This Family-Owned Hoagie Shop In Ohio Has Been Worth The Drive For 47 Years
One sandwich here is called the Franken-Hoagie. It stacks salami, ham, turkey, roast beef, and provolone, then piles on banana peppers, onions, olive oil, and oregano.
That name alone made me smile. Then I learned this little Ohio sub shop has been feeding people for 47 years.
It also keeps a display case full of gifts that visitors have brought in over the decades.
I like places that collect stories along with sandwich orders. This one has an old 8-track on display and even a picture of Captain Kangaroo.
It feels like a family scrapbook that happens to serve lunch.
I can’t imagine a better kind of road-trip stop for families. You get big sandwiches, friendly faces, and plenty to look at while you wait.
So what else is hiding behind that counter?
A North Columbus Sub Shop With Nearly Five Decades Behind The Counter
Yogis Hoagies sits along a busy stretch of Morse Road on the north side of Columbus, Ohio. It’s a small, family-owned spot that has been making subs for 47 years.
The focus is right there in the name. Hoagies lead the menu, but you’ll also find pizza, pasta, and daily specials.
Families on the move will appreciate how simple the whole setup feels. You walk up, order at the counter, and grab a table or take your food to go.
The shop sits only a few minutes from Interstate 71. That makes it an easy detour when you’re passing through Columbus with hungry kids in the back seat.
One traveler even ended up here after a flat tire on I-71. Talk about turning a bad day into a good lunch.
Columbus has no shortage of sandwich options, of course. Still, few of them can point to nearly half a century of practice slicing meats and stacking buns.
That kind of staying power usually means something is going right. In this case, it seems to be a mix of generous sandwiches and genuinely friendly people behind the counter.
New Hands Carrying On An Old Family Tradition
Ownership changed a couple of years ago, and the transition stayed close to home. Alycia, who had worked at the shop for about two years, took over the business.
That kind of handoff matters in a place like this. Someone who already knows the regulars, the recipes, and the rhythm of the lunch rush can keep things steady.
The Yogis name also stretches back further than this one storefront. There was once a Westerville location, and some longtime fans still remember it fondly.
Family-run spots tend to carry a certain feeling. You notice it in small moments, like staff greeting people as soon as they come through the door.
Friendly service comes up again and again when people talk about Yogis Hoagies. Several folks describe the place as feeling like their own family’s restaurant.
For parents, that matters more than fancy decor. Kids relax when the adults around them are warm and patient.
One first-timer had a staff member step out from behind the counter to explain the subs. That’s the kind of help that makes ordering with picky eaters a lot less stressful.
Meet The Monster Sandwich Called The Franken-Hoagie
Five layers of meat and cheese is a lot to fit in one bun. The Franken-Hoagie handles it anyway, like a sandwich with something to prove.
Inside you’ll find salami, ham, turkey, roast beef, and provolone. Then come tomatoes, banana peppers, onions, olive oil, and oregano to finish it off.
It’s billed as a monster hoagie, and the name fits. This is the order for the biggest appetite in your car.
The olive oil and oregano give it that classic Italian sub flavor. Banana peppers add a little tang without taking over.
For families, a sandwich this size can be a smart move. Splitting one among a couple of kids could stretch your lunch budget a bit further.
Of course, little ones may want to pick off the onions or peppers. Luckily, a counter-service sub shop usually makes that kind of tweak easy to request.
The Franken-Hoagie also has the best name on the menu, hands down. Kids who giggle at monster jokes will probably want to order it just for the title.
Italian Subs Are The Order Everyone Talks About
Among all the sandwiches here, the Italian sub gets the most attention. Staff even point to it as a house specialty.
You can go a few directions with it. Options include the regular Italian, a Spicy Italian, and a Super Italian for those who want more.
The seasoning tends to be the star of the show. One fan of the double Italian praised the seasonings above all else.
There’s also a practical tip worth knowing. Ordering the 16-inch size can be a better bargain, and leftovers reheat well in the oven.
That makes the bigger sub a solid choice for road trips. You eat half now and save the rest for dinner at the hotel or back home.
The Spicy Italian brings some heat for adults who want a kick. Younger travelers might stick with the classic version instead.
Either way, the Italian sub is the clearest starting point for first-timers. If you only order one thing at Yogis Hoagies, this is the safe bet that still feels special.
Plenty Of Picks For Kids Who Skip The Spicy Stuff
Not every kid wants five meats and banana peppers. Thankfully, the menu goes well beyond big Italian stacks.
A plain ham and cheese sub is right there for the cautious eaters. The meatball sub with homemade sauce is another easy win for younger appetites.
Pizza is on the menu too, including French bread pizza. That one feels tailor-made for kids who treat pizza as a food group.
Pasta dishes round things out, with spaghetti and lasagna among the options. There’s even a seafood sub, which one regular calls a personal favorite.
Bagels show up on the menu as well. Garlic cheese bread is another side that can please the whole table.
