Skip to content

The 10 Remote Finger Lakes, New York Bakeries Most Travelers Never Find

Frozen grape pies wait in a small farm stand freezer, and shoppers simply pay on the honor system. I love that a whole pie can sit there unwatched, quietly trusting you to do the right thing.

The baker behind those pies has been at it for more than 38 years, which is a lot of crust. Grape pie runs deep around here, too, since it became a beloved local tradition back in the 1960s.

Concord grapes give the filling a deep purple color and a bold, jammy sweetness you won’t forget. One bite might ruin ordinary fruit pies for your kids forever, so consider yourself fairly warned.

Bakeries like that rarely sit on the busy tourist strips in this quiet corner of New York. Finding them takes a few extra back roads, but the payoff tastes worth every single winding mile.

1. Monica’s Pies LLC

Monica's Pies LLC
© Monica’s Pies LLC

Grape pie sounds like a dare until you learn a whole town built a tradition around it. Out on State Route 21, this shop has spent more than 38 years turning Concord grapes into its signature pie.

The baker here became known locally as the Grape Pie Queen. That’s a pretty great title to earn from your hometown.

Naples has been making grape pies since the 1960s, so the competition isn’t exactly light. Still, this shop’s grape pies have picked up awards along the way.

Grapes aren’t the only option, though. The lineup includes apple, Dutch apple, blueberry, cherry, peach, elderberry, red raspberry, and strawberry rhubarb.

Craving something richer? Look for pecan, chocolate walnut, pumpkin, or caramel apple nut crunch.

Savory fans get a win too, since chicken pot pies are on the menu. Jams, jellies, conserves, and grape bread round out the shelves.

Here’s the fun part for planners. A self-service setup runs daily from 9 AM to 5 PM, offering frozen unbaked grape pies and jams.

Bring cash for those self-service visits, since that’s the only payment option. You bake the pie at home, which means your kitchen gets the best smell in town.

The shop also opens to the public on select dates with a wider pie selection. Those dates line up with the Naples Grape Festival in late September, plus Thanksgiving and Christmas.

Check ahead before you go, because those special days come and go fast. Then point your car toward the Bristol Hills and enjoy the drive.

Address: 7599 State Rte 21, Naples, NY 14512

2. Plenty the Bakery

Plenty the Bakery
© Plenty the Bakery

Weekend-only bakeries play hard to get, and this one plays the game well. Doors open Saturday and Sunday from 8 AM to 3 PM, or until the goods sell out.

That last part matters. If your heart is set on a cinnamon bun, sleeping in is a risky move.

The bakery sits along NY-64 in a quiet hillside pocket outside Naples. It feels far from the busy lake towns, which is part of the charm.

A classically trained chef from the Culinary Institute of America runs the kitchen with her husband. They opened it while chasing a slower, more intentional way of life.

You can taste that care in the menu. Expect artisan pastries, cookies, cinnamon buns, and signature quiches made with fine, often local, ingredients.

Savory cravings are well covered here. Breakfast sandwiches are a big draw, and a grilled cheese has earned plenty of attention too.

Seasonal savory galettes show up as well, such as butternut squash and spinach. Pair one with a coffee and you’ve got a proper country breakfast.

Presentation is a point of pride here. The pastries look carefully finished, almost too pretty to eat.

Almost. A newly renovated outdoor area gives you a place to sit and enjoy the hillside air.

Plan your Finger Lakes weekend around an early stop here. Your later plans can wait an hour, but the quiche might not.

Address: 6459 NY-64, Naples, NY 14512

3. Blue Heron Bakery

Blue Heron Bakery
© Blue Heron Bakery

Butter does a lot of heavy lifting at this Water Street bakery. Laminated pastries are the specialty, meaning layer after layer of dough and butter folded together.

The result is croissants and danishes with real crunch. They lean crisp and not too sweet, which makes a second one dangerously easy.

Bread gets equal billing here. The loaves and rolls are scratch-made and fresh, so grabbing one for later is a smart idea.

Penn Yan sits at the north end of Keuka Lake, surrounded by Yates County farmland. It’s a working small town, not a polished resort strip.

That makes the bakery an easy one to miss. Most visitors cruise past on the way to the lake.

Hungry for more than pastry? Sandwiches are on offer too, and they make a solid breakfast or lunch on the go.

Coffee is available, so you can build a full morning stop. Grab a croissant, a cup, and a loaf for the road.

