Skip to content

A Beloved Wisconsin Italian Restaurant Where Nobody Leaves The Table Hungry

Unlimited house salad and warm breadsticks arrive before your entree even shows up. That alone could fill a small family. Then the actual pasta lands.

On Sundays, there’s all-you-can-eat spaghetti with meatballs. I can see why people make a special trip just to test their limits. Most of them lose, happily.

This Wisconsin favorite leans hard into a Dean Martin theme, with comfortable booths and a retro mood. The bright dining room feels cheerful, while the darker bar area feels like a scene from an old movie. I appreciate a place that commits to a vibe.

The menu runs long, from fried eggplant to Sicilian steak sandwiches. Leftover boxes are basically part of the experience here. So the real question becomes simple. How much room are you saving for tiramisu?

The Breadsticks Arrive First, and That Sets the Tone

The Breadsticks Arrive First, and That Sets the Tone
© That’s Amore

Most restaurants make you wait for the good stuff. At That’s Amore Italian Cafe, the generosity starts the second you sit down.

Meals here often come with unlimited house salad and breadsticks. The salad shows up family-style, which feels like dinner at a relative’s house who refuses to let you leave hungry.

Breadsticks are easily the most talked-about item connected to this Greenfield spot. They’re warm, baked, and ready to swipe through whatever sauce lands on your plate later.

Here’s the tricky part, though. Pacing yourself takes real discipline when the basket keeps coming back.

My advice is simple and slightly painful. Enjoy a breadstick or two, then let the rest wait for the main event. The entrees at That’s Amore are known for generous portions. You’ll want room for them, plus a little space for dessert.

Treat the salad and bread as a warm welcome, not a challenge. Nobody hands out medals for finishing the basket. Still, I understand the temptation completely. A free, refillable starter is hard to resist, especially in Wisconsin, where comfort food is practically a hobby.

Dean Martin Would Feel Right at Home in These Booths

Dean Martin Would Feel Right at Home in These Booths
© That’s Amore

Somewhere between a family supper club and a Rat Pack lounge, this dining room found its groove. The name itself borrows from a famous Dean Martin tune, and the theme carries right through the decor.

Comfortable booths and a retro feel give the place real personality. The style mixes modern touches with a rustic warmth that feels relaxed instead of fussy.

Lighting changes depending on where you land. The main dining area can be bright and sunny, which works great for a lunch with friends. The bar area goes the other direction. It’s darker and moodier, with a nostalgic feel that suits a slower evening.

So which room fits your plans? A birthday lunch might feel best in the brighter space, while a date night could lean toward the cozier corners.

Asking for a preference when you book is a smart move. Reservations are recommended anyway, so you might as well make the most of them.

Honestly, a themed restaurant can feel cheesy if it’s done halfway. That’s Amore commits fully, and that confidence makes the whole room more fun to sit in.

Your Lasagna Craving Has Some Serious Competition

Your Lasagna Craving Has Some Serious Competition
© That’s Amore – 5080 S 108th St, Greenfield, WI 53228

Lasagna gets a lot of love here, with some calling it the best in the city. That’s bold talk, and it makes ordering anything else feel like a gamble.

The pasta list at That’s Amore makes the decision harder, not easier. Spaghetti Carbonara, Chicken Parmigiana, and Shrimp Scampi all share space on the menu.

The scampi brings shrimp, garlic, lemon, and butter together over pasta. Mushroom ravioli also gets plenty of attention, so it’s worth a look.

Short rib shows up in more than one dish, including pappardelle and bolognese. Baked ziti and gnocchi round things out for anyone who likes cheesy comfort.

The kitchen sticks to traditional recipes and a focus on quality ingredients. Nothing here tries to reinvent Italian food, which is kind of the point.

Here’s a practical tip for groups. Order different pastas and share a few bites around the table. Remember those generous portions, too. Even lunch servings come out large, so a single plate can easily turn into tomorrow’s lunch.

Leftover pasta often tastes even better the next day. Consider it a bonus meal you didn’t have to cook.

Sunday Spaghetti Night Is a Friendly Dare

Sunday Spaghetti Night Is a Friendly Dare
© That’s Amore

All-you-can-eat spaghetti with your choice of meatballs, meat sauce, or sausage. On a Sunday, no less, when everyone could use a little comfort before the week begins.

That’s Amore offers this Sunday special, and it fits the restaurant’s whole personality. The first plate comes out generous enough that asking for seconds might feel a little ambitious.

Fish fry is another weekly tradition worth knowing about. It’s offered on Wednesdays and Fridays, with fried and baked cod among the options. Fish fry in Wisconsin is close to a sacred ritual. Seeing it on the menu of an Italian spot makes total sense in this part of the state.

Families should circle Thursdays on the calendar. That’s when a special kids menu is offered, which makes picky eaters a bit easier to please. Specials can change over time, so a quick call before you go is wise. Nobody wants to plan a spaghetti showdown on the wrong night.

Also, keep in mind the restaurant is closed on Tuesdays. Plan your noodle adventures for any other day of the week.

