Some Iowa bakeries hit their limit during Thanksgiving week. A single orchard bakery turns out more than 3,000 pies in those few days alone.
How do you make sure your favorite flavor survives that rush? You order early, and you order smart.
This list covers small shops, a nonprofit, and a few bakeries with serious history. A teen job program runs behind one counter, and a lard crust waits behind another.
Some shops ask for holiday orders days ahead. Others offer certain flavors only in late fall, which adds a little friendly pressure.
Who wants to explain an empty dessert table to the relatives? I would rather plan ahead and enjoy every bite.
So which Iowa bakery gets your order first? Pick a favorite, call ahead, and claim your slice.
Meta:
These Iowa pie shops sell out fast before Thanksgiving, from orchard bakeries to tiny small-town favorites. Place your order early and claim a slice.
1. Kathy’s Pies & Bakery

Sweet potato pie plays hard to get in Cedar Rapids. At Kathy’s, it only shows up in November and December, which makes it a Thanksgiving celebrity.
The bakery has been making homemade fruit pies, cream pies, cookies, and cakes since 1986. That’s decades of practice rolling dough, and it shows in the lineup of 10-inch pies offered daily.
Names here are half the fun. You’ll spot choices like Bayou Goo, Coconut Cream with meringue, and Lemon Supreme sitting right next to old favorites.
Holiday shoppers often build a full spread with caramel apple, pumpkin, and French silk. Orders tend to be ready when you arrive, which feels like a small miracle during the busiest week of the year.
Timing matters most here. Kathy’s asks you to place holiday orders at least five days ahead, so don’t wait until the turkey is thawing.
Keep in mind it’s a takeout shop with no dine-in seating. The good news is that a small free parking lot makes the grab-and-go part easy.
Hours run Monday through Friday from 7 AM to 4 PM, plus Saturday mornings until 1 PM. Wednesday afternoons get busy, so a Monday visit may save you some waiting.
Cookies and cakes fill out the cases too. A Monster Cookie Cheesecake slice makes a fine reward for whoever drives the pies home.
Want the calmest route? Order early, pick up fast, and let your family think you planned this months ago.
Address: 616 5th Ave SE, Cedar Rapids, IA 52401
2. Try Pie Bakery

Some pies come with a side of life skills. At Try Pie Bakery in Waterloo, the crust is tied to lessons in money and work.
This nonprofit social enterprise started in 2014 to give teen girls paying jobs and real-world skills.
It now employs over 40 young women each year, teaching financial literacy and job readiness alongside baking.
So your Thanksgiving dessert does double duty. You get a handmade pie, and a teen gets experience she can carry into any future workplace.
The menu covers classics like apple, cherry, and mixed berry. Chocolate silk joins the party, and Rhubarb Raspberry Lavender brings a garden-party twist to the table.
Miniature pies are part of the lineup too. They’re handy if your crowd can’t agree on one flavor and you’d rather skip the family debate.
Full-size pies also show up at weddings and big celebrations, so ordering for a crowd is familiar territory here. Ice cream and coffee are on hand if you stop in for a quick treat.
Plan around the schedule, because it’s a short one. Doors open Monday through Wednesday and Friday from noon to 6 PM, plus Saturday from 10 AM to 2 PM.
Thursday and Sunday are closed. Free street parking nearby keeps your pickup quick and painless.
Call it the rare pie that makes you feel good before the first bite. Your relatives just get to enjoy the second part.
Address: 522 Mulberry St, Waterloo, IA 50703
3. Iowa Orchard and Pie Bakery

