Skip to content

We Ranked The 12 Best Pizzerias In New York And Here Is Who Made The Cut

One standout pizzeria opens for just four hours a day, five days a week, and not a minute more. That’s twenty hours a week to grab a pie, and I suspect people plan whole days around it.

A schedule that tight tells me the kitchen cares far more about the pie than the clock. Showing up too late just means you’ll be the first one in line next time around.

Great pizza in New York reaches far beyond the famous big city slice shops everyone already knows. A few of the best ovens burn real wood, so that smoky smell might greet you right outside.

Chasing a perfect pie across the state makes for one seriously delicious family road trip this winter. Just check the hours before you go, since a few kitchens open only a handful of days each week.

12. Jay’s Artisan Pizzeria, Kenmore, NY

Jay's Artisan Pizzeria, Kenmore, NY
© Jay’s Artisan Pizzeria, Kenmore, NY

Four hours a night, five nights a week, is all the time you get here. Jay’s opens Tuesday through Saturday from 4 to 8 PM, so plan your craving accordingly.

The kitchen splits its love between two styles. You can go Neapolitan with a thin, brick-oven crust, or switch to thick Detroit-style squares with cheesy, crispy edges.

Can’t decide? Bring a friend and order one of each, which feels like the only fair solution.

The Neapolitan side bakes up with a blackened, crispy bottom that gives the crust real character. On top, the toppings lean fresh and thoughtful rather than piled on for show.

Start with the Margherita if you like to judge a pizzeria by its basics. Then try the bufala mozzarella pie with housemade chili honey for a sweet-and-spicy finish.

A kale salad sits on the menu for anyone pretending to be balanced tonight. Tiramisu waits at the end, and honestly, it would be rude to skip it.

Vegan and vegetarian diners get full menus here, which is a nice surprise at a pizza shop. Reservations aren’t accepted, so arriving early on a Friday or Saturday evening is smart.

Counter service and table service both happen here. Grab a quick solo dinner or sit down with your crew, depending on your mood.

Kenmore sits just north of Buffalo in Western New York. That makes this an easy stop if you’re exploring the area and want a dinner that feels special without being fussy.

Address: 2872 Delaware Ave, Kenmore, NY 14217

11. PIZZA NOTA, Rochester, NY

PIZZA NOTA, Rochester, NY
© PIZZA NOTA, Rochester, NY

Rochester doesn’t need a road trip to Connecticut anymore. PIZZA NOTA brings New Haven-style thin-crust pizza to Anderson Avenue, and it does so with real style.

If you’ve never tried New Haven pizza, here’s the quick version. The crust runs thin, and the pies are all about char, chew, and big flavor.

The New Haven Tomato Pie is the star you should order first. It’s a vegetarian pie that puts the sauce front and center, which is exactly the point of the style.

Then comes the twist. This lively spot also serves chicken cutlets, so pizza night can turn into a full-blown feast.

The schedule takes a little homework. It’s open Monday and Thursday evenings, closed Tuesday and Wednesday, and adds lunch hours from 12 to 2 PM on Friday and Saturday.

Sunday runs from noon to 8 PM, which makes it a strong pick for a lazy weekend meal. Friday evening tends to be the busiest stretch, so go early if you hate waiting.

Families fit right in here. Kids are welcome, and the casual feel means nobody minds a little sauce on a sleeve.

Prefer eating at home? Takeout and delivery are both available, making it easy to enjoy PIZZA NOTA’s pies at home.

Outdoor seating gives you a nice choice when Upstate New York weather cooperates. Parking is usually easy too, with a free lot and free street spots nearby.

Address: 192 Anderson Ave, Rochester, NY 14607

10. Pizza Wizard, Rochester, NY

Pizza Wizard, Rochester, NY
© Pizza Wizard, Rochester, NY

Wizards usually deal in spells, but this one works its magic with a pan. Pizza Wizard on South Clinton Avenue is known for thick, crispy square pizzas.

The crust comes out thicker than a typical slice, with a crisp, well-cooked base. Toppings land generously, so these squares have serious heft.

The red sauce tastes rich and robust without feeling heavy. Small pepperonis dot the top, giving you pepperoni in nearly each bite.

The menu also plays with unexpected flavor combos. If you like trying something new, this is your playground.

Pizza isn’t the only trick up its sleeve. You’ll find chicken wings, chicken tenders, and a Number One Salad for anyone who wants some crunch.

Plant-based eaters get a real treat. The kitchen offers a full vegan menu, including vegan seitan wings that let more people join the wing party.

Save room for Dr Dave’s Cookie Nook on the dessert side. Wash it down with a Chinotto, an Italian citrus soda with a bittersweet twist.

Ordering happens at the counter, and service tends to be quick. Hours run Wednesday through Sunday from 11 AM to 8:30 PM, with Monday and Tuesday off.

