Skip to content

10 Family-Owned Italian Restaurants In Ohio That Locals Would Never Trade For Anything

A sandwich name got trademarked in Ohio back in the 1960s, and the restaurant behind it still serves it today. That same kitchen is credited with bringing the first pizza to its city in the 1930s.

I love stories like that. One spot on this list has a woman making a thousand meatballs a week. Another still uses an electric sign that hasn’t changed in more than 60 years.

These are family restaurants in the truest sense. Grandparents wrote the recipes, and grandkids now run the kitchens. Some families are on their fourth or fifth generation behind the counter.

I can’t imagine a better reason to plan a road trip. The sauces are made from scratch, the photos on the walls tell the family history, and the menus barely budge. So which one is closest to you, and how fast can you get there?

1. TAT Ristorante Di Famiglia

TAT Ristorante Di Famiglia
© TAT Ristorante Di Famiglia

Here’s a fun puzzle: TAT stands for Transcontinental Air Transport, an airline that was big in Columbus in 1929. Family lore says it also means “Take Any Table,” which is honestly the better slogan.

Pete and Philomena Corrova opened the place in 1929 in the Flytown neighborhood. Freeway construction later forced a move, and the current spot has been running since 1979.

Four generations of Corrovas have worked here. It’s known as the oldest Italian restaurant in Columbus, and it’s credited with bringing the city its first pizza in the 1930s.

Then there’s the Poor Boy sandwich. Jimmy Corrova, the second generation, trademarked that name in Ohio back in the 1960s.

The kitchen makes its pasta, soups, sauces, and dressing from scratch. That Italian dressing is so popular it gets bottled and shipped.

You can go classic with homemade spaghetti, baked lasagna, or stuffed shells. Pizza fans can try The Godfather or the TAT Special.

Want something from the sea? Shrimp scampi and Sicilian haddock are on the menu, along with Italian wedding soup.

Gluten-free pasta and crust are available, so more of your crew can join in. A banquet room seats up to 125 people for bigger celebrations.

Plan ahead, because the doors stay closed Monday and Tuesday. Weekend hours start at 3 p.m., so save your appetite for the afternoon.

Address: 1210 S James Rd, Columbus, OH 43227

2. Mama Santa’s

Mama Santa's
© Mama Santa’s | Italian

A thousand meatballs a week. Pina, wife of co-owner Anthony Starvaggi, makes them with fresh in-house breadcrumbs, Parmesan, and parsley.

Guido and Nancy Scaffidi opened Mama Santa’s on July 25, 1961. They came from Gioiosa Marea, Sicily, after World War II.

The name honors Nancy’s mother, Santa Ignazzito. She was the original chef and the spark behind the whole idea.

The restaurant has never left its original spot in Cleveland’s Little Italy. Today it’s in its fifth generation of family ownership.

Nancy Schaffer, Santa’s great-granddaughter, hand-rolls the pizza dough. Pasta, sauces, and sausage are made from scratch too.

The specialty is homemade Sicilian pasta and pizza. Choose from spaghetti, rigatoni, cavatelli, fettuccine, or lasagna, then add veal or chicken parmigiana.

Don’t skip the fried green peppers. They’re a simple side with a lot of personality.

Sandwich lovers get options too, like meatball or sausage subs. Antipasto and minestrone round things out nicely.

Think old-time, checkered tablecloths and family-style meals. Reservations aren’t taken, so seating is first-come, first-served.

Kids have their own menu, and high chairs are ready for the littlest guests. It’s a place built for multiple generations, after all.

Sundays are off, so aim for Monday through Saturday. Your future self, holding a meatball sub, will thank you.

Address: 12301 Mayfield Rd, Cleveland, OH 44106

3. Ferrari’s Little Italy and Bakery

Ferrari's Little Italy and Bakery
© Ferrari’s Little Italy and Bakery

Dinner and dessert under one roof is nice. Dinner, dessert, and a grocery store under one roof is next level.

Ferrari’s Little Italy & Bakery is owned and run by the Bassano family, with Patty Bassano at the helm. The restaurant hit 28 years in business in early 2024.

The on-site bakery turns out breads, cookies, muffins, and pastries daily. Cannoli get filled fresh with ricotta each day, which is exactly how cannoli should be treated.

You’ll also find an Italian grocery on the premises. Grab a few things for home before you leave.

The menu covers both Northern and Southern Italian cooking. Mama Bassano’s Lasagna is a natural pick, and Stuffed Mushrooms Patricia make a fun starter.

Seafood fans can look at Four Pepper Salmon or Parmesan Crusted Sole. Brick oven pizzas and toasted cheese ravioli are also waiting.

Meals are served family-style with generous portions. Bring people who like to share, or at least people who like leftovers.

Inside, brick-stucco walls, old photos, and red-and-white checkered tablecloths set a rustic, Old World mood. Outside, the patio has an Italian mural and a stone-lighted waterfall.

