12 Old-Fashioned Pizzerias In Mississippi That Will Blow Your Mind This Year
Pizza rarely gets top billing when people talk about Mississippi food, and that needs to change.
Beyond the barbecue counters, catfish houses, and meat-and-three plates, the state has old-fashioned pizzerias doing things the slow, satisfying way.
These are the places with familiar ovens, loyal regulars, family recipes, hand-tossed dough, bubbling cheese, and sauce that tastes like someone actually cared. No flashy gimmicks needed.
Just sturdy booths, friendly service, and pies that make you understand why locals keep coming back year after year.
It could be Gulf Coast favorites or small-town staples and college-town classics, these Mississippi pizzerias prove great pizza does not have to come from a famous food city. Sometimes, the best slice is waiting where people least expect it.
1. R&B Brick Oven Pizza
Road trips have a funny way of leading you to the best food, and R&B Brick Oven Pizza in Saucier is proof of that. Sitting along US 49, this spot rewards anyone willing to venture a little off the beaten path for a seriously good pizza experience.
The brick oven is the star of the operation, giving every crust that signature crispness on the bottom while keeping the inside soft and pillowy. Toppings are generous and flavors are bold without being overwhelming.
It is the kind of pizza that makes you stop mid-bite and just appreciate life for a second.
Head over to 19341 US 49, Saucier, MS 39574 and prepare to be converted. R&B keeps things straightforward and honest, which is exactly what a great pizzeria should do.
No gimmicks, no flashy branding, just excellent food made with care and a hot brick oven doing all the heavy lifting.
2. The Sicilian II
Five generations of family tradition live inside The Sicilian II, and you can taste every single one of them. The cornerstone lasagna recipe is over 100 years old, which tells you everything you need to know about how seriously this family takes their craft.
A recipe that old does not survive unless it is genuinely exceptional.
While the lasagna gets a lot of praise, the pizza here holds its own with real confidence. The Gulf Coast has embraced The Sicilian II as a staple, and locals keep coming back because consistency matters more than novelty in a great restaurant.
Find them at 1670 Pass Rd Unit I, Biloxi, MS 39531 for a meal that feels like a warm hug from an Italian grandmother you never knew you had. The atmosphere is relaxed and family-friendly, making it a solid pick for any occasion.
Bring your appetite and maybe a little extra room for that legendary lasagna while you are at it.
3. Pop’s Pizzeria
Pop’s Pizzeria smells like 1975 in the absolute best way possible. The bright red sign out front sets expectations high, and the aroma of baking dough, melting cheese, and simmering tomato sauce inside makes good on every single promise that sign makes.
Hand-tossed crusts are the foundation of everything here. They come out crispy on the edges and chewy in the middle, which is the gold standard for old-fashioned pizza done right.
Pop’s makes their pies the way pizza was always meant to be made, without shortcuts or substitutions.
Located at 921 Cedar Lake Rd, Biloxi, MS 39532, Pop’s is the kind of place that feels like it belongs to the whole neighborhood. The welcoming vibe hits you the moment you arrive, and the food keeps you coming back long after your first visit.
If you grew up loving a classic slice, Pop’s will remind you exactly why pizza became your favorite food in the first place.
4. Tony’s Brick Oven Pizzeria
Tony’s Brick Oven Pizzeria carries a story worth knowing. It opened as part of Gulfport’s Historic Downtown Renovation Project after Hurricane Katrina, making it a symbol of resilience and community pride on the Mississippi Gulf Coast.
Good pizza and good history make for a powerful combination.
The brick oven here is not decorative; it is doing serious work every single day. Crusts come out crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, with those satisfying charred spots that only real brick ovens can achieve.
The menu also features a Gumbo Pie pizza, which is exactly as bold and Southern as it sounds.
Tony’s is at 2417 14th St, Gulfport, MS 39501, right in the heart of the historic downtown area. Red umbrellas and brick walls give the exterior a classic Italian feel that pairs perfectly with the food inside.
Order the Gumbo Pie at least once because life is too short to skip the most creative pizza on any menu.
5. CA Sarducci’s
Old-world charm is rare, but CA Sarducci’s in Gulfport has it in abundance. The brick exterior and arched doorway make you feel like you just landed in a small Italian village without leaving Mississippi.
The warm lighting inside sets the mood before you even glance at the menu.
Their wood-fired pizzas come out with those gorgeous charred bubbles that only a proper oven can produce. Quality ingredients are not an afterthought here; they are the whole point.
Every pie reflects a genuine commitment to doing things the right way, not the fast way.
You can find CA Sarducci’s at 1308 27th Ave, Gulfport, MS 39501, and trust me, the drive is absolutely worth it. Order a classic margherita and let the simplicity floor you.
Sometimes the most traditional pies reveal the most talent behind the dough.
6. Fergndans Wood Fired Pizza Cafe
Oxford, Mississippi has a well-earned reputation for great food, and Fergndans Wood Fired Pizza Cafe adds serious credibility to that reputation.
A wood-fired oven changes everything about how a pizza tastes, and this cafe leans fully into that approach with enthusiasm and skill.
The crust here has that smoky depth that a conventional oven simply cannot replicate. Toppings are chosen thoughtfully, and the overall flavor profile of each pie feels intentional rather than random.
Fergndans is the kind of spot where you realize pizza can genuinely be an art form.
You will find this cafe at 176 MS-30, Oxford, MS 38655, making it a great stop whether you are in town for the weekend or a longtime local looking for something special. The atmosphere is relaxed and inviting, perfect for a long lunch or an unhurried dinner.
