Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop on Kingston Pike, the first thing visitors notice is how unpretentious the whole place feels. The shop sits at 5400 Kingston Pike, Knoxville, TN 37919, and from the outside, it looks like exactly what it is – a neighborhood pie shop that takes its craft seriously without making a big show of it.

The space inside is compact and tidy, with a display case that tends to hold a rotating selection of pies in both personal and full sizes. There is no eat-in seating, so visits are typically quick and focused on choosing what to take home.

That simplicity actually adds to the charm – walking in, picking a pie, and walking out with something genuinely good in hand feels refreshing.

Customers have described the staff as friendly and helpful, which matches the overall vibe of a place that values its regulars. For anyone new to the shop, arriving a few minutes before a busy weekend afternoon could make the experience smoother and more relaxed.

The I-40 Pie That Keeps People Coming Back

Among the most talked-about items on the menu, the I-40 Pie has developed something close to a fan base. Named with a nod to the interstate that runs through Tennessee, this pie layers pecan, coconut, and chocolate chips into a filling that reviewers consistently describe as rich and satisfying.

Multiple customers have singled it out as a must-try, with one reviewer calling it their top pick and another recommending it paired with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. The combination of textures – chewy coconut, crunchy pecans, and pockets of chocolate – gives each bite a lot to work with without feeling overdone.

Opinions on the crust vary across reviews, as they tend to with any pie shop, but many visitors have praised its texture and flavor. For first-time visitors unsure where to start, the I-40 Pie is a reasonable and well-supported choice based on the volume of positive feedback it consistently receives from both local regulars and out-of-town guests passing through Knoxville.

Granny’s Apple Pie And The Comfort It Carries

Apple pie is one of those desserts that carries a lot of expectation, and Granny’s Apple Pie at Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop manages to hold its own. Several reviewers have mentioned it as a standout, with one noting it was quite good on a first visit and another including it among their personal favorites after trying nearly every option the shop offers.

The name alone signals what the shop is going for, something that feels tied to home cooking rather than commercial baking. Whether or not every batch hits the same notes can vary, as with any made-to-order product, but the general reception from customers has been warm and consistent enough to trust.

Granny’s Apple is available in both personal and larger sizes, which makes it a flexible option depending on whether someone is treating themselves or bringing something to share. Ordering in advance, as one reviewer suggested, tends to make the pickup process smoother, especially during busier times like weekends or around holidays when demand at the shop picks up noticeably.

Peanut Butter Cream Pie For The Devoted Sweet Tooth

There is something quietly addictive about a well-made peanut butter cream pie, and more than one reviewer at Buttermilk Sky has used the word obsessed when describing this particular offering. One customer put it plainly, calling the peanut butter pie a ten out of ten and joking that it could be a bad thing for anyone with a serious sweet tooth.

The filling tends toward creamy and smooth, making it a good contrast to the crunchier or fruitier options on the menu. For people who love the combination of rich, nutty flavor and a tender pie crust, this one tends to deliver on that expectation based on the feedback shared across multiple reviews.

The shop also offers gluten-friendly options, which has made it accessible to a broader range of customers who might otherwise have to skip dessert entirely. Peanut butter cream is one of the flavors that has appeared in positive mentions from both longtime fans and newer visitors, suggesting it holds up well as a reliable favorite worth returning for on repeat visits to the Kingston Pike location.

Key Lime Pie That Hits A Bright, Refreshing Note

Key lime pie tends to be polarizing – some versions are too sweet, others too tart, and very few land exactly where they should. Based on customer reviews, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop’s version leans toward refreshing and soft, which has earned it genuine praise from visitors who tried it for the first time and came away impressed.

One reviewer described the key lime as the best they had experienced and noted it was topped with a special lime whipped cream that added a finishing touch worth mentioning. Another called it refreshing and soft, suggesting the texture is lighter than some of the richer cream-based options on the menu.