High chairs are on hand for little wizards. Groups fit well here too, which makes it handy for team dinners or birthday crews.

Parking can be tricky in this part of Rochester, so give yourself a few extra minutes. Delivery and takeout are also available if you’d rather stay put.

Address: 760 S Clinton Ave, Rochester, NY 14620

9. Apizza Regionale, Syracuse, NY

Apizza Regionale, Syracuse, NY
© Apizza Regionale, Syracuse, NY

Local ingredients get the spotlight in downtown Syracuse. Apizza Regionale builds its menu around locally sourced pizza and pasta, all anchored by a wood-fired oven.

The crust stays thin and soft, with the kind of char only real fire delivers. Toppings change things up with original combos you won’t see at a typical slice shop.

A Wood-Fired Margherita is the classic move for purists. For more personality, try the Calabrian Pizza with soppressata or the vegetarian Patata topped with Yukon Gold potatoes, caramelized onions, aged Gouda, and rosemary.

Starters deserve real attention here. Pork Store Arancini, meatballs, and fried zucchini sticks make a strong case for ordering a few plates to share.

Pasta fans aren’t left out either. Chicken Parmigiana with linguine is on the menu for anyone craving a full Italian-American dinner.

The space looks clean and classy, and an outdoor patio opens things up in nicer weather. Dogs are welcome outside, so your pup can come along for patio season.

Apizza Regionale does not accept reservations and seats guests on a first-come, first-served basis. There’s usually a wait, especially on Friday and Saturday evenings.

Lunch runs Tuesday through Friday from 11:30 AM to 3 PM, with dinner from 5 to 9 PM. Weekends are dinner only, from 4 to 9 PM, and Monday is closed.

Central New York has plenty of pizza, but this spot stands out for its focus on the region’s own ingredients. That local pride shows up right in the name.

Address: 260 W Genesee St, Syracuse, NY 13202

8. Robbie T’s Pizza, Jamesville, NY

Robbie T's Pizza, Jamesville, NY
© Robbie T’s Pizza, Jamesville, NY

Cheeseburger on a pizza? Robbie T’s makes that happen, and it’s one of the signature pies at this friendly spot in Jamesville.

The crust lands right between crispy and chewy, which is a sweet spot plenty of pizza lovers chase. A tangy sauce and well-balanced cheese round out the base.

Chicken bacon ranch is another standout here. Expect real chunks of chicken and slices of bacon, not a timid sprinkle.

Calzones arrive giant, so plan to share or plan for leftovers. Either way, tomorrow’s lunch is basically handled.

Wings come out crispy, and Buffalo boneless wings are on the menu too. Garlic knots make an easy add-on, and they pair nicely with any pie.

Feeling extra hungry? Steak fries and deep-fried mushrooms help turn a quick pizza run into a proper spread.

The kitchen is known for being spotless, and the team brings a friendly, caring touch to service. That kind of small-town hospitality is easy to appreciate.

Hours run Monday through Thursday from 11 AM to 8:30 PM. On Friday and Saturday, you get until 9 PM, while Sunday is closed.

Parking is usually plentiful, with a free lot and free street spots. Outdoor seating offers another option when the Onondaga County weather plays nice.

Groups are easy to fit, and kids are welcome too. Just know reservations aren’t taken, so larger crews should time their visit wisely.

Jamesville sits just southeast of Syracuse in Central New York. It’s a short drive that pays off in very full stomachs.

Address: 4625 North St, Jamesville, NY 13078

7. Mangia Macrina’s Wood Fired Pizza, Utica, NY

Mangia Macrina's Wood Fired Pizza, Utica, NY
© Mangia Macrina’s Wood Fired Pizza, Utica, NY

Here’s a menu option you don’t see daily: Rocketize Any Pizza. At Mangia Macrina’s in Utica, it’s a playful way to put your own spin on a pie.

The kitchen specializes in authentic wood-fired Neapolitan pizza. That means pies cooked in a fiery oven, following a tradition with roots in Naples, Italy.

The Figgy Piggy is a fun name worth ordering just to say out loud. The Rocket pizza is also vegan, which is great news for plant-based friends.

Vegan and vegetarian diners get full menus here. A Macrina Mix Salad adds something fresh to the table before the pizza lands.

Families will find plenty of thoughtful touches. There’s a kids’ menu, high chairs, and changing tables, which parents of little ones will appreciate.

Bringing the dog? Pups are allowed outside, and outdoor seating gives you a pleasant spot to eat together.

Groups and college crowds both fit right in. The relaxed setting makes it an easy pick for a casual dinner with friends.

Hours run Tuesday through Thursday from noon to 8 PM. Friday and Saturday stretch to 9 PM, Sunday wraps up at 5 PM, and Monday is closed.

