9 Massachusetts Bakeries Where Pies Are Worth Waiting In Line For
A pie shop on Cape Cod sells seafood pie and lobster rolls right next to its strawberry rhubarb. That combo alone made me sit up and pay attention.
Then I learned about a bakery where people once lined up for hours in the cold, two days before Thanksgiving. Another shop keeps freezers stocked with ready-to-bake pies, and they still sell out. I love that kind of devotion. It tells you the crust is doing something right.
Massachusetts takes its pie seriously. Apple country, berry farms, and old family recipes all play a part. The best shops turn a simple slice into a reason to set an alarm.
I rounded up nine bakeries where the wait seems to pay off. Some sit on farms, some on busy city streets, and some near the beach. So which line are you joining first?
1. Centerville Pie Company
Cape Cod beaches get the postcards, but this little pie shop deserves a few too. Centerville Pie Company bakes both sweet and savory pies with signature crusts.
The Chicken Pot Pie is one of its standout menu items. It’s the kind of dinner that makes cooking feel optional.
On the sweet side, Apple Pie earns a spot in the spotlight. The apple crumble version has a strong holiday following, especially around Thanksgiving.
Chocolate cream pie is another big draw. If you like a smooth, rich slice, this one belongs on your list.
The owners make their pies by hand. They’ll even make special pies for customers with food allergies, which is a thoughtful touch.
The shop also works as a breakfast and lunch stop. Coffee is available, so you can fuel up before your next beach walk.
Keep in mind that this is a grab-and-go place. There’s no dine-in, so plan to enjoy your treats somewhere scenic.
Delivery, takeout, and in-store pickup are all options. A free parking lot makes stopping by pretty painless.
Timing matters if you hate crowds. Monday mornings get the busiest, while Wednesdays and weekend mornings tend to be quieter.
Hours run Monday through Saturday from 8 AM to 5 PM. Sundays are shorter, from 9 AM to 3 PM.
Address: 1671 Falmouth Rd, Centerville, MA 02632
2. Petsi Pies
Pecan pie fans, meet your new obsession. The Brown Butter Pecan Pie here comes from an old family recipe.
Petsi Pies has served Somerville since 2003. It’s an independent bakery and coffee bar with a serious focus on handmade pies.
You can grab pies in 5-, 8-, and 10-inch sizes. That 5-inch size is perfect when you want a pie all to yourself and zero judgment.
The fruit lineup reads like a farmers market. Classic Apple uses Granny Smith and Cortland apples, while the Blueberry Pie features wild Maine blueberries.
Cherry Crumb Pie leans tart with Michigan cherries. Mixed Berry brings blueberries, raspberries, and blackberries together in one flaky package.
Chocolate lovers get the Mississippi Mud Pie. It packs Belgian chocolate and a brownie streusel, which sounds like dessert wearing a second dessert as a hat.
Savory cravings? The Chicken Pot Pie has you covered, and vegan pot pies are on the menu too.
Vegan fruit pies are available by online order. Frozen take-and-bake pies also let you stash a little backup happiness in your freezer.
Want it a la mode? The bakery partners with Gracie’s Ice Cream, so the scoop is part of the plan.
Here’s a handy tip for timing. Saturdays get the busiest, while weekday mornings like Monday and Tuesday tend to be calmer.
Thanksgiving week is a whole different story, so order early. Free street parking helps when you’re making a quick pie run.
Address: 285 Beacon St, Somerville, MA 02143
3. Drive-By Pies
A mom’s award-winning pie dough recipe sits at the heart of this Brookline shop. Honestly, that’s the best kind of family secret.
Drive-By Pies uses real butter and fresh, handmade ingredients daily. You can taste the care in a crust like that.
The sweet menu is long and tempting. Think Chocolate, Banana, Coconut Cream, Blueberry, Apple, Peach, Strawberry Rhubarb, Pumpkin, Key Lime, and Pecan.
Savory fans aren’t left out at all. Chicken Pot Pies, Buffalo Chicken Meat Pies, Veggie Pies, Meat Pies, and quiches all show up here.
