We Ranked The 10 Best Pie Shops In New York And Here Are The Results

A pie shop in New York sells key lime pie on a stick, dipped in dark chocolate. I had to read that twice. Then I learned that another bakery calls its cherry pie Will You Marry Me Cherry.

Pie in this state gets surprisingly creative. One upstate bakery is famous for grape pie, a regional treat that plenty of people have never even heard of. An orchard on Long Island bakes its pies with fruit grown right on the property.

I love that range. City bakeries share this list with farm shops and orchard counters miles from the nearest subway. One spot asks you to order ahead, and another opens for only a few hours on select afternoons.

So which slices earned a spot, and how far would you travel for one? I have a feeling your answer might change by the end of this list.

10. Little Pie Company

Pie in three sizes means you never have to choose between a solo treat and a party dessert. That simple idea has kept this Hell’s Kitchen bakery busy since 1985.

The shop calls itself no-frills, and that suits the pies just fine. Bakers make them from scratch, and the case also holds cakes, cookies, and muffins.

Start with the Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie, the house signature. Its apple filling balances sweet and tart, and the spices land right where they should.

Southern Pecan Pie is another strong pick if you like rich, nutty slices. Fans of fruit can try the Three Berry Pie, which brings a bright, jammy mix to the table.

Craving something creamy instead? The Florida Key Lime Pie is smooth, and the Banana Coconut Cream Pie feels like a tropical break from Midtown traffic.

Mississippi Mud Pie covers the chocolate lovers in your group. You can also grab bread pudding or an oven-fresh muffin if breakfast is on your mind.

A small seating area lets you eat a slice on the spot with a cup of coffee. Pickup, takeout, and delivery are also available when you need a whole pie for later.

Timing helps here. Friday and Saturday afternoons tend to get busy, while Sunday and Thursday mornings are much calmer, so plan your New York pie run around those windows.

Address: 424 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036

9. Petee’s Pie Company

Late-night pie cravings finally have a home on the Lower East Side. Doors stay open until 11 PM, which makes this shop a dream for anyone who thinks dessert should come after dinner and a movie.

Classic and modern pies share the menu here. Local ingredients go into the fillings, and the crust comes out buttery and flaky.

The Salty Chocolate Chess is the slice to try first. It’s sweet, a little salty, and comes as a single slice or a whole pie.

Brown Butter Honey Pecan gives the old pecan pie a richer, toasty twist. The Hudson Valley Apple Slice keeps things classic with fruit from upstate New York.

Cream pie fans can grab a Banana Cream Slice. Chess pie lovers may also spot lemon chess and sweet potato options depending on the day.

Then there’s the Pecan Pie Ice Cream, sold in small cups. Yes, pie inside ice cream, which feels like a very smart idea.

Coffee is on the menu if you need a little boost. The shop works best as a quick stop, since there’s no restroom on site.

Whole pies make easy gifts for birthdays or dinner parties. Pickup, takeout, and delivery all help you get one home without squishing it on the subway.

Address: 61 Delancey St, New York, NY 10002

8. Four & Twenty Blackbirds

Named after a nursery rhyme, this Gowanus bakery takes pie far more seriously than its playful title suggests. Sisters Emily and Melissa Elsen opened it in 2009, and it has become a Brooklyn favorite.

The menu changes with the seasons, so your next visit may look different from your last. You can buy pies whole or grab a single slice.

Salted caramel apple is a big draw, with a flaky crust and a sweet and salty balance. Many people call it one of the best apple pies in the city.

The salty honey pie is the other famous one. Its custard filling is sweet and smooth, with just enough salt to keep you reaching for another bite.

Feeling adventurous? Matcha Custard pie brings a delicate, creamy texture and gentle sweetness that feels perfect with an afternoon coffee.

Slices here are generous, so sharing is an option, though nobody will judge you for not sharing. The shop also serves breakfast hours on weekdays starting at 8 AM.

Need to get some work done? Free Wi-Fi, outlets, and room to sit make it a comfortable spot to linger.