Two private rooms hold up to 40 and 75 guests. That’s a lot of room for a big family party.

Address: 7677 Goff Terrace, Madeira, OH 45243

4. Mamma DiSalvo’s

Mamma DiSalvo's
© Mamma DiSalvo’s

Opening a restaurant takes a village, or at least three sons and a grandfather. Rinaldo and Elena DiSalvo had both when they opened their family restaurant in 1979.

Elena’s father, Pasquale Berardo, pitched in. So did their sons Nicola, Rinaldo Jr., and Roberto.

The recipes come from Italy’s Abruzzi Molise region. That gives the menu a family connection you can actually trace on a map.

Today Roberto is a chef and owner, and he makes the sauces and lasagna fresh daily. Entrees are made from scratch with fresh meats, imported cheese, pasta, and olive oil.

The lasagna al forno comes in meat and vegetarian versions. Eggplant rollatini and manicotti al forno also come out of the oven.

Homemade angel hair, cavatelli, and gnocchi share the menu with meat or cheese ravioli. Fettuccine Alfredo can be topped with chicken, shrimp, or scallops.

Daily specials keep regular visits interesting. Pizza, antipasto, and minestrone cover the rest of the bases.

Catering is an option for bigger events too. The dessert lineup includes cannoli, tiramisu, and cheesecake.

Look around the dining room while you wait. Framed photos show generations of the DiSalvo family on the walls.

Hours run Wednesday through Sunday, starting at 4 p.m. Reservations are accepted, which is a nice bonus for planners.

Address: 1375 E Stroop Rd, Kettering, OH 45429

5. Inky’s Italian Foods

Inky's Italian Foods
© Inky’s Italian Foods – Toledo, OH

Plenty of restaurants swap out their signs. The original electric sign at Inky’s has stayed the same for over 60 years, and why mess with a classic?

Brothers Frank Incorvaia Sr. and John Incorvaia Sr. opened the doors on August 6, 1957. The Incorvaia family has now run it for three generations.

Frank Incorvaia Jr. later took over operations. Next in line is a family generation being prepared to take the reins.

The menu has barely changed in decades. Ingredients still come from the same local providers the family has used since the 1950s.

Thin-crust pizza is the star here. Expect a crisp, light crust and a generous layer of cheese.

Secret family recipes drive both the pizzas and the entrees. Try the INKY’S Special Italian Sausage dinner, veal parmesan, or homemade ravioli.

Lunchtime brings luncheons with salad, spaghetti, bread, and butter. It’s a simple, filling way to break up a workday.

The dining room has an old-fashioned feel, with family photos on display. An expansion in the mid-1980s doubled the seating space.

Today it can hold up to 155 people. That’s room for the whole team after the big game.

Sundays are off, and Saturdays start at 4 p.m. Toledo pizza cravings should be scheduled accordingly.

Address: 3945 N Detroit Ave, Toledo, OH 43612

6. Mancy’s Italian Grill

Mancy's Italian Grill
© Mancy’s Italian Grill

The Mancy name has been feeding Toledo since 1921. That’s when Gus Mancy, an immigrant from Crete, opened The Ideal Restaurant.

Fast forward to April 1997, and the Italian Grill joined the family lineup. George Mancy, a third-generation restaurateur, runs it while honoring his grandmother’s heritage.

The open Italian kitchen is part of the show. You can watch homemade sauces, wood-fired pizzas, and grilled meats come together.

Pasta here gets creative. The Vesuvio pairs shrimp with fennel sausage, and Lasagna Pinwheels put a fun spin on a classic.

Steak lovers aren’t left out. Hand-cut options include an Iowa Premium NY Strip and a Delmonico.

For starters, try shishito peppers, arancini, or the polpetta with veal meatballs. Calamari is there too if you like a crunchy classic.

Lunch runs Tuesday through Friday with a “Due – Pick Two” option. Pair spaghetti red sauce with minestrone, or mix a salad with pizza.

Live music plays on Thursdays and Fridays. The mood lands somewhere between elegant and relaxed.

Planning a group dinner? Private dining fits up to 60 people, so the whole office can come along.

In early 2024, the restaurant announced it would stay put on Monroe Street. Plans included more lunch and banquet options, which is good news for Ohio pasta fans.

Address: 5453 Monroe St, Toledo, OH 43623

7. Scarsella’s Restaurant

Scarsella's Restaurant
© Scarsella’s Restaurant

Four booths, a dozen counter stools, and a single table. That was the whole setup when Luigi and Mary Grace Scarsella took over Al’s Grill on September 3, 1957.

Breakfast came first, believe it or not. Italian food took over later, and Youngstown was better for it.

Mary Grace was the culinary mind of the operation. She developed the recipes for the homemade pasta, sauce, and meatballs.

The restaurant later moved to Market Street at Florida Avenue, with seats for 50. It stayed there for 27 years before landing at its current address in 1996.