Need a pie for a crowd or just for you? Choose a 5-inch mini or a 9-inch full pie.
Full pies usually need about 24 hours notice. A quick call ahead saves you from a sad, pie-less afternoon.
This place also works as a breakfast and lunch stop. Breakfast sandwiches, soups, and salads share space with cookies, eclairs, scones, and muffins.
The coconut seven-layer bars are worth a look too. So are the apple turnovers if you want a handheld treat.
Plenty of families rely on this shop for Thanksgiving pies. Ordering a mix of pies and desserts makes holiday planning much easier.
Watch the hours, because they’re short. The shop opens at 8 AM most days, closes early Monday and Saturday, and stays closed Sunday.
Address: 248A Cypress St, Brookline, MA 02445
4. Marion’s Pie Shop
Seafood pie and a lobster roll at a pie shop? Welcome to Chatham, where the menu clearly knows it’s near the ocean.
Marion’s Pie Shop is a long-running counter-service spot on Main Street. It serves housemade pies plus comfort food like lasagna.
The Strawberry Rhubarb Pie is a menu highlight. Its flaky, buttery crust and balanced filling make it an easy first pick.
Fruit fans should also look for the Nolan B Peach and Raspberry. Dutch apple and lemon meringue have their own loyal crowds.
Chocolate cream pie lovers get a rich, smooth option here. It’s the kind of slice that disappears faster than you planned.
On the savory side, the Seafood Pie and Chicken Pot Pie steal attention. Both make great take-home dinners after a beach day.
Don’t skip the cinnamon rolls or the Chatham muffin. The 7 layer bar is another sweet way to round out your bag.
Here’s a smart tip from Cape regulars. Bring a cooler, because you may leave with more food than expected.
The shop is takeout only, with no dine-in or delivery. Sunday mornings and Saturday afternoons get the busiest, so aim for a Tuesday afternoon instead.
It’s closed Mondays. The other days open at 8 AM, with Sunday closing an hour earlier than the rest.
Address: 2022 Main St, Chatham, MA 02633
5. Colarusso’s Bakery
Ricotta pie might be the most underrated pie in Massachusetts. At this Stoneham bakery, it’s one of the stars.
Colarusso’s Bakery is a longtime, family-run Italian bakeshop. Pastries, breads, cookies, and cakes fill out the lineup.
If you’ve never tried ricotta pie, now’s your chance. It’s a classic Italian treat that feels both simple and special.
Pecan pie is another favorite here, especially for Thanksgiving. The bakery can handle big orders, too, even dozens of pies at once.
That makes it a handy pick for office parties or big family gatherings. Nobody wants to be the person who forgot dessert.
While you wait, scan the pastry case. Lobster tails are a popular Italian pastry, and they’re a fun bonus for your box.
Cookies make an easy add-on for the ride home. The Chocolate Drip Cake is a menu highlight if you’re celebrating something bigger.
This is a takeout bakery with no dine-in seating. A free parking lot keeps the pickup simple.
Saturdays get the busiest, from morning through the afternoon. Weekday mornings and Sunday mornings tend to be quieter.
Hours run Monday through Saturday from 8 AM to 6 PM. Sunday closes at 5 PM.
Address: 210 Main St, Stoneham, MA 02180
6. Shugah Hill Bakery
Wedding cakes might be the headline act, but the pies here deserve their own applause. Key Lime Pie is one of the bakery’s menu highlights.
Shugah Hill Bakery makes custom cakes from scratch in Hanover. It also offers a range of artisanal pastries and coffee.
That tart, creamy Key Lime Pie makes a great break from heavy fall flavors. It’s sunshine on a plate, even in a New England winter.
Around the holidays, the bakery handles Thanksgiving pie orders. Families often pair those pies with other holiday desserts from the same shop.
Carrot cake is another standout on the menu. So if your crew can’t agree on pie, you’ve got a solid backup.
Planning a party? The bakery takes corporate event orders along with wedding cakes.
It also works as a breakfast spot. Grab a coffee and pastry while you pick up your order.
