The olive oil on your table comes from the owners’ own family land in Sicily. It’s cold-pressed, unfiltered, and made from three kinds of olives grown in Trapani.
That detail alone had me hooked. Then I learned the restaurant sits inside a Greek Revival house built in 1858, lovingly restored by the family.
The recipes have deep roots too. The family patriarch left a small Sicilian village at 23 and opened his first restaurant in Wisconsin back in 1977.
Now his three sons run the show alongside him, cooking dishes they grew up making. I have to admit, a pistachio pasta and a baked mozzarella with a family name attached sounds pretty tempting. Would you order something familiar or try a Sicilian specialty?
Three Brothers And A Dad Who Started It All

Family recipes usually live on index cards in a kitchen drawer. At Safina, they live on a whole menu in downtown Milwaukee.
The restaurant is run by brothers Giuseppe, David, and Sal Safina, along with their father, Giovanni. Giovanni left a small village in Sicily at age 23 and later opened his first restaurant in 1977.
Milwaukee food lovers may know his earlier work. His family has a history with Nicolo’s and Giovanni’s, two longtime Italian restaurants in Milwaukee.
His sons grew up working in those kitchens and learning the family recipes by heart. They later ran their own spots, including Tutto, Notte, and Comedy Cafe.
So Safina isn’t a brand-new idea built from scratch. It’s a family collecting its greatest hits under one roof, with the original cook still involved.
I appreciate how you can spot that history right on the menu. Names like Giovanni’s original baked mozzarella and Gio’s original eggplant strips aren’t just cute labels.
They point back to dishes with real staying power. That kind of track record makes ordering feel a lot less like a gamble and more like a sure thing.
Dinner Inside A House That Dates Back To 1858

Most restaurants move into a strip mall. This one moved into a piece of Milwaukee history. Safina occupies the William A. Webber House, a Greek Revival building constructed in 1858. The Safina family restored both levels of the house before opening the doors to diners.
That’s a big project, and it shows real commitment. Old buildings come with quirks, and bringing one back to life takes patience and care.
Inside, you’ll find polished wooden floors and plush seating. Custom chandeliers hang overhead and add a soft, warm glow to the rooms.
Tables come set with fine linens, sparkling glassware, and polished cutlery. It feels dressed up without trying too hard, which fits the family’s goal perfectly.
They aim for a dinner that feels comfortable, casual, and fun around a traditional Italian meal. Think fancy enough for an anniversary, relaxed enough to loosen your belt a notch.
I love that the setting matches the food’s backstory. Recipes with decades behind them deserve a home with more than 160 years of its own.
That Bread Dip Traveled Farther Than You Did

Olive oil from a grocery shelf is fine. Olive oil from your own family’s trees in Sicily is a different story. The Safina family produces olive oil using olives grown on family land and nearby properties in Trapani, Sicily. It’s made from Biancolilla, Nocellara, and Cerasuola olives.
The oil is cold-pressed and unfiltered. That means it skips extra processing and keeps more of its natural character.
Here’s a fun fact for your next trivia night. Trapani sits on the far western tip of Sicily, an island famous for olives, citrus, and pistachios. The family doesn’t stop at oil, either. Key ingredients like pastas and salt are imported directly from Italy, specifically Sicily.
Those imports get paired with locally available seasonal ingredients. It’s a smart blend of old-country staples and fresh Midwest produce. I can’t imagine skipping the bread just to save room. When the dipping oil has its own family tree, it deserves a few bites of your attention.
Start With The Eggplant Strips And Thank Gio Later

Fried eggplant might not sound flashy. Then again, Gio’s original eggplant strips, called Melanzana Fritte, come with marinara and Parmigiano. That’s a starter with a family name on it. It’s a strong clue about which plate to grab first.
Giovanni’s original baked mozzarella is another family classic. It arrives with San Marzano tomatoes, which are prized for their sweet, rich flavor. Seafood fans have options too. The Calamari Classico features lightly floured squid with San Marzano sugo.
The Insalata di Mare mixes calamari, shrimp, and octopus. For something cheesy, the Formaggio Forno bakes fontina, Parmigiano, and asiago with spinach and artichoke.
Veggie lovers can look at the Arrostito, a Sicilian roasted cauliflower. Seppe’s Patate Vastase brings herb-roasted potatoes to the table.
My advice is simple. Order a few starters for the table and pass them around like it’s a family holiday. Sharing lets everyone sample more. It also prevents that awkward moment when someone eyes your mozzarella a little too long.
Pistachio Pasta Might Change Your Usual Order

