The build-your-own sandwich here is named after Benedict Arnold. Yes, the famous traitor. I appreciate a deli with that kind of sense of humor.
The jokes don’t stop at the menu board, either. One sandwich honors Thomas Jefferson and comes with homemade cranberry mayo.
The rolls and buns come from the store’s own bakery, so the bread is part of the show.
Then there’s the setting. This old general store in Vermont sits on an island in a big lake.
People can reach it by car, bike, boat, seaplane, or even ice skates in winter.
On a busy Saturday, the kitchen can turn out more than 500 sandwiches. That’s a lot of rolls for one little island bakery.
So what keeps everyone coming back for more?
A Sandwich Named After A Traitor Tells You Everything

History buffs, brace yourselves. At Hero’s Welcome, the build-your-own sandwich goes by The Benedict Arnold.
That name is a cheeky choice, and it sets the mood for the whole menu. Other sandwiches nod to famous figures and local landmarks.
The playful names make ordering feel like a little trivia game.
The Thomas Jefferson stacks turkey, cheddar, homemade cranberry mayo, lettuce, tomato, and onion. The Champlain brings turkey, crisp bacon, Vermont cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
Both sound like lunch with a side of history class.
Fans of something bolder can try The Norm. It pairs homemade chicken salad with pickles, hot pepper relish, cheddar, lettuce, tomato, and onion.
The Wild Bill keeps it simple with roast beef and horseradish sauce.
Then there’s The Sophie, with turkey, bacon, Swiss, lettuce, and mayo. It’s a classic combo for anyone who wants zero surprises.
I’d probably start with The Norm, because that relish sounds like trouble in the best way.
Every sandwich is made fresh with generous layers of fillings. Can’t decide?
Build your own and blame Benedict Arnold for any questionable choices.
The Bread Comes From Right Inside The Building

Plenty of delis buy their bread by the bag. Hero’s Welcome bakes its own rolls and buns in-house, and that changes things.
The store has its own bakery tucked behind a cozy counter. It turns out the rolls that hold every sandwich together.
Good bread is the quiet hero of any great sandwich, so the store’s name fits nicely.
The bakery doesn’t stop at sandwich rolls, though. Doughnuts, muffins, croissants, biscuits, and other pastries also come out of the kitchen.
That means breakfast is covered before the deli even gets busy.
Mornings start early here. The doors open at 7 a.m.
Monday through Saturday and 8 a.m. on Sunday. Coffee and iced coffee are ready too, so the pastry has a proper partner.
Think about the numbers for a second. On a busy Saturday, the kitchen can make more than 500 sandwiches.
Every one of those needs a roll, and the bakery handles that job.
I can’t imagine skipping a doughnut after learning all that. Grab one for the road, or two if the drive home is long.
Save Room For A Creemee, Because Vermont Says So

In most states, it’s called soft serve. In Vermont, it’s a creemee, and Hero’s Welcome serves them up through Lakeside Licks.
That ice cream stand sits right inside the store. It offers creemees along with hard ice cream, milkshakes, and floats.
So dessert is only a few steps from the deli counter.
The menu beyond sandwiches covers plenty of ground. Soup, salads, fish, tuna, grilled sandwiches, and chicken wraps all make an appearance.
Lighter appetites and hungry ones both have options.
Pairing lunch with a cold treat on a summer afternoon feels almost required here. The lake is right there, after all.
Ice cream tastes better with a view, and that’s basically science.
A float sounds like a fun throwback for anyone feeling nostalgic. A milkshake works well for the road trip crowd.
Kids will likely make a beeline for the creemee window anyway.
My advice is simple. Eat the sandwich first, then decide on dessert while staring at the water.
Few decisions in life are this pleasant.
Over A Century Of Shopkeeping Lives In These Walls

Back in 1899, John Tudhope built the main building that still stands today. His family ran the store for ninety years.
That’s a long stretch behind one counter. Generations of island families must have bought supplies under that roof.
The building carries more than a century of stories.
Hard times eventually closed the store. It sat empty for a while, which is a sad thought for such a classic spot. Then rescue arrived.
In 1993, Bob and Beverley Camp bought the property out of bankruptcy. They restored it and gave it a new name, Hero’s Welcome.
They opened that same Christmas, which sounds like a pretty great holiday gift for the town.
The Camps spent decades turning it into a must-see stop. Partners Carlene and Paul Letourneau joined them along the way.
The store was listed for sale in 2017 and has since sold.
Through all those changes, the doors stay open. I appreciate that a building from the 1800s still feeds people every single day.
Not many old stores get a second act this good.
Good Luck Leaving With Only A Sandwich