Service tends to be fast, which helps when hunger strikes hard. Curbside pickup and takeout are available too, though delivery isn’t.

Utica sits in the Mohawk Valley, right in the middle of New York. Parking is usually easy here, with a free lot and free street spots close by.

Address: 470 French Rd, Utica, NY 13502

6. Pizza Michelina, Albany, NY

Pizza Michelina, Albany, NY
© Pizza Michelina, Albany, NY

Dessert arancini might be the best plot twist on any pizzeria menu in Albany. Pizza Michelina serves them, and they’re reason enough to save room.

The main event is wood-fired, Neapolitan-style pizza. This welcoming spot on Delaware Avenue keeps its focus right where it belongs.

A Margherita is the natural place to start. The Veggie Lovers Pizza brings more color to the table if you want extra vegetables.

Then there’s The Croatian Pizza, topped with Croatian sausage, red onion, and roasted red pepper sauce, with a name that sparks instant curiosity. It’s the kind of order that makes the table ask questions.

Mozzarella sticks sit on the menu for anyone who believes cheese should come before more cheese. Honestly, that’s a solid life philosophy.

Ordering happens at the counter, keeping things casual and quick. A full vegetarian menu means meat-free eaters have plenty of choices.

The schedule is short, so plan ahead. It’s open Thursday and Friday from 11 AM to 9 PM, and Saturday from 2 to 9 PM.

That leaves Sunday through Wednesday closed. Mark your calendar, because showing up on a Tuesday will only bring sadness.

The spot is known as LGBTQ+ friendly and a transgender safe space. A gender-neutral restroom is part of that inclusive setup.

Kids fit right in, and dogs are allowed outside. Free street parking is usually easy to find in this part of New York’s Capital District.

Can’t make it in person? Delivery, no-contact delivery, curbside pickup, and takeout are all options here.

Address: 376 Delaware Ave, Albany, NY 12209

5. Harvest & Hearth, Saratoga Springs, NY

Harvest & Hearth, Saratoga Springs, NY
© Harvest & Hearth, Saratoga Springs, NY

Pizza by a creek sounds like a daydream, but Harvest & Hearth makes it real. This quaint pizzeria sits by the water in Saratoga Springs.

The pies come from an open wood stove, which gives the crust a thin, crisp finish. Local produce shows up in the toppings, so the menu feels tied to the land around it.

The setting leans rustic, with a relaxed feel that suits a slow dinner. A patio and outdoor seating let you eat closer to the creek on nice evenings.

Salads here aren’t an afterthought. Organic options add a fresh, crunchy start before the main event arrives.

Dessert is where things get extra comforting. A Brownie Sundae and an Apple Crisp both sit on the menu, and choosing just one feels unfair.

Coffee is available too, which helps if you plan to linger over that apple crisp. A full vegetarian menu means meat-free diners have real choices.

The hours keep things simple. It’s open Tuesday through Saturday from 4:30 to 9 PM, and closed Sunday and Monday.

Reservations are accepted, which is handy during busy Saratoga seasons. Groups fit well, and high chairs are available for younger guests.

Parking is easy with a free lot that usually has plenty of space. That’s one less thing to worry about after a day exploring Saratoga County.

For a pizza night that feels like a mini getaway, this one is hard to top in upstate New York. Bring a sweater for the patio, just in case.

Address: 251 Co Rd 67, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866

4. Pizzeria Posto Rhinebeck, Rhinebeck, NY

Pizzeria Posto Rhinebeck, Rhinebeck, NY
© Pizzeria Posto Rhinebeck, Rhinebeck, NY

A fireplace and a wood-fired oven under one roof? Pizzeria Posto in Rhinebeck covers both kinds of heat, and that’s a strong opening argument.

The menu centers on Neapolitan pies with a thin, crispy, nicely charred crust. Fresh ingredients and a balanced sauce-to-cheese ratio keep each bite in harmony.

An open kitchen lets you watch the pizza come together. It’s dinner and a show, minus the ticket.

The setting stays simple and laid-back, which suits a town like Rhinebeck. You’re here for the pizza, and nobody needs fancy decor to prove anything.

Small plates and desserts fill out the menu if you want more than a pie. Coffee is also available, a nice finish after a big meal.

The hours shift around a bit, so check before you go. It opens at noon most days, Wednesday starts at 5 PM, and Tuesday is closed.

Reservations aren’t accepted, so timing matters. Friday and Saturday evenings tend to be the busiest, while Thursday afternoon is usually calmer.

Families are welcome, high chairs are available, and dogs can join you outside. Outdoor seating makes that easy on a pleasant Hudson Valley day.

Parking won’t slow you down much. A free lot and free street parking usually leave plenty of room.

