Skip to content

We Ranked Delaware’s 12 Best Pizza Places And These Are The Ones That Made The Cut

One pizza spot on this list shares its dining space with a model train. Honestly, I did not expect that, and it made me grin before I even got to the menu.

Another serves Detroit-style square pies just steps from the beach. A third works as a deli and bakery too, so fresh pasta and Italian sandwiches share the spotlight with wood-fired pizza. For a small state, Delaware sure has big opinions about crust.

I went digging for the pizzerias that truly stand out across the First State. A few bake in brick ovens. Wood fire, paper-thin crusts, and one famous stuffed bread round out the mix.

The list stretches from busy Wilmington corners to sandy coastal streets. I can’t imagine a tastier road trip, and I love how different each stop feels. So which crust is calling your name first?

1. La Pizzeria Metro

La Pizzeria Metro
© La Pizzeria Metro

Wood fire does the heavy lifting here, and your taste buds get the reward. This Wilmington neighborhood spot builds its menu around creative pies with fresh ingredients.

The crust is the star of the show. Expect a crisp bottom with a light, chewy bite that holds up to bold toppings.

Classic fans should start with the Margherita. If you want a little earthiness, there’s a Margherita with mushrooms that adds extra depth.

The white pizza is another strong pick. It skips red sauce and lets cheese and that blistered crust carry the flavor.

Not in a pizza mood? Calzones, garlic knots, and a bruschetta plate keep the table interesting.

There’s even a sandwich called The Wilmingtonian. You have to admire a deli creation that proudly wears its hometown on its sleeve.

Groups can share a meat and cheese board before the pies arrive. Vegetarians get plenty of choices too, since the menu has a full vegetarian lineup.

Nice weather? Outdoor seating is available, and dogs are welcome outside with you.

Plan around the schedule, because the doors stay closed on Mondays. Tuesday opens in the late afternoon, while the rest of the week starts earlier.

Friday evening tends to be the busiest stretch. A weekday lunch is a smart move if you prefer a calmer meal.

Address: 3101 Miller Rd, Wilmington, DE 19802

2. Pizza by Elizabeths

Pizza by Elizabeths
© Pizza by Elizabeths

Pizza and a tearoom might sound like an odd couple. At this Kennett Pike restaurant, the pairing feels charming instead of strange.

The room features tearoom decor, a marble counter, and a fireplace. Live music shows up regularly, which gives dinner a little extra sparkle.

So what lands on the table? Thin crust pizzas with unusual toppings lead the way, backed by beautiful salads.

The menu leans gourmet without getting stuffy. Servers are happy to walk you through the options if the creative combinations leave you curious.

Save room for something sweet. Creme brulee and Kentucky butter cake both appear on the dessert list.

Starters get playful here too. A crab pretzel nods to Mid-Atlantic tastes, while cream of tomato soup offers comfort on chilly days.

Eating plant-based? The kitchen offers full vegan and vegetarian menus, so nobody has to settle for a side salad.

Kids are welcome as well. There’s a kids’ menu and high chairs, which makes a family lunch easy.

Dinner reservations are recommended, especially on busy evenings. A private dining room is available for bigger celebrations.

Delivery, takeout, and outdoor seating round out the options. Your pizza night can be fancy or couch-friendly.

Address: 3801 Kennett Pike, Wilmington, DE 19807

3. Archie’s Pizza

Archie's Pizza
© Archie’s Pizza

Math class never tasted this good. One of the signature pies here is called the 3 14 Pepperoni Pizza, a cheeky nod to pi.

This casual Newark shop focuses on signature pies with a crust that’s crispy and chewy at the same time. That balance is tougher to pull off than it sounds.

Another pie goes by the name Sophistication Pizza. You’ll just have to order it to see if it lives up to the fancy title.

Knots get serious attention too. Garlic knots handle the savory side, while Cinna Knots bring a sugary twist for dessert.

Want more snacks? Pretzels with cheese dip and meatballs make easy add-ons for a hungry crew.

