A mechanical horse named Sandy still gives rides for a dime. A vintage popcorn machine still sells bags for the same price. Somehow, it all happens inside a store with more than 75,000 different items.
The whole place spreads across four connected 19th-century buildings on two levels. Worn wooden floors creak underfoot, and clerks still ring up purchases by hand.
This New York treasure has been run by the same family since 1930. The candy counter alone holds Turkish Taffy, wax bottles, and Sugar Daddies. One wall is stacked with 40 feet of puzzles.
I’d probably head straight for the penny candy and work outward from there. But with that many rooms, could anyone really stick to a plan?
Ninety-Six Years Of Dimes Started With Two Tiny Aisles

Robert S. Vidler Sr. opened his store on June 21, 1930. That was the very start of the Great Depression, which is a bold time to sell anything.
The first Vidler’s 5 & 10 was only about 900 square feet. It had just two aisles, so shoppers probably got to know each other quickly.
Today the store fills four connected 19th-century buildings. Shoppers browse between 15,000 and 20,000 square feet of selling space across two levels.
The family calls it the largest 5 & 10 variety store in the world. It’s also recognized as one of New York State’s historic businesses, which feels well earned.
Here’s a fun twist, though. Vidler’s isn’t the oldest five-and-dime in the country, since a store in Northville opened in 1907.
Size and staying power are the real story here. Third-generation family ownership is rare in any business, let alone one built on pocket change.
The store hit its 95th year on June 21, 2025. In October 2026, the owners listed both the historic buildings and the business for sale as they prepared for retirement, but Vidler’s remains open and operating normally.
Buyers who value the store’s role in the community get priority. That’s reassuring news for anyone who loves this place.
Look Up, Because Someone Is Standing On The Roof

Red and white stripes are the first clue you’ve arrived. The awning stretches over a storefront dressed in gingerbread trim and hand-painted gold leaf signs.
Then there’s the rooftop surprise. Since 2009, the Vidler on the Roof installation has kept watch over Main Street, and yes, the pun is fully intended.
That old-fashioned look didn’t happen by accident. In the late 1960s, local graphic artist Rix Jennings helped redesign the storefront to play up the classic five-and-dime theme.
His work gave Vidler’s 5 & 10 a face people remember. Few stores can claim a facade that works like a giant, cheerful business card.
Fame got another boost in 1980, when a Liberty Bank television commercial featuring actor Peter Graves brought attention to the store. A television commercial starring Peter Graves, of Mission Impossible fame, drew shoppers from all over Western New York.
Picture a secret agent recommending cookie cutters. That’s the kind of marketing that sticks around for decades.
My advice is simple. Take a photo out front before heading in, because the outside is half the fun.
Also, give yourself a second to spot the details. The gold lettering and trim reward anyone who slows down.
A Dime Still Buys A Pony Ride And Popcorn

Ten cents. That’s the price of a ride on Sandy, the mechanical horse waiting inside Vidler’s 5 & 10.
Kids hop on happily, and adults are welcome too. Nobody has to admit how much they enjoyed it afterward.
Right nearby, an old-fashioned popcorn machine also sells bags for a dime. It’s probably the best snack deal in the entire state of New York.
Don’t skip the fortune-telling scale either. It’s a classic piece of fun that hands out readings, and your future might involve more candy.
These little touches set the tone for the whole visit. They remind you this store cares about joy, not just sales.
Bring a few dimes in your pocket before you arrive. Digging through a purse for change while a child waits on a horse is nobody’s idea of fun.
Families with young kids should plan to stop here early. A quick ride can buy plenty of patience for the long browse ahead.
Honestly, the grown-ups might need it more. Wandering 75,000 items is a workout, and a popcorn break helps.
Your Sweet Tooth Will Recognize Old Friends At The Candy Counter

Rock candy, Mallo Cups, and Crystal Beach suckers all share space on the original counter. It’s like a reunion for treats that disappeared from regular grocery shelves years ago.
Satellite Wafers are here too. So are Turkish Taffy, Sugar Daddies, and those wax bottles filled with colorful syrup.
Crystal Beach suckers deserve a special shout-out. They carry a strong Western New York connection, so they make a fun local souvenir.
Penny candy comes by the pound or by the piece. That means you can build a mix as small or as wild as you like.
My strategy would be one of everything I haven’t tasted since grade school. Then I’d add a few unfamiliar ones just to be brave.
Kids love this counter for obvious reasons. Parents and grandparents tend to light up too, often pointing at candy they forgot existed.
It’s a great spot to share stories across generations. A wax bottle can start a surprisingly long conversation.
Grab your bag near the end of your visit, though. Carrying candy around for an hour takes real willpower.
Toyland Has Been Delighting Kids Since 1954