The shop carries this flavor in its personal pie size, making it easy to try without committing to a full pie. For anyone who enjoys citrus desserts or wants something that feels a little less heavy after a big meal, the key lime is a well-reviewed pick that has shown up in multiple positive mentions across different customer experiences at this Knoxville location.

Nanny’s Pecan Pie And Its Loyal Following

Pecan pie has deep roots in Southern baking, and Buttermilk Sky’s version, called Nanny’s Pecan Pie, carries that tradition forward in a shop that clearly values the classics. It has been mentioned by name in several reviews, with one longtime customer listing it among their top favorites alongside the I-40 and peanut butter cream varieties.

Opinions on pecan pies often come down to the ratio of nuts to filling, and that preference is personal. Some customers love a pie where the pecans dominate, while others prefer a more balanced filling-to-nut ratio.

Reviews suggest Nanny’s Pecan leans toward a filling-forward style, which is worth knowing before ordering if texture preferences run strong.

The shop also carries a version with added chocolate chips, which the I-40 Pie incorporates as well, so fans of that combination have options. Nanny’s Pecan has remained a consistent presence on the menu and continues to appear in positive mentions from customers who return to this Tennessee location specifically to pick it up again, which says something about its staying power.

Mini Pies And The Four-Pack Experience

One of the more practical and fun ways to experience Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is through the four-pack of mini pies. Rather than committing to a single flavor, the four-pack lets visitors sample different varieties in one visit, which several reviewers have appreciated as a smart way to explore the menu without overcommitting to one choice.

Personal-sized pies have been priced around $5.25 each based on past customer mentions, though pricing can vary and checking directly with the shop or their website at buttermilkskypie.com is the most reliable approach. The four-pack has been described as reasonably priced given what the shop offers, and multiple customers have mentioned it as a good value for trying something new.

Flavors like Granny’s Apple, Coconut Cream, Peanut Butter Cream, and Chewy Chocolate Chip have all appeared in four-pack orders mentioned in reviews. The mini size also makes these pies easy to share or bring to a small gathering, and they travel reasonably well for anyone picking them up on the way to a get-together or family visit.

Hours, Ordering Tips, And When To Visit

Planning a visit to Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop works best with a little preparation. The shop is open Monday through Thursday from 10 AM to 6 PM, with extended hours on Friday and Saturday running until 7 PM.

The location at 5400 Kingston Pike is closed on Sundays, so timing a weekend visit means Saturday is the last opportunity before the next week begins.

Several reviewers have noted that ordering in advance makes the pickup process noticeably smoother, particularly for larger orders or specialty items. Calling ahead at 865-330-3694 or checking the website at buttermilkskypie.com for online ordering options could help avoid any surprises on arrival, especially if visiting during a busy afternoon or around a holiday.

Third-party delivery is also available for those who prefer not to make the trip in person, though picking up directly tends to give the freshest experience. Arriving earlier in the day rather than close to closing time could mean a wider selection of available flavors, since popular options like the I-40 and peanut butter cream may sell out before the end of the business day on busier weekends.

What Real Customers Say About The Experience

Customer reviews for Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop paint a picture that is mostly warm and genuine, with a 4.5-star rating across 329 reviews reflecting a broad base of satisfied visitors. Positive mentions consistently highlight the friendly staff, the variety of flavors, and the overall comfort of stopping in for something homemade-tasting and satisfying.

A few reviewers have shared less enthusiastic experiences, pointing to concerns about specific flavors, crust texture, or customer service interactions on particular visits. Those perspectives are worth acknowledging because no shop is perfect every single day, and honest feedback helps set realistic expectations for new visitors who want to know what they might encounter.

What stands out across the majority of reviews is a sense that the shop genuinely tries to deliver something special rather than just functional. Customers who have moved to the area, visited for birthdays, or simply wandered in on a craving have all found something worth mentioning.

For most people, a stop at this location turns into a return visit and that kind of repeat loyalty tends to speak louder than any single review.