Cannolis are on hand as well. A crunchy shell is a fine way to end any pizza night.

The setup is counter service, so you order up front and grab a seat. Free Wi-Fi makes it a handy stop for students and solo diners.

Hours are a bit limited, so check before you drive. The shop is closed Mondays and opens late afternoon on weekdays.

Weekends start earlier, around lunchtime. Curbside pickup and delivery help when you’d rather eat at home.

Address: 812 Pencader Dr Ste E, Newark, DE 19702

4. Cacciatori Pizza & Pasta

Cacciatori Pizza & Pasta
© Cacciatori Pizza & Pasta

New York-style pizza without the New York traffic sounds like a great deal to me. This Newark restaurant delivers foldable slices and classic Italian dishes in a laid-back setting.

The crust gets plenty of credit for being well cooked. The sauce leans sweet, which plays nicely against salty cheese and pepperoni.

White pizza is a lunchtime favorite here. If you usually skip red-sauce-free pies, this might change your mind.

Pasta shares the menu, so the whole table can mix and match. Vegetarians have a full menu to explore too.

Families will feel right at home. There’s a kids’ menu, high chairs, and plenty of room for groups.

Service moves quickly, which matters when hunger strikes hard. Counter service and table service are both part of the setup.

Don’t bother calling ahead for a table. Reservations aren’t accepted, so just show up and grab a seat.

Outdoor seating is available when the weather cooperates. Takeout works too, though delivery isn’t offered.

Timing helps here. Mondays are closed, and Friday evening usually brings the biggest crowd.

Hours run later than many spots in town, stretching into the evening most days. That makes it a solid choice for a late pizza craving.

Address: 108 Louviers Dr, Newark, DE 19711

5. Fratelli’s Italian Specialties

Fratelli’s Italian Specialties
© Fratelli’s Italian Specialties

Can’t decide between a pizza and a cheesesteak? This family-run Middletown spot has a dish called the Pizza Steak, so you don’t have to choose.

Cheesesteaks are a signature here, including a buffalo chicken version with a spicy kick. Pizza still holds its own with a crisp crust and quality cheese.

The pies are handmade, and the lineup has some fun picks. A bruschetta pizza brings fresh, bright flavors to the party.

There’s even a heart-shaped cheese pizza. That’s an easy win for date night or a sweet surprise for the kids.

Rice balls deserve a spot in your order. They’re a classic Italian snack and a great sidekick to any pie.

Mario’s Meatballs also appear on the menu. Pair them with wings, which the kitchen cooks with plenty of flavor.

The menu keeps growing, so new items may pop up. It pays to take a fresh look whenever you stop by.

Plan on takeout or delivery, since table service isn’t part of the deal. Catering is available for parties and office lunches.

Sunday is a day off for the shop. Friday and Saturday afternoons into evening are the busiest times.

Address: 2394 Dupont Pkwy, Middletown, DE 19709

6. Pizzeria DiMeo Smyrna Delaware

Pizzeria DiMeo Smyrna Delaware
© Pizzeria DiMeo Smyrna Delaware

Garlic rolls might steal the show before your pizza even arrives. This Smyrna eatery is known for its garlic bread almost as much as its pies.

Pizza comes in several styles here, so variety is the name of the game. The thin crust version earns special attention for its crunch.

Toppings taste fresh, and the cheese and sauce stay in good balance. The seasoning adds a nice punch without overpowering the slice.

Portions run large, so hungry diners can relax. Leftovers are pretty much part of the plan.

Pasta lovers get traditional Italian dishes too. A salad bar adds a lighter option for anyone wanting greens on the side.

The menu even includes organic dishes. That’s a nice touch you don’t see at many pizza places.

Bringing the whole crew? Families and groups fit in easily, with high chairs and a kids’ menu ready.

Reservations are accepted, which helps on busy Friday and Saturday evenings. Mornings tend to be much quieter.