Live bait and prank hand buzzers share space with maple syrup. That one fact explains the shopping side of Hero’s Welcome better than any brochure.
The store stocks thousands of items. Specialty foods carry the label Mostly From Vermont, including local jams, maple syrups, and artisanal crackers.
Products from Vermont farms and syrup makers fill the shelves.
Then the range gets wild. There are housewares, gadgets, dry goods, toys, clothing, and cooking supplies.
Kitchen gadget fans could lose a whole afternoon here.
The interior has rustic wooden ceilings and shelves packed from end to end. It feels like an old-school country store, the kind that keeps surprising you.
Browsing often takes longer than planned, so build in extra time.
The property includes three buildings, which means more rooms to explore. Gift shoppers will find plenty of ideas.
Grabbing a jar of Vermont jam for someone back home is an easy win.
Consider it a treasure hunt with snacks. Just maybe skip the hand buzzer if your travel buddy is already cranky.
Arrive By Seaplane, Kayak, Or Even Ice Skates

Cars are the boring way to get here. Hero’s Welcome welcomes visitors by bike, horse, ferry, seaplane, kayak, canoe, and water skis.
Winter adds one more option to the list. When the lake freezes, folks can even show up on ice skates.
That’s a sandwich run worth bragging about.
A big summer dock sits less than a hundred feet from the store. Lake travelers can tie up and walk right over for lunch.
It’s hard to beat that kind of convenience.
Want to join the water crowd? The store rents kayaks, canoes, and stand up paddleboards.
A morning paddle followed by a fresh sandwich sounds like a near-perfect Vermont day.
Biking is a great choice too, since the islands have quiet roads and pretty views. Pedaling helps justify that creemee later.
I’d call it smart planning.
Out front, two old-fashioned analog gas pumps add charm. They’re a fun reminder of the store’s long history.
Snap a photo before you head in.
Your Lunch Deserves This Lakeside View

Few delis come with a lake for a backdrop. Here, Lake Champlain sits just steps away, and that view does a lot of work.
The store’s three buildings stand close to the water’s edge. Outdoor seating lets people eat with the lake in full sight.
The veranda also offers lovely views for anyone who wants a quick break.
Out front, you’ll find benches, some painted red and some painted blue. It’s a playful touch that adds color and character.
Pick your bench wisely.
Spreading out lunch by the water turns a quick bite into a mini vacation. Bring sunglasses on bright summer days.
A light jacket helps when the lake breeze picks up.
The store even runs a live webcam with a 24-hour view. Fans can peek at the lake from home anytime.
It’s a fun way to plan a visit or just daydream at your desk.
Good luck ignoring that view while you eat. Your sandwich may get cold, but honestly, it was cold to begin with.
Finding The Store Is Easier Than Choosing A Sandwich

Route 2 runs right through the Lake Champlain Islands. Follow it, and you’ll reach Hero’s Welcome at 3537 US-2, North Hero, VT 05474.
North Hero is one of four island towns in this corner of Vermont. The others are South Hero, Grand Isle, and Isle La Motte.
North Hero also serves as the shire town, or county seat, of Grand Isle County.
Life here moves at an easy, slower pace. The lake shapes local culture all year long.
Summer brings boating, and winter brings ice skating and ice fishing.
The store keeps steady hours. It’s open 7 a.m. to 6 p.m.
Monday through Saturday, and 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. on Sunday. That covers breakfast, lunch, and a late afternoon snack.
Summer is the busy season. The store can see more than 2,000 visitors in a single day during those warm months.
Arriving earlier in the day is a smart move.
Plan for parking and patience on peak weekends. The lake isn’t going anywhere, and neither are the sandwiches.
Turn Your Sandwich Stop Into A Full Island Day

A great lunch makes a great anchor for a road trip. Hero’s Welcome sits in a spot packed with scenic stops nearby.
South Hero is home to Hackett’s Orchard, a local family farm. It’s an easy add-on for anyone who loves fresh produce.
Fall trips could pair nicely with a sandwich run.
Over in Grand Isle, E Shore N offers sweeping views of the Green Mountains and Lake Champlain. It’s a lovely drive for photo lovers.
Bring a full camera battery.
Nature fans can explore Butternut Hill or the Pelots Point Rd trail. Both offer a peaceful taste of island scenery.
A short walk feels extra rewarding after a big lunch.
The North Hero House Inn and Restaurant is also close by. It makes a handy stop for travelers spending the night.
The islands reward slow exploring.
My plan would be simple. Pick up sandwiches, paddle or bike for a bit, then hit a scenic overlook.
Vermont makes that kind of day feel effortless, and I’m sure you’ll want a second sandwich before heading home.






