9 Best Places In Long Island, New York To Grab A Burger This Year
Long Island has a food identity that extends considerably beyond its clam bars and its wine country, and the burger scene is one of the more convincing arguments for that case.
Each spot on this list has earned its place through the burger specifically, which is the only credential that matters when you’re hungry and no Snickers is nearby.
What separates a Long Island burger worth seeking out from one that merely fills a gap in the afternoon comes down to a handful of decisions made before the patty ever meets the grill.
The places on this list have solved all burger problems with varying personalities and consistent results.
Some lean classic. Some lean creative.
All of them lean toward the kind of burger that generates a specific and immediate craving on the drive home.
These Long Island burger spots have figured out something the rest of New York is still catching up to and the proof is in every single bite.
1. Smash House 5 Towns
Crispy edges are everything in the smash burger world, and Smash House 5 Towns absolutely delivers on that promise. The patties are pressed hard against the griddle, creating those golden, lacy edges that make smash burgers so addictive.
Every bite has a satisfying crunch followed by a juicy, beefy center that keeps you going back for more.
The spot sits at 594 Central Ave, Cedarhurst, NY 11516, right in the heart of the 5 Towns area. It has earned a 4.8 rating, which is no small feat in a place where people take their burgers seriously.
The sauces are layered just right, and nothing feels like an afterthought on the menu.
Fans consistently call these the best smash burgers they have ever had, and after one visit, it is easy to understand why. The staff moves with real energy, and the food comes out fast without cutting any corners.
Smash House 5 Towns is the kind of place that turns a regular Tuesday into something worth talking about. Bring your appetite and a little extra patience for the line because it is absolutely worth the wait.
2. Peri Peri Grill House
Peri Peri Grill House in Bethpage is doing something genuinely different with its burger game. Known mainly for bold, spicy peri peri flavors, the restaurant brings that same fiery energy straight to its smash burger.
The sauce is the star of the show here, adding a punchy, tangy kick that you will not find at most burger spots on Long Island.
Find it at 629 Hicksville Rd, Bethpage, NY 11714, a solid stop if you are moving through the mid-island area. It holds an impressive 4.9 rating, which tells you that people are not just stopping by once.
The chicken burger is also worth ordering if you want to mix things up from the beef options.
The menu is not overwhelming, which is actually a good sign. A focused menu usually means every item gets proper attention, and that is exactly the case here.
The smash burger has been called flat-out good by the people who have had it, and the sauce situation alone makes it a standout. Peri Peri Grill House proves that a great burger does not always have to follow the traditional playbook to win big.
3. 7th Street Burger
7th Street Burger has been making serious noise in the New York burger scene, and its Mineola location on Long Island is no exception. The brand built its reputation on classic smash-style burgers made with quality beef and a no-nonsense approach to flavor.
Every burger is straightforward but executed with a level of care that shows someone back there actually cares about the craft.
The address is 524 Jericho Tpke, Mineola, NY 11501, which puts it in a convenient spot for anyone traveling through Nassau County. The restaurant keeps things clean and simple inside, letting the food do most of the talking.
The fries are crispy and well-seasoned, making them a natural companion to any burger on the menu.
If you have ever had a 7th Street Burger in New York City and wondered if the Long Island location holds up, the answer is yes. The smash patties come out with that perfect caramelized crust every single time.
The double smash is the move if you are coming in hungry, and the milkshakes are thick enough to make a spoon feel necessary. Go during off-peak hours if you want a calmer experience without sacrificing any of the quality.
4. NY Burger Shack
Out in Medford, NY Burger Shack is the kind of spot that reminds you why simple things done well will always win. The burgers here are no-fuss and full of flavor, built for people who want a satisfying meal without a complicated menu.
There is something deeply comforting about a burger shack that just gets it right every single time.
You can find it at 2080 NY-112, Medford, NY 11763, which makes it a great pitstop for anyone in Suffolk County looking for a quality meal without a long detour.
The portions are generous and the prices are reasonable, which is a combination that never gets old.
The atmosphere is casual and relaxed, making it easy to enjoy your food without any fuss.
NY Burger Shack keeps a loyal following because it delivers consistency, and in the burger world, consistency is everything. The beef is fresh and the toppings are always on point, with nothing feeling like it came out of a bag.
A great cheeseburger from here hits differently on a warm Long Island afternoon. Pack some napkins because things are going to get a little messy, and that is exactly how it should be.
5. Burger Village
Burger Village in Deer Park brings a more elevated take to the Long Island burger scene without losing the fun and casual energy that makes burger spots so enjoyable.
The menu features creative combinations that go beyond your standard cheeseburger, giving adventurous eaters plenty of reasons to come back and try something new.
Each burger feels like it was put together with genuine thought and a clear love for bold flavor.
