Skip to content

Indiana Donut Shop Serves Giant Apple And Peach Fritters That Give Sweet Tooths A Treat

An apple fritter roughly the size of a salad plate sounds like a dare. In one Indiana town, it’s simply breakfast.

The fritter comes loaded with tender chunks of cinnamon-kissed apple. A crackly glaze coats the outside, and the dough manages to feel dense and light at once.

As it happens, the fritter isn’t even the whole show. The same family-run counter turns out maple bacon long johns, a donut that tastes a lot like pancakes and syrup, and homemade treats for your dog.

I can’t help but think a bakery that feeds the whole household deserves a closer look. So how did one small shop near the interstate earn this much sugary loyalty?

That Fritter Might Need Its Own Chair At The Table

That Fritter Might Need Its Own Chair At The Table
© Titus Bakery

Size is the first thing to know about the apple fritter at Titus Bakery and Deli. Some folks compare it to a salad plate, and others call it a full meal.

Inside, tender chunks of apple carry a warm hit of cinnamon. Outside, a crackly glaze gives every bite a little snap before the soft dough takes over.

The texture is the clever part. The dough is described as both dense and light, which sounds impossible until you consider how much apple it holds.

Sharing is a smart move here. One fritter can easily split between two people, or three if someone is being polite.

The menu also lists a Cinnamon and Cherry-Filled fritter for anyone craving a tart twist. Seasonal fritter flavors have shown up too, so the case can change through the year.

Peach fans should ask at the counter rather than assume. Flavors rotate, and a quick question beats a sad face.

Plan to grab one early in the day. Popular bakery items can sell out, and nobody wants to stare at the empty spot where a fritter used to be.

Pancakes And Syrup Somehow Turned Into A Donut

Pancakes And Syrup Somehow Turned Into A Donut
© Titus Bakery

Ask around about Titus Bakery’s signature donut and one name keeps coming up. Meet the Pershing, a maple-iced pastry with a cinnamon swirl rolled right through it.

The flavor combo lands somewhere close to a stack of pancakes with syrup. That’s a pretty bold promise for something you can hold in one hand.

Maple lovers have more to explore. The Maple Bacon Long John pairs sweet icing with salty bacon, and it makes a strong case for breakfast in one bite.

Peanut butter fans get their own reward with the Peanut Butter Fluff Long John. It reads like a lunchbox sandwich that decided to go to a party.

The donut lineup is homemade and award-winning. Titus has picked up honors at WIBC’s National Donut Day and the Indy Donut Festival, which is no small feat in a donut-loving state.

First-timers face a real decision problem here. The easy fix is ordering a Pershing plus one wild card, then trading bites with whoever came along.

Indecision is basically part of the fun.

A Family Recipe Book That Started Back In The 1950s

A Family Recipe Book That Started Back In The 1950s
© Titus Bakery

Long before the drive-thru and the bright mural, the family was already baking. Their tradition traces back to the 1950s under the name Titus Pastries.

Bill Titus bought the Lebanon shop in 1980. That’s a lot of early mornings and a mountain of flour since then.

In 2012, his daughter Terry Rake took the reins. She renamed the business Titus Bakery and widened the menu with cakes, pies, cookies, and more.

Two years later, a deli joined the party. The family clearly figured people would want lunch after all that sugar.

Growth didn’t stop in Lebanon either. Titus expanded with shops in Westfield and Atlanta, Indiana, while keeping the original spot humming.

January 2020 marked 40 years at this location. Few small businesses reach that milestone, and fewer do it while staying in the same family.

I’ve always felt that history tastes better when you can still order it. Here, the recipes and the family name both carry forward into a third generation.

That kind of staying power says plenty about what comes out of those ovens.

Hot Pink Walls Make This Place Impossible To Miss

Hot Pink Walls Make This Place Impossible To Miss
© Titus Bakery

Nobody needs GPS help once the mural comes into view. The outside of the building shows off a doughnut-themed design set against a hot-pink background.

It works as both art and a giant sign. Driving past without craving something sweet feels nearly impossible.

You’ll find all that color at 820 W South St, Lebanon, IN 46052. The shop sits just minutes from I-65, which makes it handy for road-trippers.

Inside, the mood changes a bit. Cozy wooden paneling meets turquoise walls, giving the room a cheerful but homey feel.

The pink-and-turquoise combo sounds bold on paper. In practice, it fits a bakery that clearly enjoys having fun with its treats.

Bring your camera before you bring your appetite inside. The mural makes a fun backdrop for a quick photo with a fritter in hand.

Just keep the picture short. Glaze waits for no one, and a fritter tastes best before it becomes a photo shoot prop.

Honestly, a building this bright almost dares you to stop. Most sweet tooths won’t argue with that challenge.

Lunch Shows Up On Homemade Hoagie Buns

Lunch Shows Up On Homemade Hoagie Buns
© Titus Bakery

Plenty of donut shops stop at donuts. Titus Bakery and Deli added a full delicatessen in 2014, and it changed the lunch math in Lebanon.

