Skip to content

This Ohio Ice Cream Parlor Has A Surprising Specialty That Keeps Pretzel Lovers Coming Back

The most popular item at one beloved Ohio ice cream parlor isn’t a scoop at all. It’s a crunchy, lightly salted pretzel wearing a thick coat of hand-dipped chocolate.

The pretzels are sourced from a Pennsylvania company before being coated in chocolate at the Ohio shop. Then they get dipped in milk, dark, or white chocolate. The shop offers chocolate-covered pretzels in milk chocolate, dark chocolate, and white confectionery coating.

Of course, the ice cream counter is no slouch either. Dozens of homemade hard-dip flavors share the building with more than ninety kinds of house-made chocolates. I appreciate a place that refuses to pick just one sweet lane.

So how does a family candy shop end up famous for pretzels? The answer stretches back generations. I’d happily learn it one salty, chocolatey bite at a time.

The Pretzel Everyone Ends Up Ordering

The Pretzel Everyone Ends Up Ordering
© Dietsch Brothers, 400 W Main Cross St, Findlay, OH

Salty, crunchy, and dipped in chocolate, the pretzels at Dietsch Brothers Fine Chocolates & Ice Cream are the shop’s best seller. That’s a big deal for a place known for ice cream.

The process starts with fresh, lightly salted pretzels sourced from a Pennsylvania company. The pretzels arrive ready for their thick chocolate coating, which creates the shop’s signature sweet and salty combination.

Next comes the hand-dipping. You can choose milk chocolate, dark chocolate, or white chocolate. Some pretzels get extra flair with contrasting drizzles.

Other options include miniature chocolate-covered pretzels and chocolate-dipped pretzel rods. That gives you plenty of ways to mix sweet and salty in a single bag.

I love that this treat sounds simple but clearly gets careful attention. A pretzel can easily go stale or soft. Starting fresh makes a lot of sense.

If you’re shopping for a group, grab a mix of chocolate styles. Dark chocolate fans and white chocolate fans rarely agree on anything. A variety bag keeps the peace.

Honestly, I can’t imagine leaving this shop without at least a few pretzels. They’re the reason so many visitors plan their stop around this counter.

Brothers, Recipes, And A Very Sweet Comeback

Brothers, Recipes, And A Very Sweet Comeback
© Dietsch Brothers, 400 W Main Cross St, Findlay, OH

Back in the late 1920s, Edward Dietsch opened a candy and ice cream store with his brothers Chris and Don. They worked from cherished family recipes.

That first chapter didn’t last. After a brief closure that followed family tragedies, the story could have ended right there.

Instead, Chris, known as Bud, and Don, known as Johnny, reopened in 1937. They bought a local bakery and turned their focus to fine chocolates and ice cream.

A year later, youngest brother Roy joined the business. His nickname was Snitz, which might be the best nickname in Ohio candy history.

Those nicknames make the whole story feel personal. You can almost hear the brothers calling to each other across the kitchen.

Today, the business is still family-owned and operated. The third generation now leads the company, carrying the same recipes and goals forward.

The family’s motto is quality over quantity. That idea fits a shop that still hand-dips pretzels and makes its own ice cream.

Knowing this history adds flavor to every visit. Your scoop comes with nearly ninety years of family stubbornness, in the best possible way.

Find The Green Awning On Main Cross Street

Find The Green Awning On Main Cross Street
© Dietsch Brothers, 400 W Main Cross St, Findlay, OH

A green awning on a brick building marks the spot. Dietsch Brothers sits at 400 W Main Cross St, Findlay, OH 45840, in the city’s downtown area.

The look is classic rather than flashy. That suits a shop that would rather show off its candy cases than fancy decor.

Getting there is easy for road trippers. The store sits only a few minutes from Interstate 75, which makes it a handy break on a long drive.

That convenience is dangerous in a fun way. A quick detour can quickly turn into a bag of chocolates and a cone for the road.

Plan your timing before you go. The store opens at 9 a.m. Tuesday through Friday and stays open until 9 p.m.

Saturday hours run from 10 a.m. to 9 p.m. Sundays are shorter, from noon to 5 p.m., and the shop closes on Mondays.

If you’re visiting on Monday, head to the east-side Dietsch Brothers store at 1217 Tiffin Avenue, which is open from 10 a.m. to 9 p.m. Nobody wants to stare sadly at a locked candy shop door.

Evening visits work nicely for an after-dinner treat. Sunday afternoon trips need a little more planning, so don’t wait too long.

Two Counters, One Very Tough Decision

Two Counters, One Very Tough Decision
© Dietsch Brothers

Half candy store and half ice cream parlor, this building splits your attention right away. There’s a dedicated candy counter and a separate counter for ice cream.

That setup is smart. Chocolate shoppers and cone seekers each get their own space, so nobody has to squeeze past a sundae order to buy truffles.

The candy side is where the pretzels live. Glass cases hold rows of chocolates, clusters, and other treats ready to be boxed up.

The ice cream side handles scoops, shakes, and sundaes. It can be the busier half on warm evenings, so a little patience helps.

My advice? Do both. Grab a scoop to enjoy now and a box of chocolates to enjoy later.

Chocolate boxes can even be gift-wrapped. That’s a lifesaver if you forgot a birthday and happen to be driving through Findlay.

