Skip to content

This Massachusetts Italian Restaurant Inside An 1851 Jail Is Serving Award-Winning Chef’s Italian Cuisine

The restaurant’s name means “escape” in Italian. That’s a bold choice for a dining room inside a former jail, and I love the nerve of it.

The granite building was finished in 1851 and held prisoners until 1990. Now it serves hand-pulled mozzarella, naan from a tandoori oven, and a wood-fired lobster pizza.

I find it interesting that a place built to lock people in now gets people lining up to get in.

The chef behind it all won a James Beard Award decades ago. Her cooking borrows freely from Italy, the Mediterranean, and the Middle East.

So in Massachusetts, the big question becomes simple. What would you order first behind these old stone walls?

A Name That Winks At Everyone Who Comes Through The Door

A Name That Winks At Everyone Who Comes Through The Door
© Scampo, 215 Charles St, Boston, MA 02114, United States

Scampo means “escape” in Italian. Considering the building’s past, that’s a pretty cheeky joke.

Scampo sits on the first floor of The Liberty Hotel in Boston, Massachusetts. Before it was a hotel, the structure was the Charles Street Jail.

The restaurant calls itself Italian-inspired, but the menu doesn’t stay inside any fences. Dishes pull flavors from the Mediterranean and the Middle East too.

That freedom matches the name nicely.

You can stop in for lunch Thursday through Saturday. Dinner is served every night of the week, so evening plans are easy to make.

The space feels bold, red, and full of energy. Shiny copper lamps hang overhead, and a glowing orange bar adds warmth.

It feels lively but still cozy enough for a long conversation.

Designers Rafael Alvarez and Brannen Brock created the look. Their work keeps things modern while the old building does the storytelling.

I appreciate how the restaurant leans into its history with humor instead of hiding it. A name like Scampo tells you right away that dinner here comes with a wink.

It also hints that nothing on the menu will feel locked into one tradition.

Granite Walls Hold More Than 150 Years Of Boston Stories

Granite Walls Hold More Than 150 Years Of Boston Stories
© Scampo, 215 Charles St, Boston, MA 02114, United States

Completed in 1851, the Charles Street Jail stands as a major example of the Boston Granite School of architecture. That’s an architecture term for heavy, serious stonework that was built to last.

It certainly did last. The jail operated for more than a century before closing in 1990.

Why did it close? Courts found the conditions unconstitutional, including serious overcrowding.

That’s a hard chapter, and it’s part of what makes the building’s new life so striking.

Massachusetts General Hospital bought the property in 1991. Redevelopment started in 2001, and the building reopened as The Liberty Hotel in 2007.

Plenty of the original features stayed put. Exposed brick, arched windows, and old catwalks still remind guests what the place used to be.

I can see why history lovers find this spot so appealing. You aren’t just eating near history.

You’re eating inside it, surrounded by the same stone that stood here long before cars rolled down Charles Street.

Curious to learn more? The Liberty Hotel offers historical tours exclusively to registered hotel guests on Wednesdays at 2 PM, with advance reservations required.

The Chef In Charge Helped Shape How Boston Eats

The Chef In Charge Helped Shape How Boston Eats
© Scampo

Lydia Shire doesn’t just run the kitchen here. She’s the executive chef and owner of Scampo.

In 1992, the James Beard Foundation named her America’s Best Chef – Northeast. For chefs, that’s one of the biggest honors around.

Shire is widely seen as a trailblazer in Boston’s food scene. She helped open doors at a time when top kitchens were mostly run by men.

Her cooking style is easy to describe and hard to copy. Think bold, fearless creativity backed by a serious commitment to great ingredients.

At Scampo, that means Italian cooking that isn’t boxed in by borders. One dish might lean classic Roman.

The next might borrow a spice or technique from much farther east.

I’d be curious to know how she dreams up some of these pairings. Who else would put grated maple on pork belly pappardelle?

Here’s a helpful tip. If a dish sounds a little unusual, that’s probably the point.

Shire’s menu rewards people who take a small chance, so try at least one plate that surprises you. You might find a new favorite.

Fresh Mozzarella Gets Pulled By Hand Right In Front Of You

Fresh Mozzarella Gets Pulled By Hand Right In Front Of You
© Scampo

Cheese fans, this part is for you. Scampo has a mozzarella bar, and it’s one of the restaurant’s best-known features.

Scampo’s mozzarella bar features fresh cheeses, including mozzarella and burrata. That means your cheese isn’t sitting around waiting for you.

It gets made when you ask for it.

Stools line up along the bar so you can watch the action. It’s a little like a cooking show, except you get to eat the results.

Not sure what the difference is? Mozzarella is the familiar stretchy one.

Burrata has a soft, creamy center, and stracciatella is the shredded, creamy filling on its own.

If you’re dining with a group, ordering a few kinds to share makes sense. Everyone gets to compare, and nobody fights over the last bite.

Well, probably.

The cheese shows up elsewhere on the menu too. The Scampo BLT features burrata with bacon and avocado, plus a cup of tomato soup on the side.

There’s also a Burrata and Prosciutto Naan. Fresh cheese seems to sneak into everything here, and honestly, good for it.

Naan From A Tandoori Oven Shows Up At An Italian Table

Naan From A Tandoori Oven Shows Up At An Italian Table
© Scampo, 215 Charles St, Boston, MA 02114, United States

A tandoori oven in an Italian restaurant sounds like a mix-up. At Scampo, it’s completely on purpose.