The deli uses Boar’s Head brand meats and cheeses. Those fillings go onto homemade hoagie buns, which makes sense for a place that bakes all day.

Four signature sandwiches anchor the menu. Box lunches are also available, handy for office meetings or a picnic at a nearby park.

This is where the place gets sneaky. A savory lunch leaves you sitting right next to the donut case.

Resisting dessert after a sandwich takes serious willpower. Most people would probably call a fritter a reasonable side dish anyway.

Timing matters if you want lunch here. The shop closes at 6 pm on weekdays and 2 pm on Saturdays, so plan around those hours.

Sundays are off the table completely. Lebanon gets a day of rest from frosting.

For travelers heading down Indiana’s interstate, a sandwich here beats yet another fast-food bag. It’s a real lunch stop with a dessert bonus built in.

Cream Horns, Cannoli, And A Whole Lot Of Maybe

Cream Horns, Cannoli, And A Whole Lot Of Maybe
© Titus Bakery

Donuts get the spotlight, but the bakery case runs much deeper. Cakes, pies, cookies, muffins, and danishes all share space behind the glass.

Cinnamon rolls and pecan rolls hold down the classic side. Turnovers, cannoli, and cream horns bring a little extra flair.

That variety came after Terry Rake took over in 2012. She pushed the shop beyond pastries into a full-service bakery.

Celebrations are covered too. Custom cakes can be ordered, which saves you from a dull grocery-store sheet cake at the next birthday.

Picking just one item feels nearly impossible. A mixed box solves that problem and keeps everyone at home happy.

Decorated cookies make a fun gift for teachers or coworkers. They travel well, which matters if your drive home runs long.

Here’s a practical tip worth remembering. Pre-order pickup starts at 5 am, an hour before the doors open.

That early window helps a lot when you need dozens for a morning event. You grab your boxes and become the office hero before most people finish their first coffee.

Your Dog Is Getting A Bakery Bag Too

Your Dog Is Getting A Bakery Bag Too
© Titus Bakery

Good news for four-legged fans. Titus Bakery makes homemade dog treats, so the pup in the back seat doesn’t have to sulk.

That’s a thoughtful touch for road trips. Everyone in the car gets a reward, even the one with a tail.

Popcorn is another surprise on the shelves. The bakery produces its own line, giving you a salty break from all that glaze.

A bag of popcorn makes a solid snack for later. It also works as a smart gift for someone who isn’t big on sweets.

Coffee fans have options too. Titus serves its own brand of coffee, along with specialty drinks.

Fountain drinks, bottled water, juice, and milk round out the drink list. Milk and a donut remains one of life’s best simple pairings.

Gift cards are available as well, either in store or by mail. That’s an easy present for any friend who loves a good fritter.

Bundle a gift card with a bag of popcorn, and you’ve got a gift basket. Add dog treats if the friend has a pup.

Skip The Parking Spot And Roll Through Instead

Skip The Parking Spot And Roll Through Instead
© Titus Bakery

Mornings get busy, and Titus Bakery seems to understand that. A drive-thru lets you grab a dozen without unbuckling.

Those who’d rather linger can stay inside. Dine-in seating offers room for a cupcake and coffee or a full sandwich lunch.

The shop is wheelchair accessible, which helps every visitor feel welcome. Credit cards are accepted, so there’s no scramble for cash.

Doors open at 6 am Monday through Friday and stay open until 6 pm. Saturday runs from 6 am until 2 pm.

Sunday is closed, so mark your calendar. Weekend road-trippers should time their visit for Saturday morning.

Can’t make it in person at all? Delivery and pickup are available through Grubhub and Uber Eats.

Catering is another handy option for bigger groups. Deli trays, large coffee service, and donuts by the dozen can feed a crowd fast.

That flexibility makes this Indiana bakery easy to fit into almost any plan. Whether it’s a quick window stop or a long sit-down, the fritter tastes just as good.

Sweet Treats That Give Back To The Neighbors

Sweet Treats That Give Back To The Neighbors
© Titus Bakery

A bakery’s reputation isn’t built on sugar alone. Titus Bakery and Deli regularly donates to non-profits and good causes around its communities.

That generosity earned real recognition. In 2018, the Boone County Chamber of Commerce gave the bakery its Impact Award.

It fits the family story nicely. A business rooted in one town since 1980 tends to care about the people who keep walking through the door.

Every purchase supports a local, family-run shop. That beats handing your money to a faceless chain off the highway exit.

Indiana has no shortage of road-trip snacks. Few of them come with this much history and hometown heart, though.

So stop for the giant fritter, and stay for the Pershing. Leave with a box for friends, plus a treat for the dog.

The hot-pink mural will wave you in. The family recipes will probably bring you back.

Honestly, the only hard part is choosing. Maybe the right answer is a fritter now and a second stop on the way home, because nobody should ever drive past a fritter this size twice.