Delivery, including no-contact delivery, is available if you’d rather stay home. Catering covers bigger events.

The staff and management are friendly, which makes the whole visit easy. Smyrna sits right in the middle of Delaware, so it’s a handy stop for travelers too.

Address: 2499 S Dupont Blvd, Smyrna, DE 19977

7. Veronica’s Pizzeria

Veronica's Pizzeria
© Mohio Pizza Co.

A brick oven, a thin crust, and handmade sauce make a pretty convincing trio. This Dover neighborhood pizzeria puts all three to work.

The crust comes out thin and crispy, with fresh ingredients on top. The sauce is made by hand, which you can taste in each bite.

Specialty pies carry fun names. The Margy is the Margherita option, while The Bart is a meat-loaded pizza topped with sausage, pepperoni, bacon, and meatballs.

Craving heat? The buffalo chicken pizza brings that tangy, spicy flavor fans love.

Meatball lovers should look for The Polpette. Polpette is the Italian word for meatballs, so you know what you’re getting.

Eggplant parm and garlic knots fill out the savory side. For dessert, a cannoli is waiting.

The space is small and cute, with counter service and seating. Free Wi-Fi and TVs for watching sports make it easy to linger.

Dogs can join you outside. High chairs are ready for the youngest pizza fans.

Here’s a perk: the doors open daily, even on Mondays. Sunday evening is one of the busiest times.

Need pies for a party? Catering and delivery are both available around Dover.

Address: 50 N Dupont Hwy Bldg 1, Unit 11, Dover, DE 19901

8. The Brick-Wood Fired Eats

The Brick-Wood Fired Eats
© The Brick-Wood Fired Eats

Dessert pizza is on the menu here, and I fully support that decision. This Dover eatery fires up a brick oven for savory and sweet pies alike.

The restaurant calls itself New American, but the wood-fired pizza is the real draw. Flavorful wings make a strong second act.

White pizza gets plenty of love for tasting like a New York slice. If you miss big-city pizza, this is a smart place to start.

The appetizer list is worth a close look. Bacon-wrapped jalapenos stuffed with cream cheese bring smoky, spicy, creamy goodness.

Meatball appetizers and garlic knots are also on deck. Sharing is encouraged, though nobody will blame you for guarding your plate.

Inside, the fire oven sets the scene. The mood stays casual, with attentive servers keeping things moving.

Families are welcome, with a kids’ menu and high chairs available. Groups can book ahead, since reservations are accepted.

Check the calendar before you go. The restaurant is closed Sundays and Mondays.

Tuesday opens in the late afternoon, and the rest of the week starts at noon. Friday evening is the busiest window.

Curbside pickup and delivery are handy if you want wood-fired pizza at home. Catering is available too.

Address: 150 Gateway S Blvd, Dover, DE 19901

9. Polisenos Pizzeria Milford Location

Polisenos Pizzeria Milford Location
© Polisenos Pizzeria Milford Location

Game day plans in Milford often lead straight to this pizzeria. Quick service and a convenient spot on Dupont Boulevard make it an easy stop.

New York-style pizza is the specialty here. The crust gets high marks, and the toppings don’t cut corners.

Pepperoni lovers are in luck. The pepperoni is top quality, and the Italian sausage holds its own too.

Pizza is only part of the fun. Hot wings and cheese fries make the menu feel like a full tailgate spread.

The dining room stays clean and casual. It’s an easy place to eat with family or grab a quiet solo meal.

Kids have their own menu, and high chairs are available. Free Wi-Fi is a bonus if you need to check scores.

Feeding a team or a party? Catering is available, and reservations are accepted.

Delivery covers nights when the couch wins. No-contact delivery is also an option.

Hours run long, starting in the morning most days. Weekends stretch a little later into the evening.

Saturday evening tends to be the busiest. Thursday and Sunday mornings are usually much calmer, if you can handle pizza that early.

