We Ranked The 9 Top Amish Markets In Wisconsin And Here Are The Winners
Two of the bakeries on my list open their doors only on Fridays and Saturdays. Miss that tiny window, and the pecan rolls and fry pies sit out of reach for five long days. I love that kind of schedule. It turns a simple grocery run into a small, delicious mission with a deadline.
One store here takes cash only, while another can refill your propane tank as you grab groceries.
Wisconsin’s Amish and Amish-style markets range from quiet country stores to shops operating right on working farmsteads. Their shelves hold bulk flour, dried pasta, homemade bread, kitchen knives, fabric, and even sheds.
So I ranked nine favorites by selection, baking, and the sheer fun of the drive along those buggy-friendly backroads. Which would you visit first: a bakery with a weekend-only rush, or a country store stocking work gloves right next to the oats?
1. Mishler’s Country Store
Buggy wheels and backroads lead to the number one spot, and the reward is a pantry lover’s dream. This Amish-run store near Dalton packs its shelves with bulk items and baking supplies.
You’ll find spices, baking products, dried pastas, and some produce under one roof. Grains, nuts, oats, flour, sugar, and dried fruits round out the bulk section nicely. Cheese fans get a treat here too. Look for local cheeses, including sharp cheddars and creamy spreads that beg for a cracker.
The fun doesn’t stop at food. Shelves also carry oil lamps, doilies, cookbooks, kitchen utensils, candy, toys, and gifts, so bring a list and expect to ignore it.
Homemade jams, canned goods, and fresh-baked treats make it easy to fill a basket fast. If you bake at home, wheat berries are a fun find you won’t spot at most supermarkets.
The store sits inside the Kingston and Dalton Amish settlement, which dates back to 1977. That long history shows in the store’s simple, practical layout and country setting.
Plan your trip around the calendar. It opens Monday through Wednesday plus Friday and Saturday, and it stays closed Thursday and Sunday.
Weekdays early in the week tend to run quieter, while Friday and Saturday bring the bigger crowds. Bring cash or a check, since those are the preferred ways to pay.
Address: W5115 Barry Rd, Dalton, WI 53926
2. Scenic View Bulk Foods
The name makes a bold promise, and the rolling hills around Cashton happily keep it. Getting to this Amish-style bulk food store is half the fun.
Irish Ridge Road winds through the Driftless region, an area famous for its steep valleys and farm-dotted ridges. Pack some patience and enjoy the slow, curvy drive.
Inside, the shelves focus on pantry staples. You’ll see bulk goods, baking supplies, snacks, candies, and dried goods ready for your cupboard.
Then there’s the bakery, and that’s where things get sweet. Open on Fridays and Saturdays, it offers baked treats alongside the store’s bulk-food selection.
Good prices on bulk goods make this a smart stop for stocking up. Grab a fried pie for the road, and maybe a second one for later.
The store belongs to the Cashton Amish settlement, which started in the 1960s. It’s part of the largest Amish community in Wisconsin, which gives the whole area a special feel.
Check the store’s hours before you go, especially if you’re visiting for baked goods. The bakery operates on Fridays and Saturdays, so plan accordingly.
Thursday and Sunday are closed days, so don’t plan your trip around those. Saturdays bring the biggest crowds, and early weekdays stay calmer. A restroom is available on site, which helps after a long country drive. This is a quick stop, but it’s an easy one to love.
Address: E11817 Irish Ridge Rd, Cashton, WI 54619
3. Yoder’s Country Market
Need flour, fabric, and a propane refill in one stop? This newer market outside Wautoma opened in 2024 and covers a surprising amount of ground. The store is clean, modern, and fully stocked. Bulk foods and essential groceries fill the shelves, and the produce gets high marks too.
Here’s where it gets fun. Variety items include footwear, gloves, fabrics, kitchen supplies, T-shirts, hats, toys, and plenty of knickknacks.
That mix makes it feel like a general store with a fresh coat of paint. You could restock your pantry and find a birthday gift without leaving the building. Propane refill service is a handy bonus for campers and grillers. It’s the kind of practical touch that makes a country trip easier.