The kitchen uses it to bake house-made breads. The most famous is naan served with anchovy butter, a pairing that captures Lydia Shire’s border-free style in one bite.

Anchovy butter might make some people nervous. Don’t let the little fish scare you off.

Anchovies usually add a salty, savory kick rather than a fishy flavor when blended into butter.

Other breads have shown up on the menu too. The Truffled Robiola Focaccia combines a soft Italian cheese with earthy truffle.

Bread here isn’t just a side. It’s practically a whole category worth exploring before your main course arrives.

Here’s a smart move for first-timers. Order one bread for the table and share it while you study the rest of the menu.

It keeps hungry people happy and gives you a quick taste of the kitchen’s personality. If a restaurant can make bread this interesting, you’ll probably trust its pasta choices too.

That’s a pretty good way to start any meal.

Lobster On A Pizza Might Be The Best Idea In The Building

Lobster On A Pizza Might Be The Best Idea In The Building
© Scampo

Lobster pizza. Two words, and suddenly you’re hungry.

The wood-fired lobster pizza is a signature dish at Scampo, and it makes a lot of sense in Massachusetts. New England and lobster go together like Boston and accents.

The pizza lineup goes well beyond that star. Options have included a Classic Tomato, Fior Di Latte and Basil Pizza, a Lamb Pizza, and a Roman Artichoke Pizza.

That range is handy if your group can’t agree. Someone can go classic while someone else tries something a little wilder.

Pasta lovers have plenty to explore too. Familiar favorites like Pomodoro, Carbonara, Bolognese, Vongole, and Cacio e Pepe sit next to more creative plates.

One standout is the hand-cut serrated egg pappardelle with crisped pork belly, grated maple, and cavolo nero pesto. Another pairs creste di gallo pasta with white rabbit ragu and creamed collards.

There’s even spinach gnocchi gnudi with brown butter, sage, black truffles, and soft mozzarella. That’s a lot of comfort on one plate.

Tip time: menus change, so check what’s current before you go. Your dream dish might be waiting.

Big Plates Bring Duck, Veal, And Seafood Into The Spotlight

Big Plates Bring Duck, Veal, And Seafood Into The Spotlight
© Scampo

Saving room for a main course takes discipline here. With all that bread, cheese, and pizza, it’s a real test of willpower.

Still, the entrées deserve attention. “Our Scampo Duck” has been served with celery root and celery leaf gnocchi, and duck clearly gets special treatment in this kitchen.

Another duck option has appeared over mascarpone risotto. Creamy, rich, and very hard to share.

The Veal Chop Milanese comes with yellow skin Pomodoro, melting fontina, and wild arugula. It’s a classic Italian idea given a few colorful upgrades.

Seafood fans have options as well. Scottish salmon has arrived with emerald beurre fondue and mini truffled potato gnocchetti.

Icelandic cod loin with vinegared sushi rice shows that global streak again. Italy and Japan meeting on one plate?

Only at a place called Escape.

Starters keep things interesting too. Think deviled crab on Hokkaido bread, white miso clam chowder with soba noodles, or a bisque of wild mushrooms.

For lunch, the Scampo Wagyu Burger offers a heartier choice. Whatever you pick, expect familiar foods with a twist.

Your Next Celebration Could Happen Behind Original Jail Stone

Your Next Celebration Could Happen Behind Original Jail Stone
© Scampo

Birthdays, rehearsal dinners, and work parties all need a room. Scampo offers one with a seriously unusual backstory.

The private dining room accommodates up to 30 guests. It sits within the original stone walls of the old jail, so your toast will echo off history.

Better still, the room has a view into the open kitchen. Your guests get dinner and a little show at the same time.

That open kitchen adds energy to the main dining room too. Watching cooks move around makes the whole space feel lively and busy in a good way.

Warm weather opens up another choice. A secluded 60-seat outdoor patio gives you room to enjoy fresh air with your meal.

Planning tip: book private events well ahead of time, especially for popular seasons. Big groups need more planning than a quick table for two.

I appreciate that the restaurant gives people options. You can go cozy, outdoorsy, or full party mode.

Each one feels different, and all of them come with the same story baked right into the walls.

Getting There Is Easier Than Breaking Out Ever Was

Getting There Is Easier Than Breaking Out Ever Was
© Scampo

Good news for planners. Reaching this former jail takes about three minutes on foot from the subway.

You’ll find Scampo at 215 Charles St, Boston, MA 02114, inside The Liberty Hotel. It sits in the historic Beacon Hill neighborhood, one of the most charming parts of the city.

The MBTA Red Line stops at the Charles/MGH station. From there, the walk is short enough that even bad weather can’t ruin it.

Driving instead? The Liberty Hotel offers valet parking, which beats circling Beacon Hill’s tight streets.

Timing matters too. Dinner runs nightly, with later hours on Friday and Saturday, while lunch is served Thursday through Saturday.

If you’re staying at The Liberty Hotel, you could reserve a historical tour and pair it with a meal at Scampo. That turns a regular dinner into a full Massachusetts outing.

Beacon Hill is lovely for an after-dinner stroll as well. Gas lamps and brick sidewalks make walking off that lobster pizza feel like a treat.

Honestly, it’s a rare jail people try to get into. With food this creative, who could blame them?