The old-school feel adds to the fun. It’s a place built around treats, not trends. Dietsch Brothers keeps the focus right where it belongs.

Just pace yourself. Two counters means double the temptation.

Ninety-Plus Chocolates Are Waiting For Their Moment

Ninety-Plus Chocolates Are Waiting For Their Moment
© Dietsch Brothers

More than ninety varieties of chocolates are made in-house here. That number alone could turn a quick stop into a long browse.

The cases hold truffles, caramels, barks, and clusters. You’ll also spot chocolate-covered cherries, peanut brittle, and specialty popcorn.

Then there are buckeyes. These peanut butter balls dipped in chocolate are an Ohio favorite, and skipping them in Ohio feels a little rude.

Peanut butter meltaways are another name that pops up often. If peanut butter and chocolate are your weakness, you may need a bigger box.

Many pieces are hand-rolled or individually dipped. That kind of care takes time, and it shows in how polished the cases look.

Sugar-free candy is part of the lineup too. That’s a thoughtful touch for anyone watching their sugar who still wants a treat.

For first-timers, a mixed box is the easiest path. You get to sample several styles without committing to a single favorite.

Pair a few truffles with some pretzels. Sweet, salty, smooth, and crunchy all land in one tidy package.

Buckeye Ice Cream And Other Scoop-Worthy Choices

Buckeye Ice Cream And Other Scoop-Worthy Choices
© Dietsch Brothers, 400 W Main Cross St, Findlay, OH

Chocolate Pretzel Caramel Swirl is an actual ice cream flavor here. Of course it is. Pretzel fans get a frozen version of their favorite treat.

Dietsch Brothers makes dozens of hard-dip flavors on-site. Ice cream is a major part of the business, not a side project.

Flavor names include Buckeye, Mackinac Island Fudge, and Maple Nut. Classic vanilla and chocolate are there for traditionalists too.

Fruit lovers have options as well. Sherbet and fruit flavors give you something lighter on a hot afternoon.

Cups and cones are the simple route. Waffle cones are a popular pick if you want that extra crunch with your scoop.

Can’t decide? An ice cream flight lets you taste more than one flavor. It’s basically a cheat code for indecisive people.

I’d probably start with Buckeye. It feels like the most Ohio thing you could possibly order.

The shop has earned awards for its ice cream over the years. With this many choices, multiple visits feel less like a splurge and more like homework.

Sundaes, Shakes, And Pies Raise The Stakes

Sundaes, Shakes, And Pies Raise The Stakes
© Dietsch Brothers

Sometimes a cone just isn’t enough. The menu here goes well beyond a plain scoop.

Sundaes are a big draw. You’ll find choices like a Caramel Cashew sundae and a Tin Roof sundae.

Shakes and malts are on the list too. So are sodas, which feel right at home in an old-fashioned parlor.

A malt has a toasty, nostalgic charm. If you’ve never tried one, this is a fine place to start.

Planning a party? Dietsch Brothers offers ice cream pies at both locations, while its ice cream cakes are available exclusively at the east-side store.

That’s a handy option for birthdays or family gatherings. A cake built from Dietsch Brothers ice cream will probably get more attention than the candles.

Portions here have a reputation for being generous. Sharing a sundae could be a smart move, especially with candy on your shopping list.

One more tip: there’s a water tap at the end of the counter. A cold glass of water between sweet bites keeps your taste buds ready for round two.

Leave Room In Your Bag For The Gift Shop

Leave Room In Your Bag For The Gift Shop
© Dietsch Brothers

Tea towels and chocolate make a surprisingly good team. The main store includes a gift shop stocked with local goods and seasonal items.

Serving trays and kitchen towels often show up on the shelves. There are also fun finds for dog and cat lovers.

That makes the shop a strong pick for small gifts. Think teachers, neighbors, hostesses, or that coworker who always remembers your birthday.

Custom chocolate gifts are available too. A personalized box feels a lot more thoughtful than a last-minute gas station card.

Remember the gift-wrapping option for chocolate boxes. It saves time and makes your present look polished without any tape mishaps.

Seasonal items change throughout the year. That gives repeat visitors a reason to browse again instead of heading straight for the pretzels.

Okay, you’ll still head straight for the pretzels. But the gift shop is worth a slow lap afterward.

I appreciate that the shop thinks beyond dessert. It turns a sweet stop into a one-trip errand for presents, souvenirs, and something special for yourself.

Findlay Keeps This Family Business Growing

Findlay Keeps This Family Business Growing
© Dietsch Brothers

Over 100 employees help keep the candy cases and freezers full. Many of them have stayed with the company for decades.

Much of the production still happens right in Findlay. That keeps Dietsch Brothers tightly tied to the community it has served for generations.

The shop is often named among the businesses that put Findlay on the map. For many Ohio families, its treats are part of holidays and celebrations.

Big plans are also in the works. The company is expanding at its downtown location by acquiring an adjacent property.

The goal is more workspace, more production capacity, and more warehousing. More pretzels sounds like great news for everyone.

Future ideas include a bigger parking lot and possibly an outdoor patio. The beloved retail spaces are expected to stay the same.

Groundbreaking is hoped for in spring 2027. Until then, the classic shop keeps doing what it does best.

So stop by now and come back later to see what changes. A family business that keeps growing after nearly ninety years? That’s a sweet sign for downtown Findlay.