Rhinebeck makes a lovely day trip from much of New York, with plenty to explore on foot. Ending that trip with a wood-fired pie sounds about right.

Address: 43 E Market St, Rhinebeck, NY 12572

3. Hudson & Packard, Poughkeepsie, NY

Hudson & Packard, Poughkeepsie, NY
© Hudson & Packard, Poughkeepsie, NY

The Hudson Hornet shares its name with a classic American car, and it brings real heat. At Hudson & Packard in Poughkeepsie, that pie is just one reason to visit.

Detroit-style squares are the specialty here. Expect a thick crust with a light, fluffy interior and a crispy bottom.

Cheese runs right to the edges, and a flavorful tomato sauce tops things off. Those edges are reason enough to grab a corner piece.

Pepperoni fans should look at the Ambassador, loaded with extra pepperoni. If you like a kick, the Hudson Hornet is your move.

The pies look like little works of art when they land on the table. Snap a photo first, then show no mercy.

Starters go beyond the usual. Buffalo wings and a Smokey Bleu Cheese Dressing are both on the menu, and Chicky Parmy adds an Italian-American comfort play.

Dessert keeps the fun going. Fried dough and Grandma Carol’s Green Cake both sit on the menu, and that name alone is irresistible.

Hours run Wednesday and Thursday from 11:30 AM to 8:30 PM. Friday and Saturday go until 9:30 PM, Sunday runs 12:30 to 8 PM, and Monday and Tuesday are closed.

Reservations are accepted, which helps on busy Friday nights. Delivery and takeout are available if you’d rather enjoy your squares on the couch.

Full vegan and vegetarian menus make this an easy pick for mixed groups in the Hudson Valley. College crowds and kids both fit right in.

Address: 29 Academy St, Poughkeepsie, NY 12601

2. Lucali, Brooklyn, NY

Lucali, Brooklyn, NY
© Lucali, Brooklyn, NY

Pizza and calzones are the stars of a tightly focused menu at Lucali. This acclaimed Carroll Gardens spot proves you don’t need a giant list to win hearts.

The brick oven turns out a thin, crispy crust with a nice char and a few dark spots on the bottom. It’s sturdy yet foldable, which is exactly what a New York pie should be.

The crust has a well-seasoned, mellow flavor that holds its own. Fresh basil and a balanced mix of sauce and gooey cheese finish the job.

Toppings stay simple and fresh. Pepperoni, mushrooms, shallots, and artichoke are options worth considering.

Craving extra sauce? You can order a side of it, and nobody will judge you for dunking.

There’s also Nonna’s x Lucali olive oil on the menu. It’s a fun detail for olive oil fans.

The room feels rustic and stylish at the same time. It’s casual enough for jeans but polished enough for a special night out.

Dinner is the only meal here, starting at 5 PM. Lucali opens at 5 PM and closes at 11 PM on its operating days, with Tuesdays closed.

Lucali does not accept reservations and operates on a first-come, first-served basis, with names added to the waitlist starting at 4 PM. Parking on nearby streets is free, though finding a spot can be tough.

Takeout and delivery are available if the dining room is packed. Either way, this is one New York pizza experience worth planning around.

Address: 575 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

1. Rubirosa, New York, NY

Rubirosa, New York, NY
© Rubirosa, New York, NY

Three sauces on one pie sounds like a kitchen experiment gone wild. At Rubirosa, the Tie Dye pizza swirls tomato sauce, pesto, and a third classic sauce across one colorful pie.

The thin crust stays crispy with a nice chew. Flavors come through fresh and intense, so even a plain pie makes a strong impression.

This Mulberry Street spot is an Italian-American institution in Manhattan. It reinvents classic dishes, so the menu goes far beyond pizza.

Family Style Lasagne is built for sharing with your whole crew. Chicken Parmigiano, cavatelli, and mushroom campanelle keep the pasta lovers busy.

Mini rice balls make an easy starter, and the Best of Rubirosa Appetizers offers a sampler-style option. For dessert, the New York-style cheesecake feels like a must in this city.

Gluten-free diners can order the Rubirosa Ragu in a gluten-free version. Vegetarian diners have several choices, while vegan guests can request dairy-free cheese on suitable pizzas, although some sauces, including the pesto, contain dairy.

Hours run from 11 AM to 11 PM seven days a week. That makes it a rare pizza stop that works for lunch, brunch, dinner, or a late bite.

Reservations are recommended, and there’s usually a wait. Weekend afternoons and evenings tend to be especially busy, so book ahead when you can.

Parking nearby is paid and often tough to find. Taking the subway or walking from a nearby neighborhood will save you some stress.

Groups and families both fit right in, and high chairs are available. It’s a fun finish for any New York pizza ranking, and a delicious one too.

Address: 235 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10012