Daily specials add a little variety if you visit more than once. Ask what’s available when you order, since specials change.
The Eastern Eddie is another sub with a loyal following. It’s a fun name to try out on curious kids.
This range makes Yogis Hoagies easier for families with mixed tastes. Parents can grab a loaded hoagie while the kids stay happily in the pizza lane.
A Dining Room That Doubles As A Time Capsule
An old 8-track tape sits on display inside, and that’s just a start. The dining room at Yogis Hoagies is packed with nostalgic memorabilia.
There’s even a picture of Captain Kangaroo on the wall. Grandparents may recognize him instantly, while kids will likely ask who he is.
The standout feature is a display case filled with gifts. Visitors have brought these items in since the shop first opened.
That case turns lunch into a mini scavenger hunt. Kids can spend a few minutes spotting the oddest or oldest treasure inside.
The decor leans retro and a bit dated, and nobody pretends otherwise. It’s clearly an old-school mom-and-pop place, with Italian-style decorations mixed in.
Honestly, that’s part of the charm for families. You don’t have to worry about little hands smudging anything too fancy.
The vibe works best for a casual lunch rather than a dressy dinner out. Think comfortable booths and conversation, not candlelight.
It also gives parents an easy conversation starter. Few things beat explaining an 8-track to a kid who streams everything.
Room Enough For Birthday Crowds And Graduation Parties
Celebrations happen here more often than you might expect. The space works well for hosting small parties with family and friends.
One guest celebrated a master’s degree at Yogis Hoagies. The room was easy to decorate and stage for the occasion.
Food was prepared fresh as guests ate. The staff kept things warm and welcoming throughout the event.
For families, that opens up some fun possibilities. A kid’s birthday, a team lunch, or a small reunion could all fit the setting.
There’s also room for eat-in groups on a regular day. That’s handy when you’re traveling with grandparents, cousins, or a carload of hungry teens.
Wi-Fi is available inside as well. Older kids can check messages while the adults linger over their sandwiches.
If you’re planning a gathering, reach out ahead of time. Hours and availability can shift, so it helps to confirm details early.
A sub shop party might not sound glamorous. Still, piles of fresh hoagies and a memorabilia-filled room make for a pretty memorable afternoon.
Quick Lunches And Easy Online Orders
Speed counts when you’re on a lunch break or a tight travel schedule. The crew here seems to understand that well.
Staff are known for moving fast when people are clearly on the clock. Your sub shows up without a long, awkward wait.
Online ordering is another big plus. You can place your order ahead and simply swing in to grab it.
That’s a lifesaver for parents with restless kids in the car. Nobody has to unbuckle, wander, and debate the menu for ten minutes.
Takeout works nicely for picnics too. Grab a few subs and head to a nearby park for a relaxed meal outdoors.
Delivery through apps is also an option in the area. Keep in mind that app pricing can run higher than ordering directly.
Subs travel better than many restaurant meals. They hold up fine in a bag and don’t need special handling.
For road-tripping families, this flexibility is huge. You can eat in, take out, or order ahead depending on how the day is going.
Know The Hours Before You Point The Car North
Sundays are off the table, so plan around that. Yogis Hoagies is closed every Sunday.
Monday through Thursday, doors open at 11 a.m. and close at 7 p.m. Friday and Saturday stretch later, running from 11 a.m. to 9 p.m.
Those weekend evening hours help families coming from farther away. You can spend the day exploring Columbus and still grab dinner.
You’ll find the shop at 1274 Morse Rd, Columbus, OH 43229. It’s on the north side, just a short hop from I-71.
That location makes it a manageable drive from other parts of Ohio. One fan even drove up from Cincinnati just for a sandwich.
Families from Dayton, Mansfield, or Delaware could easily fit it into a day trip. Columbus attractions nearby make the drive feel extra worthwhile.
Prices are fair, and the larger sizes offer better value. Discounts are sometimes available, though they may apply only to certain items.
Hours can change seasonally or around holidays. A quick check before you leave saves disappointment.
Why This Little Sub Shop Earns A Spot On Your Route
Forty-seven years is a long run for any small restaurant. For a family sub shop on a busy Columbus road, it says plenty.
Yogis Hoagies doesn’t chase trends or polish its look. It sticks with big hoagies, friendly faces, and a dining room full of memories.
Families get a lot in one stop. There are kid-friendly options, quick service, and an entertaining display case to explore.
Not every order lands perfectly, and that’s true almost anywhere. The subs, especially the Italians, remain the clear reason to come.
I believe places like this deserve a little extra love. They carry the personality that chain restaurants just can’t copy.
The nostalgic decor gives grandparents something to talk about. Kids get a monster-named sandwich and a mini museum lesson.
Passing through Ohio on I-71 makes this an easy add to your plans. Even a planned trip to Columbus could use a hearty lunch stop.
Order the Italian, split a Franken-Hoagie, and take a peek at those gifts. You’ll leave full and probably a little curious about that 8-track.