Shoppers come from the neighboring Amish community and many surrounding counties. Adams, Portage, Waupaca, Marquette, Winnebago, and Green Lake folks all make the trip.
Hours run longer than you might expect. It’s open 8 AM to 5 PM Monday through Thursday, until 7 PM Friday, and 8 AM to 4 PM Saturday. Friday evenings are a sneaky smart time to visit, since they tend to stay quiet. Saturdays draw the biggest crowds, and Sundays are closed.
There’s a free parking lot and a restroom on site. Both make this an easy stop if you’re touring central Wisconsin.
Address: N1208 County Rd II, Wautoma, WI 54982
4. Pleasant View Bakery
Two days a week, the ovens in this little Dalton bakery get their big moment. Friday and Saturday are the only days you can shop here, so plan accordingly. The selection makes the short schedule worth it. Expect fresh homemade bread, donuts, pretzels, pies, cookies, and cinnamon rolls.
Pecan rolls are a menu highlight, and they’re worth putting at the top of your list. Turnovers and fry pies also earn plenty of love. Pie lovers get a real choice here. The bakery offers a large selection of pies and breads, so you might need a second bag.
Homemade jams, pickles, and preserves sit alongside the baked goods. Grab a jar to pair with a fresh loaf for an easy breakfast at home. The setting matches the food. It’s a quaint, peaceful bakery surrounded by rolling farmland in Green Lake County’s Amish country.
Saturday mornings tend to be the busiest stretch. If you’d rather skip the rush, Friday afternoon usually runs quieter. A line can form, but it moves toward fresh treats, so nobody’s complaining much. Coffee is offered too, which helps while you wait.
This is takeout only, with no dine-in seating. Bring cash, since that’s the preferred way to pay. It’s part of the Kingston and Dalton Amish settlement, founded in 1977. Pair it with a stop at Mishler’s for a full Dalton day.
Address: N9541 Kiefer Rd, Dalton, WI 53926
5. Lark Country Store
Rada cutlery, baby items, and bulk spices all share an address on one Shawano County farmstead. That’s quite a lineup for a store on a quiet backroad.
This Amish shop calls itself a one-stop destination, and the list backs it up. Bulk foods, bulk spices, and grocery essentials form the core. Then the variety section takes over. You’ll find books and cards, baby items, kitchenware, gloves, socks, and plenty more.
Rada cutlery is a fun find for home cooks. Those knives have a loyal fan base, and seeing them on a farmstead shelf feels a little unexpected.
Interesting Amish items mix in with the dry goods and housewares. Give yourself time to wander, because small treasures hide in the corners. Customers travel from across Wisconsin and beyond to shop here. The open-country setting is a big part of the charm.
The hours are friendly for weekday trips. It’s open 8 AM to 5 PM Monday through Friday and 8 AM to 4:30 PM on Saturday. Saturdays bring the most shoppers, while weekday mornings stay calm. Sundays are closed, so save the Sunday drive for scenery only.
A restroom is available, which is great news after a long country ride. Most visits here are quick, unless the spice aisle pulls you in. Bring a cooler bag if you’re stocking up for a while. Bulk buying makes it easy to fill the trunk.
Address: W5431 Lark Rd, Shawano, WI 54166
6. Oven Fresh Bakery
Free cookie samples might be the friendliest welcome in Wisconsin baking. This small Amish-run bakery near Markesan makes a strong first impression.
Everything here leans homemade and from scratch. Glazed and bismark doughnuts, cinnamon rolls, and pecan rolls lead the sweet side. Bread, pies, and fried pies fill out the shelves nicely. Pecan pie and toffee add a little extra temptation if your willpower is low.
Prices are a big reason people keep coming back. The value on scratch-made goods here is hard to beat. The staff is known for being friendly and helpful. That makes it easy to ask what’s fresh or which treat to try first.
Timing matters, so mark your calendar. The bakery opens only Friday and Saturday from 8 AM to 4:30 PM. Monday through Thursday and Sunday are closed days. If you want the best pick of doughnuts, earlier in the day is a smart move.
