Skip to content

Locals Know This Wisconsin Italian Restaurant Is Worth Visiting With An Empty Stomach

A steak pizza with no red sauce at all, just garlic and olive oil under the cheese. That was enough to grab my attention. Then I learned the tenderloin, red onions, mushrooms, and red peppers ride on top.

The family behind this Wisconsin pizzeria started learning the kitchen at ages eight and ten. Their recipes come from a name tied to local Italian cooking since the 1950s. I appreciate a menu with that kind of backstory.

The salad alone sounds like a group project. It comes loaded with pepperoni, black olives, pepperoncini, tomatoes, and cheese. Add baked pasta, homemade meatballs, and thin-crust pies, and the math gets tricky fast.

There’s also a patio with a skyline view. Summer fireworks show up there too. So how exactly do you plan an order when everything sounds this good?

A Family Recipe Story You Can Actually Taste

A Family Recipe Story You Can Actually Taste
© Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes – 1211 E Conway St, Milwaukee, WI 53207

Some family stories get told at holidays. At Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes, the story gets served on a pizza board.

The DeMarinis name has been tied to Italian cooking in Milwaukee since the 1950s. Brothers Dominic and Phillip grew up inside that world, working in the kitchen from ages eight and ten.

Their family was behind the earlier Mama DeMarinis restaurant. In 1996, the brothers went on to open their own place. So the brothers opened their own place that same year.

The name says exactly what they brought along. Original recipes, carried over from the family kitchen and kept going for decades.

Families can be complicated, and this one had its share of disagreements. Yet the recipes held steady through all of it. Today the next generation is part of the story. Daughters Lucia and Anna Maria are partners in the business.

That kind of continuity matters in a neighborhood restaurant. It means the pizza your parents ordered might taste the way it always did.

I love that the whole history fits inside one sign. Dom and Phil are right there in the name, and their recipes are still running the show.

That Crust Can’t Decide What It Wants To Be, And It’s Perfect

That Crust Can't Decide What It Wants To Be, And It's Perfect
© Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes

Thin crust or soft crust? Here, the answer is somehow both. The pizza at this Wisconsin favorite uses a hybrid style. The base stays soft and pillowy, while the edges turn crispy and curl up the pan.

That curl is a big deal for crust lovers. It gives every slice a crunchy border without turning the whole thing into a cracker. The restaurant is widely known for its thin-crust pies. House specialty pizzas lean on simple ingredients rather than piles of fancy extras.

Start with the #1 Pizza if you want a classic. It brings sausage, mushroom, and onion together in one familiar lineup. The sausage deserves its own mention. It’s often described as closer to a meatball than a typical crumble.

That’s a fun twist for anyone who loves meatballs. You basically get a little bit of Sunday dinner on every slice.

Pizzas arrive on wooden boards at the table. It’s an old-school touch that fits the family recipe vibe. My advice? Order one classic pie and one wild card. The crust is the star either way, so you really can’t lose.

Skip The Red Sauce Once And Meet The Steak Compobasa

Skip The Red Sauce Once And Meet The Steak Compobasa
© Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes

Garlic and olive oil take over where the marinara usually sits. That one swap makes the Steak Compobasa Pizza stand out on the menu. Mozzarella melts over that garlicky base. Then come tenderloin steak, red onions, mushrooms, and red peppers.

It reads almost like a steak dinner that decided to become a pizza. Honestly, I respect the ambition.

Without red sauce, the toppings get more of the spotlight. The garlic and olive oil keep things rich without hiding the steak. Steak pizza pops up often when people talk about this spot. It’s a smart pick when your table already has a classic sausage pie covered.

Pizzas come in different sizes, including a junior option. That helps if you want to sample this one alongside pasta or appetizers. Leftovers are part of the plan here, too. A steak pizza for breakfast sounds like a pretty great next morning.

Bring a friend who always orders the same thing. Hand them a slice of this and watch their routine get shaken up. It’s proof that a family recipe menu can still surprise you. Sometimes the best move is leaving the sauce out.

The Pasta Side Of The Menu Pulls Serious Weight

The Pasta Side Of The Menu Pulls Serious Weight
© Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes – 1211 E Conway St, Milwaukee, WI 53207

Lasagna made from an original family recipe is reason enough to look past the pizza list. The DeMarinis House Made Lasagna layers Italian sausage, mozzarella, parmesan, and marinara between the noodles.

Baked Mostaccioli is another heavy hitter. It brings Italian sausage and melted mozzarella over mostaccioli noodles with marinara. Baked pasta covered in cheese is pure comfort. It’s the kind of dish that makes a chilly Milwaukee night feel friendlier.

Meat ravioli are available with marinara, and you can order them with meatballs. That’s ravioli and meatballs on one plate, which feels like a smart deal for your appetite.

Classic fans can keep it simple. Spaghetti or mostaccioli can come with meatballs or Italian sausage.

Notice a pattern? Sausage and meatballs show up all over this menu, and the kitchen clearly takes them seriously. Freshly made pastas are part of what the restaurant is known for. That gives non-pizza people plenty of options at the table.

Here’s a tip for groups. Split a pizza and a baked pasta so everyone gets a taste of both sides of the kitchen. Your leftovers container will thank you later.