Connie Kushma, Mary Grace’s granddaughter, took over management in 1982 and owns it today. Her sons Sean, the executive chef, and Dale handle daily operations.

Meatballs and crispy veal Parmesan with sauce are big reasons people know this name. Homemade spaghetti alla chitarra and smoked chicken ravioli add some range.

Soup fans can pick Italian wedding or pasta e fagioli, both homemade. A gluten-free pasta option is available too.

Sandwiches deserve a look, especially the pepper and eggs. That one’s a classic comfort pick.

Fridays bring special treats. An Italian fish dinner and Italian fish sandwich show up only that day.

Save room for tiramisu if you can. The doors close on Sundays, so plan your fish Friday wisely.

Address: 4151 Market St, Youngstown, OH 44512

8. Moretti’s of Dublin

Moretti's of Dublin
© Moretti’s of Dublin

Even the butter is homemade. Bread, pasta, and sausage get the from-scratch treatment too.

The Moretti family started making sausage, bread, and dishes in their basement. In 1984, they opened a Grandview carryout called Armondo’s, and people started eating right there.

Tommy Moretti opened the Sawmill Road spot in 1989. He still starts his day early to prep the food.

That homemade sausage has been a staple since 1969. The recipe has passed through three generations of Moretti restaurateurs.

Pasta gets made fresh to order, including fettuccine and ravioli. You can choose egg or spinach noodles, and ravioli come filled with ground veal or ricotta.

Casseroles are a big deal here. The lineup includes traditional lasagna, sausage lasagna with spinach noodles, eggplant lasagna, and cannelloni.

Chicken Moretti and Veal Moretti carry the family name proudly. Veal Armando and Chicken Padrone add a few more house twists.

Starters include grilled peppers with fresh mozzarella and fried eggplant with ricotta. The pork sausage with banana peppers and onions is a strong opener.

Portions are generous, so a to-go box is likely. Family meals are also available for carryout.

Dinner only, Monday through Saturday, with Sundays off. The dining room recently got a remodel, so there’s a fresh look waiting in central Ohio.

Address: 5849 Sawmill Rd, Dublin, OH 43017

9. Geraci’s Restaurant

Geraci's Restaurant
© Geraci’s Restaurant University Hts

The pizza here earned a feature on Diners, Drive-ins and Dives. Not bad for a family place that opened on July 2, 1956.

Frances and Michael Geraci founded it. After five years at its first University Heights spot, it moved to Warrensville Center Road around 1961.

Their daughter Marti Geraci runs it now with her husband, Greg Spoth, and their children. That’s more than 70 years of family ownership.

The recipes trace back to a small village in Sicily. They’ve been handed down through generations of the family.

Pizza options range from a classic Deluxe to a Honey Pie. Yes, Honey Pie, and yes, you’re curious now.

The baked lasagna stacks ricotta, mozzarella, meatball, and Geraci’s sauce. Cavatelli in spicy tomato cream and gnocchi in cream pesto are worth a look too.

Appetizers lean fun, like breaded artichoke hearts, zucchini fries, and toasted ravioli. Steamed mussels work for seafood fans.

Dessert brings a Cannoli Trio, tiramisu, and spingi. Ordering one of each is a reasonable plan.

Family photos line the walls, and the kitchen has an open design. Gluten-free pasta is available, and reservations are taken by phone.

Mondays are the only day off. The rest of the week, the doors open at 11 a.m. and stay open until 9 p.m.

Address: 2266 Warrensville Center Rd, University Heights, OH 44118

10. Bocca Grande Italian Steakhouse

Bocca Grande Italian Steakhouse
© Bocca Grande Italian Steakhouse

Bocca Grande means “big mouth” in Italian. It was Larry Anderson’s grandmother’s loving nickname for him, which is adorable and a little bit of a roast.

Her homemade meals inspired both the name and the hospitality. Larry and Renee Anderson have owned the place since January 1991.

The spot sits along the historic Ohio & Erie Canal Towpath. A walk before dinner makes a lot of sense here.

The menu blends prime steaks with classic Italian recipes. Pick a filet or ribeye, or go straight for The Best Lasagna.

Bold menu name, right? Confidence like that deserves a taste test.

Spicy chicken and gnocchi and the Tuscan pasta bake give pasta fans plenty to chew on. Pizza is homemade and hand-tossed.

Starters include Boom Boom Shrimp and hot peppers stuffed with sausage and fresh mozzarella. The shrimp and corn bisque is made in-house.

Walleye shows up on the seafood list, a nice nod to the Great Lakes region. Bocca’s Signature French Dip leads the sandwich side.

Weather permitting, you can eat on the full-service patio. The Farmhouse private room fits 20 to 30 guests for rehearsal dinners and anniversaries.

Weekend reservations are recommended. Dinner runs Tuesday through Saturday, so Sunday and Monday are rest days.

Address: 4490 Erie Ave NW, Canal Fulton, OH 44614