Three thousand pies in one week sounds like a typo. At Iowa Orchard in Urbandale, it’s simply what Thanksgiving week looks like.
The family’s apple-growing roots reach back to 1939, and the business opened in 1975. Today, second-generation growers run the orchard and its busy pie bakery.
Bakers here make over 25 kinds of pies and cobblers by hand. They use real fruit and skip the canned filling, which explains a lot about the reputation.
Popular picks include Dutch Crumb Apple, Black Raspberry, and Chocolate Pecan. The small store also stocks take-and-bake pies in flavors like peach, cherry, mixed berry, and strawberry rhubarb.
Take-and-bake is a smart Thanksgiving move. You get a fresh-from-your-oven pie without wrestling flour all over the kitchen.
Don’t leave with just pie, though. The shelves also carry apple cider, caramel apples, donuts, and fudge, plus bags of Honeycrisp apples in season.
Staff members are known for being friendly and helpful when you’re stuck between flavors. Lean on them, because choosing between black raspberry and Dutch crumb apple is tough work.
The farm market stays open year-round, Tuesday through Sunday from 9 AM to 6 PM. That means you can scout flavors in October and come back for the holidays.
Mondays are closed, so mark your calendar. With thousands of pies leaving the building, an early plan beats a hopeful drive-by.
Address: 9875 Meredith Dr, Urbandale, IA 50322
4. Kozi Pie Shoppe

Lard is the secret behind the soft, flaky apple pie crust at Kozi Pie Shoppe. Yes, old-school bakers everywhere just nodded proudly.
This Decorah shop started small, carrying pies from a home kitchen to the farmers market. It later added an online store and opened its first storefront in January 2022.
Small batches and scratch baking sit at the heart of the operation. The shop also leans on local ingredients whenever it can.
For Thanksgiving, look for the Holiday Pies menu. Pumpkin, pecan, and apple headline the seasonal lineup for holiday gatherings.
Key lime pie has its own fan base here too. It’s a bright, tangy option if your table already has enough pumpkin to feed a small town.
Kozi isn’t only about dessert. The menu also includes savory pies, quiche, omelets, pancakes, and hash browns, with coffee to match.
Online orders get picked up at the Madison Road location. Placing your holiday order online first can save you a lot of guesswork.
Hours are limited and can shift, so check before you head out. Showing up on a closed day with pie on your mind is a sad little surprise.
Whole pies to go are a big part of the draw. One taste of that crust may convince you to order two.
The shop also openly welcomes LGBTQ+ guests. That’s a nice detail to know when you’re bringing the whole crew.
Address: 2123 Madison Rd, Decorah, IA 52101
5. Once Upon an Apple Pie

The salted caramel apple pie at Once Upon an Apple Pie has a dangerous reputation. It’s the kind of pie that makes you eye the empty box hopefully.
This little Grimes shop focuses on pie, and its light, flaky crust gets plenty of attention. Salted Caramel Apple Crumble and peanut butter chocolate are two standouts worth knowing.
Flavors change monthly, which keeps things exciting. Cookie sandwiches rotate along with the pies, so your favorite might vanish before you know it.
That rotation is exactly why timing matters before Thanksgiving. If a fall flavor catches your eye, claim it while it’s still on the menu.
Individual mini pies come in a solid selection. They’re perfect for sampling several flavors without committing to one giant dessert.
Buying four pies earns a discount too. Grab four, and you’ve got a tasting party for the whole table.
Hours are short and sweet, so plan carefully. The shop opens Friday from 8 AM to 2 PM and Saturday from 9 AM to 2 PM.
That’s it for the week. Monday through Thursday and Sunday are closed, so a midweek pie craving will have to wait.
Delivery isn’t offered, so takeout is the way to go. Swing by on a Friday morning and you’ll have the weekend to admire your haul.
Mini pies also make clever stand-ins for place cards at Thanksgiving dinner. Guests get dessert at their seat, and nobody fights over the last slice.
Address: 312 E 1st St, Grimes, IA 50111
6. Sugarpie Bakery & Cafe