Start With A Salad Big Enough To Need Its Own Chair

Start With A Salad Big Enough To Need Its Own Chair
© Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes – 1211 E Conway St, Milwaukee, WI 53207

Massive is the word that keeps coming up with the Family Style Italian Salad. It’s topped with lettuce, tomatoes, cheese, black olives, pepperoncini, and pepperoni. Treat it like a shared starter. One bowl can easily set the tone for a whole table.

A smaller dinner salad is on the menu too. That’s handy when you want greens without a full-blown salad project. Now for the appetizers, which make patience very difficult. Breaded Mozzarella Ala DeMarinis is a popular starter, served with sauce.

Garlic bread is available with or without sauce. Garlic cheese bread also gets plenty of love around here. Deep-fried breaded ravioli come four to an order with sauce. It’s ravioli dressed up for a party.

The Meatball Appetizer might be the coziest choice. You get three homemade meatballs in marinara with Italian bread and butter.

Here’s my honest warning. Order too many starters and your pizza may become tomorrow’s lunch. Then again, is that really a problem? Cold leftover pizza has a loyal fan club of its own.

Friday Nights Bring A Wisconsin Tradition To The Table

Friday Nights Bring A Wisconsin Tradition To The Table
© Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes

Wisconsin and the Friday fish fry go together like pizza and a wooden board. This Italian kitchen joins the tradition with its own Friday fish fry.

That makes Friday a fun night to bring a mixed crowd. One person can go for fish while someone else grabs a pie. Friday hours also run later than midweek. The kitchen stays open until 10 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.

Not feeling fish or pizza? The sandwich lineup has you covered.

A Meatball Sandwich features the restaurant’s meatballs, with cheese available as an option. It’s simple, saucy, and very on brand for this kitchen.

The DeMarinis Original Sausage Sandwich comes on Italian bread. Given how much love the sausage gets here, it’s a natural pick.

Sandwiches make sense for smaller appetites, too. They’re a good way to taste those famous meats without ordering a full pizza.

I like that the menu respects local habits. An Italian spot running a Friday fish fry feels very Milwaukee in the best way. Plan ahead, though. Fridays at a beloved neighborhood restaurant can be a popular choice for families.

Low Lights, Old-School Charm, And Plenty Of Family Chatter

Low Lights, Old-School Charm, And Plenty Of Family Chatter
© Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes

Trendy design isn’t the point here, and that’s part of the charm. The dining room leans cozy and old-school, with decor that feels lived-in rather than worn out.

Low lighting keeps things relaxed. It’s the kind of room where a pizza dinner can stretch into a long conversation. Things can get lively, especially when families pack in. Expect a happy buzz rather than a hushed fine-dining hush.

That energy fits a family-owned restaurant. Kids, parents, and grandparents all seem right at home in a place like this.

Besides the dining room, there’s also a lounge area. That gives you a slightly different setting depending on your mood. Wooden boards land on the table for the pizza. It’s a small detail, but it adds to the classic pizzeria feeling.

Celebrating something? The restaurant can host small gatherings and birthday parties for up to 30 people. Reservations are accepted, which is a big help for groups. Nobody wants to wait hungry with a crowd of cousins.

I appreciate a place that knows what it is. Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes feels comfortable in its own skin.

Grab A Patio Seat For Skyline Views And Summer Fireworks

Grab A Patio Seat For Skyline Views And Summer Fireworks
© Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes

Milwaukee’s skyline makes a pretty great dinner backdrop. The outdoor patio here offers views of the city. That alone makes a summer evening feel special. Pizza tastes even better with fresh air and a view.

Then the fireworks enter the picture. In summer, the patio is a popular spot to watch them light up the sky. Honestly, it’s hard to beat that combo. Thin-crust pizza, a breeze, and a sky full of color sounds like a top-tier Wisconsin night.

The restaurant sits in Bay View, one of Milwaukee’s well-loved neighborhoods. You’ll find it at 1211 E Conway St, Milwaukee, WI 53207. Street parking is available for guests. Give yourself a few extra minutes on busy evenings to find a spot.

Patio weather in Wisconsin doesn’t last all year. When those warm nights arrive, this is a smart place to spend one.

Planning a fireworks night? Arrive early and settle your order before the show starts. You’ll want your hands free for the sky, not stuck flagging down another basket of garlic bread.

Plan Your Visit Around These Hours And Handy Extras

Plan Your Visit Around These Hours And Handy Extras
© Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes

Mondays and Tuesdays are off-limits, so mark your calendar wisely. Dom & Phil DeMarinis Original Recipes opens Wednesday through Sunday.

Wednesday and Thursday run from 4 PM to 9 PM. Friday and Saturday stretch to 10 PM. Sunday starts a little earlier, at 3 PM, and wraps at 9 PM. That’s perfect for an early family dinner before the workweek.

Can’t stay to eat? Takeout is available, so your pizza can ride home with you. Catering is another option for bigger plans. It’s pick-up only and needs 48 hours of notice.

Picture a party table loaded with baked pasta and meatballs. Your guests will remember that spread. The family has served Bay View and West Allis for many years. That long run says a lot about this Wisconsin favorite.

Reservations help on busy nights, especially for groups. A quick plan keeps the evening smooth. My final tip is simple. Skip the big lunch, show up ready to share, and let the original recipes take it from there.