Back in 1954, the store expanded its basement and created Toyland. From then on, Vidler’s became famous for its huge toy selection.
The lineup leans timeless. Think yo-yos, rubber bugs, paper dolls, model kits, and wacky wind-ups.
Jack-in-the-boxes still pop here. Stuffed animals, toy cars, plastic animals, and coloring books fill in the rest.
Puzzle fans, brace yourselves. One wall stretches about 40 feet and is packed with puzzles, plus plenty of board games nearby.
There’s also a fun local link worth knowing. Fisher-Price was founded in East Aurora in 1930, and Vidler’s was the first store to carry its toys.
That shared hometown history makes this section feel extra special. Two famous names grew up on the same streets in the same year.
Set a budget before kids reach this area. Otherwise, the rubber bugs and wind-ups may stage a full takeover of your cart.
Grandparents, this might be your favorite gifting stop. Classic toys rarely need batteries, and that’s a win for everyone.
Home Cooks Should Budget Extra Time For The Gadget Aisles

Cookie cutters line the walls all year long. The selection is so large that bakers could find a shape for almost any party theme imaginable.
The housewares department at Vidler’s 5 & 10 goes way beyond baking. It’s packed with gadgets, widgets, and thing-a-majigs you won’t find at a big box store.
Canning and cake decorating supplies sit near bakeware and flour sifters. Tea kettles, enamelware, spatulas, and jar-lid removers fill the shelves too.
Campers get love here as well. Lodge cast iron, Rome pie irons, and campfire-cooking utensils are ready for your next fire pit night.
I appreciate a store that still stocks a proper flour sifter. Some tools just never go out of style.
This department makes a great stop for gift shopping. A quirky kitchen tool often feels more thoughtful than another candle.
Bring measurements if you’re replacing a specific item. Lids, pans, and molds come in many sizes, and guessing rarely ends well.
And yes, you’ll probably leave with something you didn’t plan to buy. That’s half the charm of this aisle.
Crafters, Collectors, And Back-Scratch Seekers All Get Their Moment

Need felt squares, feathers, or fake fur? The craft section has you covered, along with yarn, fabric, beads, and jewelry findings.
Sewing needles, thread, and embroidery floss sit near stencils, paints, and brushes. Unfinished wood pieces and craft patterns round out the creative supplies.
Then the store gets delightfully random. Back scratchers come in bamboo and even antler, which feels like a strong conversation starter.
Hair nets, curlers, shaving soap, and bingo dabbers all have homes here. So do paper masks, taper candles, and vinyl change holders.
School and office shelves offer sealing wax, brass stamps, and coin-collecting books. Flash cards, magnifying glasses, and password books are tucked among them.
Collectors can browse retro tins, mugs, and figurines too. Pop culture favorites like The Wizard of Oz, Lucy, Star Wars, and Hello Kitty show up.
Gag gifts and pet-lover presents add even more variety. There’s also a lodge-themed corner for cabin fans.
Bring a list, but stay flexible. This is the section where shopping lists quietly give up and let curiosity steer.
Christmas Never Fully Leaves This Corner Of New York

It could be July outside, and ornaments would still be waiting. Vidler’s keeps a Christmas and holiday section open all year.
Musical instrument ornaments are one quirky find here. They make sweet gifts for band kids or anyone who plays in a church choir.
Seasonal shelves shift with the weather too. Bird feeders, bird baths, and garden flags appear for folks sprucing up their yards.
Home decor, candles, cards, and bath and body products are also part of the mix. American and New York State-made soaps add a nice local touch.
Buffalo pride shows up strong. You’ll find Buffalo Bills merchandise and Vidler’s-themed souvenirs, including little replicas of the store itself.
A Vidler’s Store replica might be the perfect memento. It’s hard to think of a better reminder of the trip.
Shopping for stocking stuffers here is a smart move. The variety makes it easy to match small gifts to big personalities.
Specialty foods are available too. Pair one with a quirky gadget, and you’ve got a gift basket that feels truly one of a kind.
Plan A Whole Main Street Day Around Your Visit

East Aurora sits about 20 miles south of Buffalo. That short drive makes Vidler’s an easy day trip for much of Western New York.
You’ll find Vidler’s 5 & 10 at 676–694 E Main St, East Aurora, NY 14052. Parking is available behind the store, which saves a lap around the block.
Hours run 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday through Saturday. Sundays are 11 a.m. to 5 p.m., and the store closes on several major holidays.
Those closures include New Year’s Day, Easter, and Memorial Day. July 4th, Labor Day, Thanksgiving, and Christmas are also off the calendar.
The historic Main Street location puts lots within walking distance. Restaurants, shops, and the Aurora Theatre are all nearby.
History buffs can visit the Roycroft Campus and the Elbert Hubbard Museum. The Millard Fillmore House is close too, honoring the former president.
The East Aurora Farmer’s Market adds another reason to linger. Pair it with your shopping for a full, relaxed day.
Can’t make the trip? The store takes mail orders, though the full experience really shines in person.