Exposed brick, industrial ceilings, and the smell of fresh Sugar Pies set the scene in downtown Belmond. Not a bad way to start a pie errand.
Sugarpie Bakery & Cafe serves made-from-scratch breakfast dishes and fresh baked goods. A real pastry chef handles the baking, and the care shows.
The namesake sugar pie is the star. It’s the signature treat, and it earns a spot right beside your pumpkin pie.
This is also a sit-down spot with table service. Breakfast, brunch, and lunch all happen here, along with good coffee and a strong tea selection.
Reservations are accepted, which is handy for a group. Kids are welcome too, and high chairs are ready for the littlest pie fans.
Hours lean early in the day. Tuesday through Friday runs 7:30 AM to 1:30 PM, and Saturday goes from 8 AM to noon.
Mondays and Sundays are closed. That leaves a tight window, so ask about holiday baking before Thanksgiving week sneaks up on you.
Parking is easy, with a free lot and free street spaces nearby. You won’t have to circle the block while your pie waits.
Belmond sits in north central Iowa, which may mean a drive for some readers. Pair your pickup with breakfast, and the trip suddenly feels like a mini holiday.
Takeout works too if you’re in a hurry. Grab your pies, grab a coffee, and you’re back on the road.
Address: 319 E Main St, Belmond, IA 50421
7. Jaarsma Bakery

Order ahead for your pies. That’s the advice tied to Jaarsma Bakery in Pella, and it’s worth taking seriously.
Pella is famous for its Dutch heritage, and this bakery leans right into it with signature Dutch letters. The selection of pastries, cookies, bread, and pies can feel almost overwhelming.
Pecan pie is a favorite here. It pairs nicely with a Thanksgiving table that already has pumpkin covered.
Beyond pie, the cases hold almond sticks, pecan rolls, coffee cake, and angel food cake. Cinnamon rolls are a hit too, and they’d make a fine Thanksgiving breakfast.
Lines can get long, especially on Saturday mornings and afternoons. Monday and Wednesday evenings tend to be quieter if you’d rather skip the crowd.
Hours stretch from 6 AM to 6 PM, Monday through Saturday. Sundays are closed, so plan your pickup before the weekend wraps up.
It’s a takeout bakery with no dine-in seating. Coffee is available, though, which helps on an early morning pie run.
Free street parking makes stopping in simple. Just be ready to wait a bit if you show up at peak time.
The staff are known for being helpful when choices pile up. With this many options, a little guidance goes a long way.
Toss a few Dutch letters in your bag for the drive home. Congratulations, you now have dessert for your dessert.
Plan your order early. Then the pie waits for you, not the other way around.
Address: 727 Franklin St, Pella, IA 50219
8. The Classic Deli & Ice Cream Shoppe

Pork tenderloin sandwiches might be the headline at The Classic Deli & Ice Cream Shoppe. Pie fans, though, know the homemade pies deserve equal billing.
This small-town Brooklyn eatery serves breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Whole homemade pies are available to take home, and they come at a friendly price.
The owner usually cooks the food and is on hand daily. That hands-on approach fits a place built on homemade cooking.
Pies here are often called perfect. That’s high praise in Iowa, where pie standards run seriously high.
While you wait on a pie, the menu tempts in other directions. Brisket sandwiches, chili burgers, party potatoes, and huge salads all make appearances.
Ice cream is part of the name, so dessert doesn’t stop at pie. A scoop beside your slice is never a bad call.
Hours run Tuesday through Saturday from 7 AM to 8 PM. Mondays and Sundays are closed, so time your pie pickup with that in mind.
Friday afternoons and evenings tend to be busiest. A Thursday evening stop is usually calmer if you want quick service.
Reservations and catering are both available. That’s handy if Thanksgiving dinner is bigger than your dining room.
Kids get their own menu, and high chairs are ready. Grandparents and grandkids can share a table and debate pie flavors.
Parking is plentiful, with a free lot and free street spots. Pull in, pick up your pie, and maybe stay for a tenderloin while you’re at it.
Address: 120 Jackson St, Brooklyn, IA 52211