Free parking makes stopping by easy on a busy South Shore day. This is a quick-visit kind of place, ideal for errands.
Check the hours before heading over. It’s closed Mondays and closes at 1 PM on Tuesdays.
Wednesday through Sunday, it opens at 7 AM and runs until 5 PM. Early birds definitely get the first pick here.
Address: 352 Columbia Rd Unit C, Hanover, MA 02339
7. Ever So Humble Pie Co
Picture-perfect pie, without turning on the oven until you want to? This East Walpole shop makes that wish pretty easy.
Ever So Humble Pie Co sells handmade pies as frozen ready-to-bake or fully baked thaw-and-serve. They come in four sizes.
The company has been in business for more than 25 years. It was also named the Best Pie Company in Massachusetts by 24/7 Wall Street.
Classic dessert lovers can go for New England Apple Pie or Wild Blueberry Pie. Butter pecan pie is another one to watch for.
Here’s where things get savory and fun. Zucchini Frittata, Bacon Cheddar Frittata, and Mac and Cheese Pie all sit on the menu.
Meat pie fans have choices too. Canadian Meat Pie, Chicken Pot Pie, and Shepherd’s Pie make dinner almost effortless.
The shop supports local producers for its apples and peaches. Fresh scones are another reason to swing by.
Popular pies can sell out, so timing matters. Coming early gives you the best shot at your favorite flavor.
Retail hours are short, so plan ahead. It’s open Tuesday through Friday from 8 AM to 4 PM and Saturday from 8 AM to noon.
Sundays and Mondays are closed. Gift certificates make a sweet present for the pie lover in your life.
Address: 153 Washington St, East Walpole, MA 02032
8. Mann Orchards
Apple pie tastes a little better when the apple trees are right outside. That’s the whole charm of this Methuen orchard.
Mann Orchards combines apple-picking, a farm market, and a bakery in one stop. It’s a full outing, not just a pie errand.
The apple pies are the big reason people show up. They’re a go-to choice for holidays and gatherings of all kinds.
Thanksgiving is when demand really climbs. Some families call weeks in advance to get their orders in.
So take the hint and plan early. Waiting until the last minute could leave you staring at an empty table.
The farm market sells produce and other goods too. You can pick up something for dinner along with dessert.
Apple-picking season makes a visit extra fun. Picking your own fruit and then buying a pie feels like a fair trade.
Kids and grownups both tend to enjoy orchard trips. It’s a classic Massachusetts fall tradition for a reason.
Hours run Monday through Saturday from 8 AM to 6 PM. Sundays are open from 8 AM to 5 PM.
That early start is great news for pie planners. Grab yours in the morning and you’re the hero of the evening.
Address: 27 Pleasant Valley St, Methuen, MA 01844
9. Flour Bakery + Cafe
Long lines in Boston usually mean sports tickets or brunch. At this Back Bay bakery, they mean pastry.
Flour Bakery + Cafe is part of a local group of bake shops known for French treats. Croissants and sticky buns are big reasons people line up.
Pie fans have plenty to love here too. Boston Cream Pie is a menu highlight, and it’s practically the state dessert.
Coconut cream and chocolate cream pies also earn attention. Seasonal holiday pies join the lineup when the calendar calls for them.
Yes, the line can get very long. The good news is that it tends to move pretty fast.
While you wait, scope out other goodies. Banana bread, brownies, bread pudding, and quiche all make strong cases for themselves.
The Brown Sugar Almond Meringue Cloud sounds like a dessert from a dream. Pair it with hot chocolate or a cappuccino for a sweet break.
Unlike several shops on this list, you can sit down here. Dine-in seating, free Wi-Fi, and a restroom make lingering easy.
Weekend mornings get the busiest, along with Thursday and Friday mornings. Evenings tend to be quieter if you want an easier visit.
Hours run 7 AM to 7 PM on weekdays and 8 AM to 6 PM on weekends. Paid street parking is available nearby.
Address: 131 Clarendon St, Boston, MA 02116