Skip to content

This Wisconsin Deli Makes Chicago-Style Pastrami Sandwiches Worth Loosening Your Belt For

Every pastrami sandwich here gets carved by hand off a steam table, right at the moment you order it. No slicing machine touches that meat, not ever.

That old-school method is a big reason people make the drive up from Chicago to buy the pastrami by the pound. The meat is peppered, smoked, and spiced the old way, then piled high on rye.

I appreciate a place that refuses to rush something this good. This Wisconsin deli has been serving hand-cut corned beef since 1955, and a crunchy kosher pickle still rides along with every single sandwich.

Honestly, any sandwich that pulls hungry fans across a state line has earned a closer look from the rest of us. So how long could you hold out before planning a lunch run?

Your Sandwich Comes With Seventy-Plus Years Of Practice Behind It

Your Sandwich Comes With Seventy-Plus Years Of Practice Behind It
© Jake’s Delicatessen — 1634 W North Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53205

Back in 1955, Jake Levin bought a deli from Ruben Cohen and proudly put his own name over the door. That deal created Jake’s Delicatessen, and the hand-cut corned beef has been flowing ever since.

Seventy-one years is a long run for any restaurant. In the sandwich world, that’s practically royalty status. The deli is widely considered a Milwaukee institution. That reputation comes from sticking with methods that work instead of chasing every new food trend.

I love that the formula has stayed refreshingly simple. Good meat, real rye, a pickle on the side, and a knife instead of a machine.

Travel Wisconsin describes the goal as keeping the same feel as if it were still 1955. That’s a bold promise, and it’s exactly the kind of promise a deli lover wants to hear.

So, the next time a chain sandwich feels a little forgettable, remember this place. Somebody here has been carving meat by hand since your grandparents were young.

History tastes better when it comes stacked on rye. Consider that your first clue about why this North Avenue stop keeps drawing so much attention.

Chicago Drivers Have A Very Good Reason To Head North

Chicago Drivers Have A Very Good Reason To Head North
© Jake’s Delicatessen

Pastrami gets the star treatment at Jake’s Delicatessen. It’s peppered, smoked, and spiced the old way, which means no shortcuts and no fancy reinventions. Then comes the part that makes deli fans grin. Each sandwich gets carved by hand off a steam table at the moment you order.

Nobody fires up a slicing machine for this job. A person with a knife does the work, one order at a time. That method matters more than you might expect. It’s cited as a reason people travel all the way from Chicago to buy pastrami by the pound.

Let that sink in for a second. Chicago has plenty of sandwich options, yet some folks still point their cars toward Milwaukee. Once carved, the meat gets piled high on rye bread. Belt buckles everywhere should consider themselves warned.

My advice is simple and a little selfish. Order the pastrami sandwich first, then decide whether you need a pound to go.

Leaving without trying it would feel like visiting a bakery and skipping dessert. I can’t imagine making that mistake on purpose, especially after hearing how far some fans travel.

The Corned Beef Starts Its Journey Right Here In The Kitchen

The Corned Beef Starts Its Journey Right Here In The Kitchen
© Jake’s Delicatessen

Brining happens in-house at this deli, and that’s a detail worth bragging about. The corned beef gets brined, steamed, and then hand-cut fresh to order.

Many sandwich shops buy their meat ready to go from a supplier. Doing the brining yourself takes patience, space, and a real commitment to tradition.

Corned beef is actually where the legend began in 1955. Pastrami may grab headlines, but this meat has held the spotlight for decades.

Fans of a classic Reuben have a lot to celebrate here. The deli’s version stacks corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and Thousand Island dressing on grilled rye.

Grilled rye gives the whole thing a toasty edge. It’s the kind of sandwich that requires both hands and maybe a stack of napkins.

The Rachel also appears on the menu for anyone who likes a twist on the classic Reuben. Ordering both and splitting them with a friend sounds like a very reasonable plan to me.

I have to admit, a fresh-cut Reuben sounds hard to beat. Wisconsin winters practically beg for something warm, hearty, and stacked this generously.

Pastrami On A Hot Dog Might Be The Boldest Idea On The Menu

Pastrami On A Hot Dog Might Be The Boldest Idea On The Menu
© Jake’s Delicatessen

A Chicago-style hot dog with pastrami added sounds like something dreamed up at midnight. At Jake’s Delicatessen, it’s a real menu item, and I’m fully on board.

The deli also keeps a Chicago Hot Dog on the lineup. That’s a fun nod to the neighbors down south who already love the pastrami. Corned beef shows up in more than one form, too. The Corned Beef Philly brings that famous meat into cheesesteak territory.

Turkey fans haven’t been forgotten either. The Turkey Senator gives anyone skipping beef a reason to grab a booth. This variety makes the deli a smart pick for groups. One person can go classic while another tries something a little more adventurous.

Picky eaters and bold eaters can finally share a table in peace. Everybody walks away happy, and nobody has to settle for a sad salad. My vote goes to ordering one wild card alongside a classic sandwich. Splitting a pastrami dog sounds like smart strategy, not overindulgence.

After all, comfort food this creative deserves a little exploring. The regular sandwiches will still be there next time, waiting patiently on the steam table.

