Skip to content

The 9 New York Tea Rooms Serving Afternoon Tea All December

Hundreds of dresses and feathery boas fill the whole upstairs of one tea room, ready for guests to borrow free. I love that detail so much, because tea simply tastes fancier when you’re wearing a borrowed hat.

Little ones would probably race up those stairs, and plenty of grown ups would be right behind them. A feather boa can turn a simple afternoon snack into a royal event worth remembering for years.

December makes afternoon tea feel extra special, especially when the sky outside turns gray and chilly. Warm scones with clotted cream and a refillable pot can turn even the gloomiest day around pretty fast.

Tea rooms across New York keep this cozy tradition going all December long, scones and all. I honestly can’t imagine a better trade for a cold afternoon than a hot cup and a cucumber sandwich.

1. Florrie Kayes Tea Room

Florrie Kayes Tea Room
© Florrie Kayes Tea Room

When was the last time you ate a meal stacked three stories high? At Florrie Kayes Tea Room in Brewster, the afternoon tea special arrives on a three-tier stand that answers that question beautifully.

The layout follows a smart order. Finger sandwiches sit on the bottom, scones with jelly and whipped cream fill the middle, and desserts claim the top.

Work your way up, and you’ll finish on a sweet note. It’s basically a staircase made of snacks.

The tea list is extensive, so expect to spend a few minutes choosing. Moroccan Mint is one option on the menu if you like something bright and fresh.

Brewster sits in Putnam County, an easy trip north of the city. That makes this a handy stop for a December escape from Manhattan crowds.

Hours are generous for a tea room. It opens Tuesday through Saturday at 11 AM, stays open until 9 PM on Fridays, and starts at 10 AM on Sundays.

That Friday schedule is a sneaky perk. You can squeeze in a late tea after work instead of fighting for a weekend slot.

Sundays tend to be the busiest stretch, while Thursdays run quieter. Reservations are highly recommended, especially during busy December weekends, but afternoon tea is also available to walk-in guests when space permits.

The room is closed Mondays. Takeout and delivery are available too, in case you want a little tea-time comfort at home.

Address: 512 Clock Tower Commons Dr, Brewster, NY 10509

2. Charlotte’s Tea Room

Charlotte's Tea Room
© Charlotte’s Tea Room

Picking a room might be the hardest decision you make at Charlotte’s Tea Room. The vintage-themed tea house in Warwick has small rooms, and each one is decorated differently.

Classical music plays while you sip, giving the place an elegant, unhurried mood. It feels a bit like stepping into an old-fashioned tea party.

The deluxe tea for two is the star of the show. Courses come in a relaxed order, starting with scones, then tea sandwiches, then desserts.

That pacing gives you time to chat between bites. Slow and steady wins the tea race.

Scones come with clotted cream and lemon curd, a pairing that’s hard to beat. The tea list runs wide, with choices like dragon pearl jasmine and sencha.

Want something heartier first? Butternut squash soup has appeared on the menu, which sounds perfect for a chilly December afternoon.

Warwick sits in the Hudson Valley, making this a sweet stop on a winter drive through New York. There’s a free on-site parking lot, so you won’t circle the block.

The tea room opens Wednesday through Sunday from 11 AM to 4 PM. It’s closed Mondays and Tuesdays, so save it for midweek or the weekend.

The space is also LGBTQ+ friendly and has a gender-neutral restroom. Everyone deserves a comfy seat at the tea table.

Takeout is available too, so you can grab a treat for the road. A scone in the cup holder is a holiday road trip upgrade.

Address: 15 Oakland Ave, Warwick, NY 10990

3. The Whistling Kettle

The Whistling Kettle
© The Whistling Kettle

A tea room named after a noisy kettle should know its tea, and this one does. The Whistling Kettle in Ballston Spa is a quaint cafe and tearoom with a standout tea selection.

The best news for December planners is the schedule. It’s open seven days a week, with weekday hours from 11 AM to 6:30 PM.

Weekends start earlier, at 10 AM on Saturday and Sunday. Saturday and Sunday afternoons are the busiest, so a weekday visit can feel calmer.

Afternoon tea is on the menu here, but so are savory crepes, panini, and salads. That mix makes it easy to bring a friend who is only lukewarm on tea.

Seasonal flavors fit right in. The Turkey Cranberry and Brie sounds like Thanksgiving leftovers in their fanciest outfit.

