Skip to content

A Little Piece Of Sicily Is Waiting Inside This Wisconsin Italian Restaurant

A pizza oven built in Naples fires up to 900 degrees here and finishes a crust in about 90 seconds. That alone made me stop scrolling. Then I learned the chef behind it was born in a Sicilian fishing harbor.

His family recipes made the trip across the ocean with him. The walls carry painted murals of his hometown. Small replicas of family fishing boats add to the scene.

I appreciate a place that wears its roots this proudly. The menu leans on handmade pasta dough, imported olive oil, and seafood seasoned with coastal herbs. It all sits on a quiet stretch of a Wisconsin neighborhood.

I can see why people make a special trip for a taste of Sicily without a passport. So what does that taste like on a Milwaukee evening?

A Sicilian Fishing Village Lives On In Every Recipe

A Sicilian Fishing Village Lives On In Every Recipe
© Carini’s Southern Italian Restaurant

Porticello is a small fishing harbor on the coast of Sicily. Chef Peter Carini was born there, and his cooking still points straight back home.

Carini’s Southern Italian Restaurant, also called Carini’s La Conca D’Oro, opened in 1996. Peter started it with his wife, Janice, after decades of cooking in the United States.

His American kitchen career began in 1966. Along the way, he became executive chef at the Milwaukee Athletic Club before launching a place of his own.

The name has a story too. La Conca D’Oro means Golden Shell, a reference to the coastal landscape around Palermo, Sicily.

That background matters once the plates arrive. The recipes come from the Carini family, carried across the ocean and kept close for generations.

I love knowing a dish has a hometown. It turns a regular dinner into something with a little more heart and a lot more history.

So when you sit down, you’re tasting more than a menu. You’re tasting a harbor, a family, and a chef who never let go of where he started.

That Naples Oven Works Faster Than You Can Unfold A Napkin

That Naples Oven Works Faster Than You Can Unfold A Napkin
© Carini’s Southern Italian Restaurant

Ninety seconds. That’s about how long a pizza spends inside the custom oven made in Naples, Italy. The oven reaches around 900 degrees. Heat like that bakes a crust quickly, which is the whole point of true wood-fired pizza.

You’ll spot the oven easily near the entrance. It acts like a glowing welcome sign for anyone who loves a good pie.

The Margherita keeps things classic and simple. For a little heat, the Diavola brings spicy salami to the party.

Feeling bold? The Quattro Gusti piles on fresh mozzarella, mushrooms, artichokes, prosciutto cotto, and kalamata olives. That’s a lot of flavor on one crust, and I respect the ambition.

Pizza fans in Wisconsin have plenty of choices. Few of them come from an oven that actually traveled from Naples to get here.

Here’s my advice for a group. Order one pizza for the table as a starter while everyone studies the rest of the menu. It buys time and keeps hungry people happy, which is a skill every dinner host needs.

Save Room For The Seafood Pasta That Carries The Restaurant’s Name

Save Room For The Seafood Pasta That Carries The Restaurant's Name
© Carini’s Southern Italian Restaurant

Shrimp, mussels, clams, and calamari all share one plate. That lineup belongs to the Conca d’Oro Seafood Pasta, a signature house dish. It comes over spaghetti with garlic and the restaurant’s signature marinara sauce.

A seafood dish fits this kitchen perfectly. Remember, the chef grew up in a fishing harbor, so this plate feels like a family postcard.

The menu also highlights fresh seafood seasoned with coastal Sicilian herbs. Handmade pasta doughs and imported cold-pressed extra virgin olive oil round out the kitchen’s careful approach.

Pasta lovers have other strong options too. Homemade lasagna, Nonna’s Bolognese, and shrimp with broccolini over fettuccine all make appearances.

Gluten-free pasta is available as well. That’s helpful news for anyone who usually skips the pasta page entirely.

I’d call the seafood pasta the dish that tells the story best. If you only get one visit, it deserves a serious look before you settle on something familiar.

Three Days Of Marinating Earns This Lamb Its Big Title

Three Days Of Marinating Earns This Lamb Its Big Title
© Carini’s Southern Italian Restaurant

Some dishes need patience. Peter’s World Famous Rack of Lamb spends three days marinating in seasoned garlic oil before it ever hits the grill.

After that, it gets char-grilled. Then the kitchen finishes it with breadcrumbs and serves it with garlic whipped potato.

Calling anything world famous takes confidence. Honestly, three days of prep sounds like a pretty good reason to brag a little. The menu offers a half rack too. That’s a smart pick if you want lamb but still plan to leave room for dessert.

Not a lamb person? The parm dishes are a big draw here, from chicken parmigiana to eggplant parmigiana. Veal parmigiana is also on the list. Chicken marsala and chicken alfredo give comfort-food fans even more to consider.

The kitchen follows a scratch-cooking approach. Homemade sausage and imported San Marzano tomatoes show how seriously the team takes its ingredients.

My take is simple. Order the lamb if you want the chef’s personality on a plate, and order a parm if you want a warm hug instead.