Every Sandwich Shows Up With A Crunchy Sidekick

Every Sandwich Shows Up With A Crunchy Sidekick
© Jake’s Delicatessen

Kosher pickles come with every sandwich, no extra request needed. That little green spear does important work, cutting through all that rich, peppery meat. Matzo ball soup is made fresh daily here. It often sells out early, so afternoon visitors might find the pot already empty.

That’s a strong argument for showing up closer to opening time. Soup that disappears fast usually disappears for a reason.

The rest of the side lineup sticks to deli basics. Choose from coleslaw, potato salad, or Jake’s chips to round out the tray. Drinks follow the same old-school script. Classic sodas offer a refreshing pairing with the deli’s hearty sandwiches.

Dr. Brown’s and deli sandwiches go together like rye and mustard. Sipping a black cherry soda next to a pastrami stack just feels right. I appreciate that nothing here tries too hard to be trendy. The sides support the sandwiches instead of stealing the show.

Still, I’d be pretty bummed to miss that soup on a chilly Milwaukee afternoon. Grab a bowl if it’s there, because tomorrow’s batch won’t help you today.

The Building Was Handling Meat Long Before Pastrami Arrived

The Building Was Handling Meat Long Before Pastrami Arrived
© Jake’s Delicatessen

Around 1903, the building that holds this deli opened as a butcher shop. Meat has been part of the address’s story for well over a century. That’s a fun bit of trivia to share while waiting for your order. It also makes the hand-carving tradition feel like a natural fit.

Jake’s Delicatessen sits on Milwaukee’s north side. That area was historically a Jewish neighborhood, and the deli became a significant cultural landmark there.

Neighborhood delis across America often served as community anchors, not just lunch counters. This one carries that legacy on its own corner of North Avenue.

Most new restaurants open in spaces with no story at all. This one comes with a century of history baked right into the walls. Knowing the background adds flavor to every bite. A sandwich feels a bit more meaningful when it connects you to generations of Milwaukee eaters.

Take a moment to look around before your sandwich arrives. Old buildings tend to tell stories if you pay attention. History buffs and food lovers can both find something to enjoy here. Not many lunch stops in Wisconsin can say that with a straight face.

A Baseball Legend Helped Keep The Carving Knives Moving

A Baseball Legend Helped Keep The Carving Knives Moving
© Jake’s Delicatessen — 1634 W North Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53205

Bud Selig is famous for his baseball career, but his name also pops up in this deli’s story. In 1969, a group of local investors that included Selig stepped in to keep the doors open.

That’s quite a plot twist for a corned beef shop. Most sandwich spots don’t get rescued by a future baseball commissioner. Selig later became Commissioner of Major League Baseball, which makes this connection even more fun. It’s the kind of fact that wins trivia night.

The rescue says a lot about how much Milwaukee valued the place. People don’t pool their money to save something they can live without.

I find that pretty touching, honestly. A community decided its favorite deli was worth protecting, and decades later the sandwiches are still coming.

Sports fans visiting Milwaukee now have a bonus reason to stop. Pair a game day with a pastrami sandwich, and you’ve built a very local afternoon.

Just remember the deli closes on Sundays. Plan your sandwich-and-sports combo for a different day of the week. A little history, a little baseball, and a lot of meat on rye. That’s a lineup worth cheering for.

Grab A Vintage Booth Or Haul Home A Whole Pound

Grab A Vintage Booth Or Haul Home A Whole Pound
© Jake’s Delicatessen — 1634 W North Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53205

Vintage booths fill the dining area, giving the room a classic deli feel. It’s the kind of setting that makes a sandwich taste like a tradition. Dining in lets you enjoy that meat while it’s still hot from the steam table. Nobody wants a carefully carved sandwich to sit in a bag too long.

Of course, some days call for a takeout plan. Jake’s Delicatessen sells corned beef, pastrami, and turkey by the pound for exactly those moments. The deli also sells rye bread by the loaf. Soup comes by the quart, too, which feels like a gift to your future self.

That setup turns one trip into several meals. Build sandwiches at home, share with family, or stock up before a busy week. I appreciate a deli that trusts you to take the good stuff home. It’s like getting a backstage pass to the whole operation.

Hosting a game-day crowd or family gathering? A pound or two of pastrami with fresh rye could make you the most popular person in the room. Just don’t forget the pickles at home. The real deli experience deserves a crunchy finish.

Set Your Alarm, Because The Steam Table Fires Up At 10

Set Your Alarm, Because The Steam Table Fires Up At 10
© Jake’s Delicatessen

Finding the deli is easy once you know where to look. Jake’s Delicatessen sits at 1634 W North Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53205, on the city’s north side.

Doors open at 10 in the morning, Monday through Saturday. Sundays are a day off, so plan your craving accordingly. Early arrivals have a clear advantage here. That matzo ball soup often sells out, and nobody wants to miss the day’s batch.

The deli lists a 6 p.m. closing time, though checking the latest hours before heading out is smart. It beats showing up hungry to a locked door. Milwaukee makes an easy target for a Wisconsin food road trip. Chicago travelers already prove the drive is doable for a pound of pastrami.

I like the idea of building a whole day around this stop. Start with lunch, take some meat home, and plan your next visit on the ride back.

Dress for comfort when you go. Stretchy pants aren’t required, but your belt might appreciate the gesture after a sandwich piled this high. Seven decades in, the knife work is still the point. Some traditions are worth driving for, and this one comes with a pickle.