Sweet tooth? Try the Berries and Cream Crepe, or go savory with the Quiche of the Day.

Gluten-free crepes are available, which is a nice bonus for anyone avoiding wheat. The Kettle House Salad is vegan, too.

Matcha lattes also show up on the drink list. They’re a fun pick if you want your green tea in a creamier form.

Ballston Spa sits in Saratoga County in upstate New York, and free street parking makes stopping easy. Curbside pickup and takeout are available if your day is packed.

Grab a pot, find a seat, and let the kettle do the whistling. You’ve earned a break from the gift wrap.

Address: 24 Front St, Ballston Spa, NY 12020

4. The Hidden Oak Café

The Hidden Oak Café
© The Hidden Oak Café

Snow on an estate lawn and a pot of tea in your hands is a pretty strong December combo. The Hidden Oak Café serves Victorian tea inside a mansion at the Bayard Cutting Arboretum on Long Island.

The setting is the headline. The café looks out over the lawn and the river, so the view does a lot of the decorating.

Victorian Tea is served by reservation, so don’t just show up hoping for a seat. Book ahead, especially during the busy holiday season.

The tea service includes scones, finger sandwiches, and assorted desserts. Turkey on croissant has appeared among the sandwiches, which is a fun twist on the classic.

Tea choices are plentiful, so take your time with the list. A Pot of Tea for Two is also on the menu if you’d rather keep things simple.

Not in a tea-party mood? The café also offers lunch, with wraps, salads, and a classic BLT.

Crumb cake is another option for a quick sweet bite. It’s a fine reward after a stroll around the arboretum grounds.

Families get a break here, too. There’s a kids’ menu and high chairs, which makes bringing little ones much easier.

During December, the café opens Tuesday through Sunday from 11 AM to 3 PM, with Mondays and Christmas Day closed. Parking is usually plentiful, so you can focus on the scones instead of the lot.

Address: 440 Montauk Hwy, Great River, NY 11739

5. The Secret Garden Tearoom & Gift Shoppe

The Secret Garden Tearoom & Gift Shoppe
© The Secret Garden Tearoom & Gift Shoppe

Shopping and snacking rarely happen at the same table, but this Port Jefferson spot pulls off both. The Secret Garden Tearoom & Gift Shoppe pairs an old-fashioned gift shop with a tea room full of quaint charm.

The tea service follows English style. Savory bites and sweets arrive on tiered servers, set down on lace-covered, glass-topped tables.

Soft music plays in the background, which helps the room stay quiet and calm. After a hectic week of holiday errands, that might be the best gift on the property.

Hungry? The Full Afternoon Tea is the big option, while the Light Tea Service suits a smaller appetite.

There’s also a plate of mini sandwiches and puffs if you just want a nibble. Dessert and the tea selection both get high marks here.

Solo diners feel right at home, too. A table for one with a pot of tea is a lovely way to slow down.

Timing takes a little care, because the tea room opens Monday and Thursday through Sunday from 11 AM to 3 PM. It’s closed Tuesdays and Wednesdays, so plan your Long Island day trip around that.

Lunch reservations are recommended, especially in busy December. Parking options include free street parking and a paid lot.

Before you leave, browse the gift shop for a last-minute present or two. Your holiday shopping list, and maybe your aunt, will thank you.

Address: 225 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777

6. The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant

The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant
© The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant

Some tea rooms whisper elegance, but this Blue Point spot opens with a pun. The Mad Batter Tea Room & Restaurant is a whimsical tea room, and the name sets the tone before you even sit down.

Afternoon tea here arrives on two-tier towers. Expect pastries, tea sandwiches, fresh fruit, and scones served with clotted cream and jam.

The fresh fruit is a nice touch between rich bites. It gives you a breather before you go back for another scone.

Piano music adds to the charm of the setting. It turns a simple lunch into something that feels like a small event.

Watch for the Tea Sandwich of the Day, a vegetarian option on the menu. Coming back twice in December? You might get a different bite each time.

Service is known for being quick, which helps on a hectic holiday weekend. Coffee is also on hand for anyone in your group who isn’t a tea person.

Kids have their own menu, so younger tea fans can join the fun. It’s a sweet way to start a holiday tradition with the family.

The tea room is open Wednesday through Sunday from noon to 4 PM. It’s closed Mondays and Tuesdays, and reservations are accepted.

Blue Point sits on the South Shore of Long Island in New York, and there’s a free parking lot plus street parking. Pack your curiosity about what’s waiting down the rabbit hole.