Coffee is available, which pairs nicely with a warm cinnamon roll in the car. This is takeout only, with no seating inside. The bakery sits in the quiet countryside around Markesan, a small farming community. A free parking lot makes the stop simple.
Bismark doughnuts are filled treats, so grab napkins before you take a bite. Your car seats will thank you.
Address: W3699 Heritage Rd, Markesan, WI 53946
7. Hillpoint Country Store (Amish Discount Grocery)
Groceries on one side, sheds out front, and a cash register that only speaks cash. This Hill Point store definitely keeps things interesting. It’s a family-owned discount grocery with bulk foods and seasonal produce. Liquidated and near-date groceries help keep prices low.
Bargain hunters, this one’s for you. Stock changes over time, so each visit can turn up something new. Bulk pantry items cover the basics for home cooks and bakers. Seasonal produce adds fresh color depending on the time of year.
Baked goods show up here as well, including cherry pie. Snag one if you spot it, because pie and bargains make a great team. And yes, the sheds are real. A selection of sheds sits alongside the grocery business, which might be the most surprising combo on this list.
Remember your cash, since this Amish-run store doesn’t take cards. A quick ATM stop before you arrive saves a lot of frustration.
The store sits along State Highway 130 in tiny Hill Point, an unincorporated community in Sauk County. It’s part of the Loganville and Hill Point settlement, founded in 1988.
Hours run 8 AM to 5 PM Monday through Saturday. Sundays are closed. Saturdays bring the biggest crowds. Monday and Thursday mornings tend to be the quietest windows for relaxed browsing.
Address: S6547 WI-130, Hill Point, WI 53937
8. Cranberry Country Market
Cranberry marshes and timber surround this stop, so the name fits like a glove. Cranberry Country Market sits along Highway 173 outside Tomah.
It’s a specialty grocery with a big focus on baking. Bulk baking supplies make it a handy stop for anyone who loves to bake from scratch.
Hungry right now? The deli serves fresh sandwiches, which solves the lunch question on a long road trip. A wide variety of Amish goods fills the store at reasonable prices. Produce gets strong praise, and flowers add a cheerful touch.
That mix gives the market a little something for different kinds of shoppers. Bakers, sandwich fans, and gift seekers can all leave happy. The location is part of the appeal. Monroe County’s cranberry country makes for a pleasant drive, especially when the marshes come into view.
Hours here are generous. It’s open 9 AM to 6 PM on weekdays and 9 AM to 4 PM on Saturday. Evenings during the week tend to be calm, which is perfect for after-work browsing. Saturdays get the busiest, and Sundays are closed.
On-site parking and a restroom make it an easy pit stop. It’s a smart place to break up a drive through western Wisconsin. Grab a sandwich, a bag of baking supplies, and maybe some flowers. That’s a pretty great haul for one quick stop.
Address: 9941 WI-173, Tomah, WI 54660
9. Amish House
Sunday shoppers, rejoice, because this Westfield market opens seven days a week. That alone makes it a rare find on this list. Shelves here brim with bulk Amish and gourmet foods. Candies, nuts, snacks, baking supplies, and health foods cover a lot of ground.
The deli brings cheese and sausage to the party. Ice cream is on hand too, which makes a hot summer stop much sweeter.
Coffee fans get a fun perk. The on-site cafe lets you taste coffee before you buy a bag. Honey and sorghum line up next to homemade jams, pickles, and preserves. Fresh bread and cinnamon rolls round out the pantry picks.
Then the shopping branches out. Handcrafted furniture, gardening supplies, outdoor decor, candles, and kitchen items fill the rest of the store. Seasonal produce shows up when the time is right. It’s worth checking what’s fresh whenever you visit.
Hours run 8 AM to 7 PM daily. Weekends draw the biggest crowds, while Tuesday and Wednesday tend to stay quiet. Free Wi-Fi and a restroom add some easy comfort. Westfield is a small village in Marquette County, and the market has a friendly, country-store feel.
This is a great final stop on a Wisconsin Amish market tour. Grab a coffee, pick a candle, and maybe leave room for ice cream.
Address: 217 N Pioneer Park Rd, Westfield, WI 53964