Order Appetizers Carefully, Because They Act Like Meals

Order Appetizers Carefully, Because They Act Like Meals
© That’s Amore

French Fried Eggplant sounds like a side dish. In practice, it’s one of the more popular starters on the menu. The appetizer list at That’s Amore Italian Cafe goes deep. Homemade Calamari, Mozzarella Marinara, and Short Rib Arancini all compete for attention.

Can’t decide? The Amore Combo exists for exactly that problem, letting the table sample a mix instead of fighting over one choice.

Garlic bread with mozzarella is another option for anyone who believes bread deserves its own course. Considering the free breadsticks, that’s a bold but understandable move.

Here’s my honest strategy suggestion. Pick one starter for every two or three people, not one each. Appetizers here come in generous servings, and the salad and breadsticks are already on their way. Overordering early is the fastest route to needing a nap before your entree arrives.

Sharing also makes the meal feel more social. Passing plates around a table is half the fun of eating Italian food anyway. Save the leftovers if you can’t finish. Fried eggplant reheated the next day still beats most weekday lunches.

The Patio Makes Summer Evenings Feel Like a Vacation

The Patio Makes Summer Evenings Feel Like a Vacation
© That’s Amore

Wisconsin summers are short, so outdoor dining feels like a treasure. That’s Amore offers outdoor seating, and the patio ranks among the most mentioned features of the place.

Eating pasta outside on a warm evening simply hits differently. The breeze, the slower pace, and a plate of something saucy make an ordinary weeknight feel special.

Lunch on the patio works nicely too. A midday break outdoors can turn a busy workday into something worth looking forward to. Timing matters, of course. Patio weather in this part of the state comes and goes quickly, sometimes in the same afternoon.

Checking the forecast before heading out is a good habit. If you’re hoping for an outdoor table, mentioning that when you reserve can help. Families will appreciate the extra elbow room outside. Kids can be a little louder without anyone giving side-eye.

The patio also suits a slow catch-up with an old friend. When the food arrives in big portions, you’ll have plenty of time to talk while you work through it.

Three Banquet Rooms Mean Your Whole Family Can Come

Three Banquet Rooms Mean Your Whole Family Can Come
© That’s Amore – 5080 S 108th St, Greenfield, WI 53228

That’s Amore offers three private banquet rooms for gatherings of different sizes. The restaurant lists options for groups of 15, 40, and 60, with limited space for 75 to 80 guests.

That flexibility is a big deal for anyone planning a celebration. Anniversaries, wedding celebrations, family milestones, and private parties all find a home here.

Rehearsal dinners are a natural fit. A relaxed Italian meal the night before a wedding helps everyone unwind before the big day. Catering adds another option. The restaurant brings its food to outside events too, so your party doesn’t have to stay at the restaurant.

Planning tip number one: book early. Popular weekends fill up, and big rooms are hard to find on short notice. Tip number two is to ask about dietary needs ahead of time. Sharing allergies and preferences early gives the kitchen time to plan safe choices for everyone.

Family-style Italian food suits big groups especially well. Pasta, salad, and bread feed a crowd without much fuss. Nobody wants to host a party where guests head home hungry. At this Greenfield spot, that worry pretty much takes care of itself.

A Family Name and a Sicilian Chef Behind the Recipes

A Family Name and a Sicilian Chef Behind the Recipes
© That’s Amore

Behind every long-running restaurant is a story about people. Here, it’s the LoPiparo Family that invites guests to enjoy their authentic dishes.

That’s Amore has been serving the area for more than 30 years. Lasting that long in the restaurant business takes steady cooking and a loyal neighborhood.

The kitchen also teamed up with Antonino, formerly of Antonino’s Sicilian Ristorante del Carreto. His culinary know-how adds another layer of tradition to the menu.

You can spot Sicilian touches throughout. Sicilian Steak Sandwiches and Sicilian Pork Tenderloin both carry that influence proudly. Safety gets attention too. Kitchen personnel are licensed through the National Restaurant Association in Sanitation, which is reassuring to know.

Beyond the menu, the restaurant offers dine-in, carry-out, and catering. That range shows a business built around feeding people however they need it.

Free Wi-Fi and wheelchair access make visits easier for many guests. Small details like these matter when you’re planning a meal for everyone. Three decades is a long time to keep a dining room full. Clearly, the family has figured out a recipe that works.

Plan Your Visit, Then Walk Off Dinner Nearby

Plan Your Visit, Then Walk Off Dinner Nearby
© That’s Amore

Good news for anyone driving in. You’ll find the restaurant at 5080 S 108th St, Greenfield, WI 53228, on Milwaukee’s southwest side.

Opening hours vary by day, so check the restaurant’s current schedule before visiting. Showing up hungry to a locked door is nobody’s idea of a fun evening. Reservations are recommended, especially on Friday nights. Fish fry and weekend dinners can make tables go fast.

Here’s a bonus worth knowing. Whitnall Park and its gardens sit nearby, which makes a post-dinner stroll easy to plan. Walking through greenery after a giant plate of pasta feels like the responsible move. Your future self will thank you for it.

Carry-out is also available for nights when you’d rather eat at home. Everything from lasagna to fried eggplant can come along for the ride. Whatever way you enjoy That’s Amore, bring a container plan. In this corner of Wisconsin, leftovers are basically guaranteed.