Address: 154 Montauk Hwy, Blue Point, NY 11715

7. Brooklyn High Low – Original Location

Brooklyn High Low - Original Location
© Brooklyn High Low – Original Location

Unlimited tea might be the sweetest phrase in Brooklyn. At Brooklyn High Low, the classic tea for two comes with bottomless pots served with cream, honey, and sugar.

The food side is just as generous. You get four types of finger sandwiches, two scones with clotted cream and jam, and dessert.

Want even more? The Heights service adds soup to the lineup, along with sandwiches, scones, and a dessert tier.

This female-owned teahouse also pays attention to different diets. Vegetarian and pescatarian guests have several choices, while gluten-free options require advance notice and vegan guests at the original location can book only a limited vegan tea service.

Winter doesn’t shut down the garden either. The outdoor space is heated, so you can sip outside even when December gets frosty.

Timing is the key detail with this one. The teahouse opens only Friday through Sunday, from noon on Fridays and from 10 AM on weekends.

Service wraps up at 3:30 PM each of those days. Plan an early outing, then stroll Vanderbilt Avenue afterward.

Parking in this part of New York City is paid street parking, so transit may be the easier ride. Takeout is available if you want to bring treats home.

The tea selection is a highlight, so bring curiosity and maybe a notebook. You’ll want to remember your favorite blend for next time.

The space is LGBTQ+ friendly and offers a gender-neutral restroom. Good tea should feel welcoming for everyone at the table.

Address: 611 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238

8. HatTea’s Tea Room & Cafe

HatTea's Tea Room & Cafe
© HatTea’s Tea Room & Cafe

Feather boa or wide-brimmed hat? That’s the kind of tough choice you face at HatTea’s Tea Room & Cafe in Lakewood.

The second floor overflows with hundreds of dresses, hats, boas, and pieces of jewelry. Dress-up is included for kids and adults alike, so grown-ups can play along, too.

The building has a story of its own. HatTea’s lives in a rescued and revitalized farmhouse that now serves lunch and proper afternoon tea.

Downstairs, the dining area shows off original woodwork. Lace curtains, lace tablecloths, chandeliers, and imported wall sconces add plenty of old-fashioned charm.

Afternoon tea brings freshly baked scones with clotted cream, plus assorted savory bites. Kids can have their own version of tea time with juice.

That combination makes it a fantastic place for a child’s first tea party. A little one in a sparkly hat, sipping juice from a teacup, is pure holiday magic.

Reservations are required for both lunch and afternoon tea at least two days in advance, and guests must select their food when booking. The tea room accepts advance reservations Tuesday through Saturday from 11 AM to 2 PM, with Sundays reserved for groups of at least five.

That’s a short window, so aim for a late morning arrival. Mondays are closed.

Lakewood sits in Western New York, near the far corner of the state. Free parking in a lot and on the street keeps arrival simple.

Ending this list on a tea room with a costume closet feels right. Go ahead and pick the biggest hat in the house.

Address: 125 E Fairmount Ave, Lakewood, NY 14750

9. Kings’ Carriage House

Kings' Carriage House
© Kings’ Carriage House

Horses and teacups don’t usually share a story, yet this Upper East Side carriage house makes the pairing feel natural. The duplex space has an English-country-house feel, which is a fun surprise on a busy Manhattan block.

Kings’ Carriage House serves set-price New American menus along with afternoon tea. That means you can treat it as a fancy lunch stop or a full tea outing.

December brings a twist worth planning around. During the holidays, the kitchen focuses on one special holiday version of afternoon tea instead of several options.

Honestly, that makes ordering easy. You skip the menu debate and go straight to the good part.

The regular menu gives a sense of the style here. Look for cucumber triangles with chive butter, scones with cream and jam, and a timbale of oak smoked salmon tartare.

Tea lovers get plenty to explore, since the tea selection is a real highlight. Vegetarians are covered too, with a full vegetarian menu on offer.

Can’t stay long? An Afternoon Tea Box is on the menu, and takeout is available for a treat to enjoy at home.

Hours run Tuesday through Sunday from noon to 6 PM, and the room is closed Mondays. Reservations are recommended for lunch, so book ahead before your holiday calendar fills up.

Groups do well here, which makes it a smart pick for a family tea or a friends’ holiday outing. Just pack your best pinky-raising technique.

Address: 251 E 82nd St, New York, NY 10028