Address: 923 N Dupont Blvd, Milford, DE 19963

10. Nicola Pizza

Nicola Pizza
© Nicola Pizza

Ask around the Delaware beaches about stuffed bread, and one name keeps popping up. Nicola Pizza is the home of the famous Nic-O-Boli.

This family-owned spot started out in Rehoboth Beach and is now based in Lewes. It’s been feeding beach crowds for decades, which makes it a true local institution.

The Nic-O-Boli comes in several versions. You’ll find a No Beef option and a Healthy Heart vegetarian version for different tastes.

The pizza holds up its end of the deal. Expect a hand-tossed, boardwalk-style crust with butter, plenty of mozzarella, and a sweet sauce.

Kids get an extra treat here. The family-friendly space includes a model train, which is pure fun while you wait.

Fried pickles, pepperoni rolls, and a pail of fries fill out the snack list. Baked ziti supreme brings heartier pasta comfort.

Reservations aren’t accepted, so arrive with a little patience. Friday, Saturday, and Sunday evenings draw the biggest crowds.

Hours run late, until 11 PM daily. That’s perfect after a long beach day.

Birthday parties are welcome, and a private dining room is available. Changing tables and a kids’ menu make family visits smooth.

Address: 17323 Ocean One Plz, Lewes, DE 19958

11. Touch of Italy

Touch of Italy
© Touch of Italy

Look up when you enter, because cheese and sausage hang from the ceiling. That’s your first clue this Lewes spot takes Italian food seriously.

It works as an eatery, deli, and bakery all in one. Wood-fired pizza shares the spotlight with homemade pasta.

The pizzas arrive neatly sectioned, with rich cheese, olive oil, sauce, and fresh green herbs. It’s the kind of pie that looks great before you even take a bite.

Craving pasta? Lasagne and gnocchi calciano are both on the menu.

The Calzone di Napoli comes stuffed with ricotta, fresh mozzarella, and Genoa salami, making it a hearty choice for meat lovers. Garlic cheese bread is an easy add-on for the table.

Deli fans can grab a cold sandwich called Da Paulie. Antipasto platters and eggplant rolls also make tasty starters.

Second Street puts you right in the heart of historic downtown Lewes. Parking can be tricky, so plan a short stroll.

The Lewes location does not accept reservations, so arriving early may help you avoid a longer wait on busy Saturdays. Weekday mornings tend to be calmer.

Outdoor seating is available when the coastal breeze is nice. Takeout works too, though delivery isn’t offered.

Kids get their own menu and high chairs. Save room for dessert from the bakery side.

Address: 101 2nd St, Lewes, DE 19958

12. Ava’s Pizzeria & Wine Bar – Rehoboth Beach

Ava's Pizzeria & Wine Bar - Rehoboth Beach
© Ava’s Pizzeria & Wine Bar – Rehoboth Beach

Square pizza near the sand? Rehoboth Beach makes it happen with scratch-made Detroit-style pies on Baltimore Avenue.

Detroit-style pizza is baked in a rectangular pan. The result is a thick, airy crust with crispy, cheesy edges that fans can’t stop picking at.

The Detroit Pepperoni is the menu star. Traditional round pizzas are also available if you prefer the classic shape.

Pasta gets equal love here. Spaghetti and MA’s Meatballs sounds like a family recipe, and it’s a hearty partner for any pie.

Plant-based eaters have options, including vegetarian pizzas and the ability to customize certain pies with vegan cheese. That’s a big plus for mixed groups.

The restaurant opens only for dinner, starting in the late afternoon. Tuesday is the day off, so plan around it.

Friday and Saturday evenings fill up fast. Dinner reservations are recommended, especially during busy beach weeks.

Families are welcome, with a kids’ menu, high chairs, and changing tables. Dogs can hang out with you outside.

Parking means paid street spots, which is typical for downtown Rehoboth. Leave a few extra minutes to find one.

Takeout is available, though delivery isn’t. A square slice on the boardwalk sounds like a perfect Delaware evening to me.

Address: 29 Baltimore Ave, Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971