Pistachios aren’t just for ice cream. In Sicily, they show up in all kinds of dishes, and Safina brings that idea to Milwaukee.
The Fusilloni al Pistachio pairs big spiral pasta with guanciale and a creamy pistachio pesto. Guanciale is cured pork cheek, a classic Italian ingredient with deep, savory flavor.
If you crave comfort, look at the Ragu al Forno. It features Giovanni’s signature meat sauce with penne, provolone, and garlic bread. That one sounds like the dish nonna makes when she wants everyone home on time. The name even tells you it comes from the head of the family.
Other choices cover plenty of moods. There’s a classic three-cheese Fettuccine Alfredo and a creamy penne dish with shrimp, mushrooms, spinach, and sun-dried tomatoes.
Seafood lovers can try the Frutta di Mare. It features black linguine in seafood broth with shrimp, calamari, and octopus. Honestly, picking one pasta feels unfair. Bring a friend, order two, and trade halfway through.
Momma, Nonna, And Gio All Get A Spot On The Entree List

Some menus name dishes after places. This one names them after family members, and that tells you a lot. Momma’s Vesuvio is a Sicilian herb-crusted, free-range chicken. Nonna’s Eggplant Parmigiana layers eggplant, San Marzano sugo, fontina, and mozzarella over linguine.
Gio’s Stuffed Filet goes big. It’s a center-cut filet with provolone, prosciutto di Parma, caramelized onions, tomato, and potatoes. Giovanni’s Original Veal comes two ways. You can choose Parmigiana style or Cotoletta style, depending on your mood.
The list keeps going with a Sicilian Grilled Maiale, which is a bone-in pork chop. There’s also Chicken Parmesan for anyone who sticks with a favorite.
Fish fans aren’t left out. The Branzino Griglia is grilled branzino, and the Pesce alla Puttanesca features roasted swordfish.
With so many family names attached, ordering feels a bit like choosing which relative’s cooking you trust most. Good news, though. You don’t have to tell anyone who won.
Save A Little Room, Because Tiramisu Is Waiting

Dessert is a big deal at an Italian family table. Safina keeps that tradition alive with an assortment of decadent Italian desserts, including Tiramisu. Tiramisu means something like pick me up in Italian. It’s a fitting name for the last bite of a long, happy dinner.
Before you get there, salads offer a lighter, brighter moment. The Rosetta Salad mixes greens with artichoke, Sicilian olives, pepperoncini, red onion, tomato, and Parmigiano.
Pino’s Burrata is even more colorful. It combines burrata with arugula, blood and navel oranges, fennel, dried cherries, and toasted pistachio. A millefiori balsamic vinaigrette ties it together. Notice those pistachios again? They really are a Sicilian favorite.
Here’s a practical tip. Starting with a salad keeps things balanced, so you still have space when dessert time arrives. Plan ahead and maybe split an entree. Walking away without tiramisu because you’re too full would be a real shame.
Got A Big Group? Head Upstairs To La Loggia

Planning a party for 25 people can feel like herding cats. Safina makes it easier with private and semi-private dining options. La Loggia is a cozy, elegant upstairs space that seats up to 30 guests. It’s a nice fit for birthdays, rehearsal dinners, and holiday parties.
The restaurant also accommodates private events for groups of up to 50 guests, with arrangements made in advance.
Groups of 12 or more can pick family-style prix-fixe menus. That’s the closest thing to a true Sunday dinner, with platters passed down the table.
The culinary team works with hosts to tailor menus. Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options are available, so nobody gets stuck with a sad side salad.
Private and semi-private events can happen any day of the week. That flexibility helps when your big day falls on a Monday. Corporate events and family gatherings work well here too. Call early, plan your menu, and let somebody else handle the dishes.
Book Ahead, Then Stroll Over To Cathedral Square

Timing matters with this one. Safina serves dinner Wednesday through Saturday, from 4 to 9 PM. Reservations are recommended, especially for groups. You can book online, which beats crossing your fingers at the door.
You’ll find the restaurant at 785 N Jefferson St, Milwaukee, WI 53202. It sits just steps from Cathedral Square Park in the East Town neighborhood. That location makes planning an evening easy. Downtown hotels are nearby, so out-of-town visitors can grab dinner without a long drive.
East Town stays busy with fun events. Jazz in the Park and Bastille Days both call this part of Wisconsin home.
Picture a summer plan that starts with music in the park. Then it ends with pasta in an 1858 house a few steps away.
The family’s goal is for every meal to feel like Sunday dinner at their own table. Since they’re closed on actual Sundays, think of a Wednesday visit as Sunday dinner arriving early. Nobody in Wisconsin will complain.