Rice Balls And Crispy Bites Make Starting Way Too Easy

Rice Balls And Crispy Bites Make Starting Way Too Easy
© Carini’s Southern Italian Restaurant

Arancini are a Sicilian classic. At this restaurant, the deep-fried rice balls come filled with meat sauce, peas, and cheese. That’s a lot packed into one golden bite. It’s also a great way to taste Sicily before the main course shows up.

Hand-breaded mozzarella arrives with the house marinara. Cheese and sauce together rarely disappoint anyone at the table.

Bruschetta comes on grilled Sciortino’s bread with garlic and tomato. Sciortino’s is a longtime Milwaukee bakery name, so that detail adds some local flavor.

Deep-fried eggplant strips are another option. They make a fun choice for anyone who loves eggplant but wants something lighter than a full parm dinner.

Fried mushrooms with marinara for dipping round out the crispy choices. Clearly, this kitchen enjoys a good fryer.

Here’s a friendly tip for groups. Pick two starters and share them, since main courses here lean generous. I can’t imagine skipping the arancini, though. They’re small, they’re traditional, and they’re basically a passport stamp you can eat.

Murals Of Porticello Turn The Walls Into A Sicilian Postcard

Murals Of Porticello Turn The Walls Into A Sicilian Postcard
© Carini’s Southern Italian Restaurant

Look up from your plate for a second. The walls show murals of places around Porticello, painted by artist John Koch.

Small replicas of family fishing boats sit around the space. Photographs of Porticello by Esther Shapiro add even more of the chef’s hometown.

The overall mood feels warm, rustic, and homey. It’s a Mediterranean look that fits right in on a chilly Milwaukee night. Some pieces came from far away too. The oven, tile, and bar are among items imported from Naples.

Carini’s Southern Italian Restaurant also offers plenty of room to spread out. There’s a bar area, two main dining rooms, and two private rooms.

Patio-style seating is available for warmer days. Wisconsin summers are short, so outdoor dinners always feel like a bonus prize.

I appreciate decor that actually means something. Every boat and painting connects back to one real place and one real family. Spend a minute exploring before you order. The walls tell the story just as well as the menu does.

Three Generations Keep The Family Table Running

Three Generations Keep The Family Table Running
© Carini’s Southern Italian Restaurant

Family businesses are tough to keep going for decades. Carini’s has done it since 1996, and the family is still very much involved.

Peter’s children, Lisa and Gregg, are part of the restaurant. His grandson PJ is involved too, making this a true multi-generational effort.

Peter himself has been known to greet diners at their tables. He shares the story behind the restaurant and his pride in his Sicilian heritage.

That kind of personal touch is getting rare. Big chains can copy recipes, but they can’t copy a grandfather telling you where the food came from.

Three decades on North Oakland Avenue adds up to something special. The restaurant has become a fixture in its corner of Milwaukee’s East Side. Families gather here for birthdays and big dinners. Couples come for date nights too.

I love how the place feels connected from one generation to the next. The recipes passed down to Peter are now being passed along again. That’s how a little piece of Sicily stays alive in Wisconsin. One family, one kitchen, and a lot of handmade pasta.

Cannoli Lovers, Your Grand Finale Has Arrived

Cannoli Lovers, Your Grand Finale Has Arrived
© Carini’s Southern Italian Restaurant

A Sicilian restaurant without cannoli would be a strange thing. Thankfully, Carini’s fills them fresh, the way this classic pastry deserves. Crunchy shell, creamy filling, done. It’s a simple dessert, and that’s exactly why it works so well.

Tiramisu is another option for the coffee-and-cream crowd. The lava cake gives chocolate fans something rich to dig into. Then there’s the limoncello cheesecake. It’s a bright, lemony twist that fits nicely after a hearty pasta dinner.

Here’s my practical advice. Decide on dessert before dinner, because portions here tend to be generous and your appetite may vanish. Splitting a dessert is never a bad plan. Order two different ones for the table and pass them around like a tasting menu.

Celebrating something? A birthday dinner with cannoli at the end sounds like a solid tradition to start. I can’t imagine leaving without at least one sweet bite. After a chef traveled all the way from Sicily, skipping the cannoli feels almost rude.

Plan Around The Hours And Grab A Table Before The Rush

Plan Around The Hours And Grab A Table Before The Rush
© Carini’s Southern Italian Restaurant

Timing matters here. Carini’s Southern Italian Restaurant opens at 3:30 p.m. Wednesday through Sunday and stays closed Mondays and Tuesdays.

Closing time is 8:30 p.m. on Wednesday, Thursday, and Sunday. Friday and Saturday run a little later, until 9:30 p.m. You’ll find it at 3468 N Oakland Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53211. It sits in the Downer Woods neighborhood on Milwaukee’s East Side.

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends. Walk-ins are welcome when the dining room has space, so a little planning helps.

Staying in tonight? Online ordering is available for pickup, with curbside or counter options. Bigger plans are covered too. The restaurant hosts private events in its dining rooms and offers off-site catering for family parties or work gatherings.

Specials pop up on certain weeknights as well. It’s worth asking about them when you book.

For anyone in Wisconsin craving real Sicilian cooking, this address belongs on your list. Pick a Wednesday, call ahead, and let a Porticello family recipe handle the rest.