Weekend afternoons can get busy. Weekday evenings tend to be quieter, which is a nice time to claim a table and a slice.

Address: 439 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

7. Steve’s Authentic Key Lime Pie

Key lime pie on a stick, dipped in dark chocolate, sounds like a fair snack to invent. Red Hook’s famous citrus specialist sells exactly that, and it’s called the Swingle.

The shop focuses on one thing and does it with real pride. Fresh-baked key lime pies sit at the center of the menu.

A graham cracker crust holds the filling, which is smooth, creamy, and full of lime flavor. Many people treat it as the benchmark key lime pie in New York City.

The Classic Swingle is the frozen version of that dream. It’s a key lime tart, dipped in dark chocolate, that you can eat while strolling.

Love berries too? A raspberry key lime version on a stick also gets plenty of attention.

Red Hook sits along the Brooklyn waterfront, so the trip feels like a small adventure. Dogs are allowed, which means your four-legged buddy can tag along for the walk.

Keep in mind there’s no restroom on site. This is a quick visit kind of place, so grab your treat and wander.

Hours start at noon on weekdays and 11 AM on weekends. Saturday afternoons get busy, while Sunday mornings are the calmest time to swing by.

Address: 185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

6. Noble Pies Bakery and Cafe

Any bakery that names a pie Will You Marry Me Cherry clearly has a sense of humor. You’ll find that sweet proposal on the menu at this family-owned spot in Warwick.

Fruit pies and savory dinner pies get equal love here. The crusts are rich, and the fruit fillings come packed with plenty of fruit.

That cherry pie is perfectly balanced, whether or not anyone pops the question. Hudson Valley Apple and Wild Blueberry with Pastry Crust keep things rooted in classic flavors.

Leslie’s Lime Pie offers a tangy option. Banana cream pie also earns plenty of love from pie fans.

Savory pies might steal the show, honestly. Chicken Pot Pie is rich and hearty, and the Vegetable Curry Pie brings a creative twist.

A Vegetable Quiche rounds out the savory side for breakfast or lunch. The cafe opens at 8 AM, so pie for breakfast is fully on the table.

The newer Warwick location is comfortable for catching up with friends over a slice. Free Wi-Fi and a restroom make it easy to stay a while.

Parking is simple, with a free lot and free street parking. Sunday, Thursday, and Saturday afternoons draw the biggest crowds, so come early if you want a quieter table.

Address: 12 Oakland Ave, Warwick, NY 10990

5. Briermere Farms

Few pies can claim their fruit traveled only a few steps from tree to crust. At this North Fork orchard, the pies and pastries use fruit grown right on the property.

Briermere Farms runs a retail shop on Sound Avenue in Riverhead. Homemade pies are the main event, but jellies, jams, and pastries also fill the shelves.

The pie selection covers a wide range of fruit and cream varieties. That variety is a big reason Long Islanders treat this stop as a must on any North Fork trip.

Locally grown produce is also part of the draw. You can pick up fresh fruit for home while you’re grabbing a pie for dessert.

Here’s a tip for pie planning. Since the fruit comes from the farm, it makes sense to ask what’s in season when you visit.

The jams and jellies make handy souvenirs. They pack easily, which is great if you’re heading back to the city or farther.

Briermere Farms is open daily from 9 AM to 5 PM during its regular season, which runs from April through Christmas Eve. That steady schedule makes it easy to plan a weekend drive out east.

A free on-site parking lot takes the stress out of arriving. Just park, pick your pie, and try not to eat it in the car before you get home.

Address: 4414 Sound Ave, Riverhead, NY 11901

4. Monica’s Pies LLC

Grape pie might sound unusual, but in the Finger Lakes it’s practically a local treasure. Monica’s Pies in Naples is known as a classic home for this purple, fruity favorite.

Naples sits in grape country, so the pie fits right in. The filling uses Concord grapes, giving it a bold flavor you won’t find in most bakeries.

The shop is known far and wide for that grape pie. Still, the menu offers plenty of other choices if you want to try more than one.