Come hungry, bring a friend, and order more than you think you need because leftovers from a wood-fired pizza cafe are never a bad idea.
7. Pizzashop
Sometimes a name tells you exactly what a place is about, and Pizzashop in Oxford delivers precisely what it promises with zero pretension.
There is something refreshing about a restaurant that skips the branding games and just focuses entirely on making great pizza every single day.
Oxford has a lively food culture thanks to Ole Miss, and Pizzashop has carved out a loyal following by keeping things real and consistent.
The slices are satisfying, the sauce has character, and the overall experience feels like what pizza was before it got complicated.
Swing by 81 Ed Perry Blvd, Oxford, MS 38655 and give yourself permission to just enjoy a simple, well-made pizza without overthinking it.
The casual atmosphere makes it a great spot for a relaxed meal between classes, after a game, or on any ordinary Tuesday that needs a little improvement.
Pizzashop proves that you do not need an elaborate concept to build a seriously devoted fan base in a college town.
8. Sal & Mookie’s Jackson
Sal & Mookie’s in Jackson is one of those places that has become genuinely woven into the fabric of the city. The name alone carries weight in Mississippi because this spot has been feeding happy people for years with a menu that balances tradition and personality in equal measure.
The pizza here is approachable and crowd-pleasing without being boring. Crusts have good structure, sauce is well-seasoned, and the cheese pull is the kind that earns an immediate smile.
It is a restaurant that understands what people actually want when they sit down for a pizza dinner.
Find Sal & Mookie’s Jackson at 200 District Blvd E, Jackson, MS 39211, right in a lively part of the city. The energy inside matches the food, which means both are consistently good.
Whether you are a first-timer or a regular, the experience feels warm and familiar in a way that only a truly community-rooted restaurant can pull off.
9. Sal & Mookie’s Madison
The Madison outpost of Sal & Mookie’s brings the same beloved energy to the suburbs with a comfortable, family-friendly setting that makes everyone feel right at home.
Colony Crossing is a busy spot, and Sal & Mookie’s holds its own as one of the top reasons people make the trip out there.
The pizza menu mirrors the quality that made the Jackson location famous, with consistent flavors and satisfying portions that never leave you disappointed.
Kids love it, adults love it, and that kind of universal appeal is genuinely hard to achieve without cutting corners, which Sal & Mookie’s refuses to do.
You can visit at 111 Colony Crossing Way Ste 130, Madison, MS 39110 for a laid-back meal that delivers real satisfaction. The atmosphere is cheerful and unpretentious, which makes it a reliable go-to for family dinners or a casual night out with friends.
Two locations, one consistent standard of quality, and zero reasons to skip a visit when you are anywhere near Madison.
10. Mimmo’s Ristorante Pizzeria
Laurel, Mississippi has been having a serious moment in the spotlight lately, and Mimmo’s Ristorante Pizzeria is one of the delicious reasons why the city deserves all the attention it gets.
Authentic Italian cooking in a Southern small town is a combination that just works beautifully.
The pizza at Mimmo’s has that homemade quality that chain restaurants spend millions trying to fake and never quite achieve. Sauce, dough, and toppings all come together with the kind of harmony that only real cooking knowledge can produce.
Every bite feels considered rather than rushed.
Head to 312 Central Ave, Laurel, MS 39440 and treat yourself to a proper Italian meal in a welcoming, unhurried setting. Mimmo’s is the kind of restaurant that makes you want to linger over your food rather than rush through it.
Order the pizza, try a pasta dish on the side, and take your time because a meal at Mimmo’s is worth savoring from the very first bite to the very last.
11. Brooklyn Pizzeria
New York-style pizza has very high standards, and Brooklyn Pizzeria in Gulfport meets them without breaking a sweat.
Large, thin, foldable slices with a crust that balances crispy and chewy is what New Yorkers expect, and this Gulfport spot delivers that experience with surprising authenticity.
The no-frills approach here is a feature, not a flaw. Good pizza does not need fancy furniture or elaborate presentations.
Brooklyn Pizzeria keeps the focus exactly where it belongs, on the quality of the slice sitting in front of you.
Mississippi might not be the first state you think of when craving New York pizza, but Brooklyn Pizzeria makes a genuinely convincing case that great pizza can happen anywhere when the right people are behind the dough.
The portions are generous and the flavors are bold without being overdone.
If you love a classic New York slice and happen to find yourself on the Gulf Coast, skipping this spot would be a serious mistake you would regret almost immediately.
12. Pizza Den Oxford
Pizza Den has been an Oxford institution since 1966, which means it has been feeding Ole Miss students longer than most of their professors have been alive.
That kind of longevity is not an accident; it is the direct result of consistently great food and a loyal community that keeps showing up.
The walls are covered in Ole Miss sports memorabilia, giving the place a personality that feels lived-in and genuine. Famous sandwiches served on Gambino’s French Bread from New Orleans add a regional twist that sets Pizza Den apart from every other pizza spot in town.
The combination of New Orleans bread and Mississippi pizza is a crossover nobody expected but everyone appreciates.
Generations of students and families have made memories at Pizza Den, and the tradition continues strong today. The menu is reliable and satisfying, anchored by Italian favorites that have stood the test of time.
If you are in Oxford and want to eat somewhere with real history and real flavor, Pizza Den on the Ole Miss campus side of town is a mandatory stop.