The same family has worked this land since 1741, before the United States existed. How many bakeries can claim that kind of history?
The farm now covers more than 1,100 acres of Connecticut orchards and fields. Its bakery turns out fruit pies, cream pies, and a towering apple pie worth the drive.
A market, a deli, and a creamery round out the stop.
Why settle for a grocery store pie when this one has nearly three centuries behind it? I think holiday desserts taste better with a story attached.
This one comes from a family now in its 8th, 9th, and 10th generations. Every slice carries a little Connecticut history.
So which pie lands on your table this year? Order early, because the holiday rush waits for nobody.
A Family Farm That Beats The Nation By Decades

Lyman Orchards Apple Barrel Farm Market sits on land with a story older than the country. John Lyman and his wife, Hope, bought the first 37-acre parcel in what is now Middlefield, Connecticut, in 1741.
That is a lot of Thanksgivings ago.
The farm has stayed with the same family ever since. Today the 8th, 9th, and 10th generations of the Lyman family are involved, which makes it one of the oldest family-owned businesses in America.
The land has grown from that small start to more than 1,100 acres. Orchards, golf courses, mazes, and a busy market all share the property now.
The farm also has a reputation for having been a stop on the Underground Railroad. That adds another layer to a place already full of history.
So when you order a pie here, you are buying from a family that has been feeding neighbors for nearly three centuries. Not many bakeries can say that, and fewer can say it while still handing the keys to the next generation.
It makes a store-bought dessert feel a little bland by comparison.
The Hi-Top Apple Pie Takes The Spotlight

Start with the star of the bakery counter, the Hi-Top Apple Pie. It is the signature pie at Lyman Orchards, and the name fits a pie piled high with apples.
Apple Crumb is another favorite for those who like a sweet topping over their fruit. One recent customer even picked it up along with a fresh coffee and called the whole stop a treat.
The orchards grow more than 100 varieties of fruit, so the apple tradition runs deep here. That connection to the farm is part of what makes these pies feel local.
The pies are known as award-winning and freshly baked. For a holiday meal, that gives you a reliable centerpiece without hours of peeling and rolling.
If apple is the one pie your family expects every year, this is the safe and delicious choice. Order one for the table and you may need a second for leftovers.
Nobody ever complained about extra apple pie on the day after Thanksgiving.
Fruit And Cream Pies For Every Opinion At The Table

Every family has that one relative who refuses apple. Luckily, the bakery has options for them too.
The fruit list includes Blueberry, Bumbleberry, Cherry, and Strawberry Rhubarb. Seasonal choices such as Peach and Pumpkin also show up on the lineup.
Cream pies fill out the rest of the menu. Banana, Chocolate, Coconut, and Lemon Meringue are all offered, along with Pecan.
Pecan has already earned a promise from one shopper, who planned to return for Thanksgiving pies. Another customer called the Strawberry Rhubarb the best on the planet and said they would drive a long way for it.
With this many choices, you can build a dessert table that covers everyone. Pick a classic, add a fruit pie, and toss in a cream pie for the chocolate fans.
Just keep a knife handy, because pie diplomacy is a real job during the holidays.
How Thanksgiving Pie Orders Work

Planning ahead matters when a whole state wants pie at the same time. Customers can order Thanksgiving pies for pickup at the farm market.
Ordering deadlines are typically a few days before the holiday. Check the farm’s current Thanksgiving ordering details before you settle on a flavor list.
The bakery counter is open from 9 AM to 5 PM, while the market itself is open daily from 9 AM to 6 PM. Those hours make pickup easier to fit into a busy week.
Write down how many guests you expect, then choose one pie for every few people. A little extra never hurts when seconds are involved.
Custom cakes and cupcakes can also be ordered if someone at your table has a birthday close to the holiday. That way one trip covers more than one celebration.
Ordering early also means you can skip the stress of an empty shelf on the day before Thanksgiving.
Cider Donuts Deserve A Spot In The Car

Apple cider donuts are the item people keep mentioning at this market. Forty-two Google mentions say a lot for one fried treat.
One customer called the donuts a must, and another said they were the highlight of the visit. A third picked up both apple pie and donuts and loved them.
The donuts also connect to a good cause. The Salvation Army has partnered with the Lyman team for National Donut Day celebrations.
The bakery makes plenty beyond donuts too. Muffins, cookies, breads, pastries, cakes, cupcakes, and cannolis all join the lineup.
So while you are picking up pie, grab a bag of donuts for the ride home. They make a handy snack for the person guarding the pies in the back seat.
That person may need extra motivation to keep their fork to themselves.
The Market At 32 Reeds Gap Road Has More Than Pie

The Apple Barrel Farm Market is located at 32 Reeds Gap Road, Middlefield, CT 06455. It opened in 1972 and remains a key part of the farm.
Inside, shelves hold Lyman Orchards jams, jellies, and sauces. The market also stocks locally sourced cheeses, milk, eggs, and meats.
One shopper praised the huge wall of jams and jellies, along with the pierogis and fresh pasta. Another left with stuffed breads and cheese.
There is also a gift shop on the property for last-minute presents. That makes the trip handy for hosts who need a thank-you gift.
Fill a basket with a jar of jam, a wedge of cheese, and your pie order. Your Thanksgiving table will look like you planned it for weeks.
Only you need to know it took one stop.
Heat-And-Serve Dinners For Two

Not every Thanksgiving needs a twenty-pound turkey. Sometimes the guest list is just two people.
The market offers heat-and-serve Thanksgiving dinners for two. They are available for in-store pickup.
Pair one with a pie and the holiday is basically handled. You get a full meal and dessert from the same family farm.
The deli also serves made-to-order sandwiches, wraps, and salads during the year. Homemade potato chips come alongside the sandwiches.
That variety helps if you have guests arriving the day before the big meal. Grab lunch at the deli, then collect your pie on the way out.
The deli runs from 9 AM to 4 PM, so plan your timing and skip the rush near closing.
Make A Day Of It With Creamery Treats And Orchard Views

Once the pie is boxed, there is still plenty to enjoy. The creamery serves soft-serve, locally sourced hard ice cream, sundaes, and slushies.
It is open from 9 AM to 5:30 PM.
Tables and chairs sit toward the back of the building. One shopper described it as a good place to relax and eat after shopping.
Pick Your Own season runs from June to November, with apples among the main crops. The apple season has ended for this year, so the orchards are quiet now.
Fall favorites include a large corn maze, running from August to November. The farm also hosts events through the year, such as live music, Santa brunches, and horse-drawn wagon rides.
Visit in the off-season and you will find fewer crowds than a busy autumn Saturday. Weekends in peak fall can bring long lines, so patience helps.
A quiet November visit may be the better plan.
Plan Your Pickup Like A Pro

A smooth pickup starts with knowing the basics. The market is open every day from 9 AM to 6 PM, and parking is available in the lot down the hill.
Fall weekends can be busy. Lyman Orchards limits how many people can be in the store at once, so a line is possible.
Weekday mornings may feel calmer. That is simply a good guess, so plan a little extra time either way.
Lyman Orchards is a pet-free property, though service animals are welcome. Leave the dog at home and bring a sturdy box for the pies.
The farm also offers bus parking and event space at the Lyman Homestead for larger groups. For most of us, though, the goal is simple.
Grab the pies, say thanks, and drive home with dessert handled for Connecticut’s biggest food holiday.