Head over to 152 The Arches Cir, Suite 1002, Deer Park, NY 11729 to find it inside The Arches shopping center. The location makes it an easy stop to pair with a shopping trip, but the food is good enough to justify a standalone visit.
The inside is clean, well-lit, and comfortable, making it a solid option for families and groups.
The patties are thick and cooked to order, which is a detail that separates the serious burger joints from the forgettable ones. Burger Village also does not sleep on its sides, with fries and other options that complement the main event well.
The staff is friendly and the service moves at a good pace. If Deer Park is your stomping ground in New York, this spot should already be in your regular rotation.
6. No Good Burger Joint
The name sounds like a warning, but No Good Burger Joint is actually one of the highest-rated burger spots in all of New York State. Yelp named it the best burger in New York, and Eat This, Not That ranked it the number one burger restaurant in the state.
That is not a small achievement, and one bite of the double smash burger makes the hype feel completely justified.
The Baldwin location sits at 930 Atlantic Ave, Baldwin, NY 11510, and it also has a presence in Rockville Centre along with food trucks rolling around Long Island. The beef is ground fresh in-house daily, which is the kind of detail that separates a truly great burger from an ordinary one.
The double smashburger with cheese, pickles, and smash sauce is the signature move here.
More than eight specialty burgers are on the menu, so there is always something to explore beyond the classic order. The atmosphere is lively and the energy inside the restaurant matches the reputation perfectly.
No Good Burger Joint has earned every single bit of its buzz through quality and consistency. If you have not been yet, you are genuinely missing out on one of Long Island’s greatest burger experiences.
7. Black Label Burgers
Black Label Burgers in Westbury carries a name that sets a high expectation, and the food backs it up with confidence. The burgers here have a premium feel from the quality of the beef to the way the toppings are layered with intention.
It is the kind of burger spot where you feel like you are getting more than just a meal, you are getting an experience built around real craft.
The restaurant is at 683 Old Country Rd, Westbury, NY 11590, making it easy to reach from multiple points across Nassau County.
The menu covers a solid range of burger styles, giving first-timers and regulars alike something to get excited about on every visit.
The fries and sides hold their own and pair well with any selection from the main menu.
Black Label Burgers has built a following among Long Island locals who appreciate quality over quantity. The atmosphere inside is comfortable without being overly formal, hitting that sweet spot between a casual hangout and a genuinely good dining experience.
The beef is always fresh and the flavors are bold without being overdone. For anyone in the Westbury area who has not made the trip yet, consider this your official signal to go sooner rather than later.
8. Lusi’s Burgers, Dogs, Fries And Shakes
Right on Fire Island Ave in Babylon, Lusi’s Burgers, Dogs, Fries and Shakes has the kind of laid-back coastal energy that makes every burger taste just a little bit better.
The menu is exactly what the name promises, focused and fun, with no unnecessary fluff getting in the way of the main attraction.
It is a spot built for people who know what they want and want it done right.
You will find it at 504 Fire Island Ave, Babylon, NY 11702, which gives it a fantastic setting close to the water and the relaxed South Shore atmosphere.
The burgers are fresh and satisfying, the fries are crispy, and the shakes are thick and creamy enough to make you slow down and enjoy every sip.
The hot dogs are also worth a mention for anyone who wants to mix things up.
Lusi’s has that neighborhood gem quality where the regulars come in knowing exactly what they are ordering before they even reach the counter. The prices are fair and the portions are generous, which keeps everyone leaving happy.
On a warm Long Island afternoon, a burger and shake from Lusi’s feels like the most perfect combination possible. This spot is a genuine South Shore treasure worth every visit.
9. Burgerology Massapequa
Burgerology Massapequa takes the concept of a craft burger and runs with it in the most exciting direction possible. The brand describes its approach as science meets flavor, and that philosophy shows up in every carefully constructed burger on the menu.
Bold combinations, unexpected toppings, and house-made sauces make each visit feel like a discovery rather than just a meal.
Find the Massapequa location at 4225 Merrick Rd, Massapequa, NY 11758, a solid anchor on the South Shore of Long Island’s burger map. The restaurant has a modern, energetic atmosphere that matches the creativity happening in the kitchen.
Custom-crafted patties paired with artisan toppings give regulars plenty of reasons to keep coming back and trying new things.
Burgerology has multiple locations across Long Island, but the Massapequa spot holds its own with a loyal local crowd that appreciates the bold flavor philosophy.
The shakes are indulgent and worth ordering alongside your burger, completing the full experience the right way.
For anyone who finds standard burger menus a little too predictable, Burgerology is the answer. The food is fun, the flavors are serious, and the whole experience feels like eating at a place that genuinely loves what it does.
Long Island is lucky to have it.