Blueberry pie gets huge praise, with some calling it the best they’ve ever tasted. Dutch apple and strawberry-rhubarb also make appearances for fans of classic fruit.

Savory pies are part of the mix too. Chicken pot pie makes an easy dinner after a day of exploring the area.

Homemade jams are another nice find here. They make great gifts for friends who couldn’t join the trip.

Customer service is a point of pride at this bakery. That friendly touch adds to the small-town charm of a stop in Naples.

A free parking lot makes pulling in easy. Consider this your excuse for a scenic upstate New York drive with a grape pie as the reward.

Address: 7599 State Rte 21, Naples, NY 14512

3. Smith’s Orchard & Bake Shop

Cider donuts and homemade pies under one roof sounds like a perfect fall day. This orchard bake shop in Ballston Spa serves both, all year round during open hours.

Pies are the headliner, with fruit-packed fillings and a crust described as crazy flaky. Apple Pie and Pecan Pie are two of the classics worth grabbing.

Don’t skip the Apple Cider Donuts. They pair well with pie, or with a car ride home if you can’t wait.

Turnovers and carrot cake also show up in the bakery case. The shop even sells locally produced meats, preserves, and other pantry goodies.

Livestock on site adds some extra fun. Kids and grown-ups alike may enjoy a quick look around.

One handy feature stands out. Customers can order homemade pies for store pickup, making it easier to plan ahead for busy schedules.

This is a takeout spot, with no dine-in service and no restroom. Curbside pickup helps if you’d rather stay in your car.

Watch the calendar, since the shop closes on Tuesdays. Saturday mornings get busy, so arrive early for the best pie selection.

Address: 4561 Jockey St, Ballston Spa, NY 12020

2. Portage Pie

Planning ahead pays off in Westfield, where the local pie shop recommends advance ordering. Once you taste a slice, you’ll understand why people reserve their pies early.

Portage Pie specializes in handmade fruit and cream pies. The crusts come out flaky, and the fillings taste fresh and full of flavor.

Red raspberry pies get special attention here. The Raspberry and Mixed Berry pies are both standout choices.

Grape pie also has a place on the menu, which fits Chautauqua County’s grape-growing roots. The staff are friendly and happy to talk about how they make them.

That kind of chat is part of the charm. You might leave with a pie and a few baking tips for your own kitchen.

The shop also offers items that make nice gifts. Pies themselves are a pretty great present too, if you ask anyone with a sweet tooth.

Keep in mind this is a takeout spot, with no dine-in service and no restroom. Grab your order and enjoy it at home or on a picnic.

Hours run Wednesday through Sunday, with shorter hours on Sunday. Monday and Tuesday are closed, so plan your western New York pie trip around that.

Address: 42 N Portage St, Westfield, NY 14787

1. Newbury Park Pastries

Dinner and dessert can come home from the same Rochester bakery, where freshly baked sweets accompany frozen savory pies designed to be baked at home. Newbury Park Pastries sells freshly prepared sweet pies and frozen savory pot pies that customers can bake at home.

Pot pies are a big part of the appeal. They make an easy, no-mess homemade dinner on a busy weeknight.

The pies here are huge and packed with filling. The hand-made shell comes out flaky, which is exactly what you want from a great crust.

Sweet pies and tarts fill out the menu nicely. Specialty pies are especially popular, so they’re worth a look when you stop in.

Not a pie person? Cheesecakes, brownies, and cut-out cookies are also on offer.

Hours here are short, so check before you go. The shop opens Thursdays from 3 to 5 PM for standard savory pies only, Fridays from 3 to 6 PM, and Saturdays from 11 AM to 3 PM, with desserts and specialty pies unavailable for Thursday pickup.

That small window makes each visit feel like a mini event. Curbside pickup helps if you’re squeezing it into a packed day.

There’s no dine-in service or restroom, but a free on-site lot keeps things simple. It’s a fitting final stop for anyone who believes pie belongs at both dinner and dessert.

Address: 205 Mushroom Blvd, Rochester, NY 14623