Timing takes some planning, since the bakery keeps short hours. It’s open Thursday through Saturday from 8 AM to 3 PM.

Sunday hours run from 8 AM to 1 PM. Monday through Wednesday, the ovens take a break.

A free lot makes the stop simple. Leave room in the car for bread, because you’ll probably buy more than you planned.

Address: 136 Water St, Penn Yan, NY 14527

4. Oak Leaf Cafe & Bakery Penn Yan

Oak Leaf Cafe & Bakery Penn Yan
© Oak Leaf Cafe & Bakery Penn Yan

Few bakeries come with a side of bulk oats and spices, but this one does. It shares space with a bulk foods market on rural NY-14A south of Penn Yan.

The road runs through farmland dotted with Old Order Mennonite farms. Between Keuka and Seneca lakes, it’s a peaceful stretch of New York countryside.

Inside, the cafe feels bright and clean. A fireplace adds a homey touch on chilly mornings.

Breakfast is a strong reason to stop. Try the Seneca Sunrise Sandwich, a vegetarian pick named for the nearby lake.

Baked oatmeal is another morning favorite. It’s hearty enough to fuel a full day of exploring.

Lunch leans toward paninis, which come out hot and fast. A full vegetarian menu makes it easy for mixed groups to find something.

Then there’s the bakery side. Cookies and other baked goods tempt you on the way to the register.

Tea fans get a nice selection, and coffee is solid too. Free Wi-Fi makes it a handy stop if you need to catch up on email.

Families will appreciate the kids’ menu and high chairs. Outdoor seating is available when the weather cooperates.

Hours run Monday through Saturday from 7 AM to 4 PM. Saturdays get busiest, so a weekday visit is your quieter bet.

Address: 3173 NY-14A, Penn Yan, NY 14527

5. Clarisse’s Cottage

Clarisse's Cottage
© Clarisse’s Cottage

Crackers rarely steal the show at a sweets shop. At this little Main Street spot, artisanal crackers sit right beside the cookies and biscotti.

The shop describes its mission as carrying on a delicious legacy one cookie at a time. Honestly, that’s a mission statement worth supporting.

Hammondsport is a tiny village at the southern tip of Keuka Lake. Fewer than 600 people call it home.

That small size means you can stroll Main Street in minutes. A stop for cookies fits right into a lazy village wander.

Shortbread is the headliner here. It’s buttery, simple, and the kind of treat that pairs well with a lake view.

Biscotti make another smart pick. They travel well, so a bag can ride along for the rest of your trip.

Pastries round out the case too. Selection may vary, so peek in and see what’s ready that day.

Those crackers deserve a spot in your bag. They’d be right at home on a picnic board with local cheese and fruit.

The hours are a bit unusual, so plan carefully. It’s open Monday through Friday and Sunday from 9 AM to 5 PM.

Saturday is the day off, which surprises plenty of weekend travelers. Pickup options are available if you’d rather grab and go.

Address: 41 Main St, Hammondsport, NY 14840

6. Dave & Rita’s Farm Market & Bakery

Dave & Rita's Farm Market & Bakery
© Dave & Rita’s Farm Market & Bakery

White deer inspired a granola, and that’s not a sentence you read every day. Near this farm market sits a former Army depot known for its rare white deer.

The bakery tipped its hat with White Deer Granola. It’s one of the most famous items on the shelves.

The market sits along NY-96A in Romulus, between Seneca and Cayuga lakes. Open farm fields stretch out in nearly every direction.

Bread is the backbone here. Loaves, pastries, donuts, and pies are baked fresh using wholesome, fresh, and organic ingredients.

A trained pastry chef leads the baking. That skill shows up in desserts that go beyond basic farm stand fare.

Look for strawberry rhubarb pie when it’s around. Gooey chocolate and marshmallow brownies are another tasty reason to visit.

Cookies and ice cream join the lineup too. A cone on a summer afternoon feels just right out here.

The farm side matters just as much. Fresh fruits and vegetables grown on the property fill the market.

So you can grab dinner veggies and dessert in one stop. That’s efficient snacking at its finest.

Hours shift with the seasons, so check before you go. The store is generally closed early in the week, so aim for Thursday through the weekend.

Address: 5404 NY-96A, Romulus, NY 14541

7. Hearth & Harvest

Hearth & Harvest
© Hearth & Harvest

Sourdough, wraps, and home decor walk into a shop on Main Street. That’s not a joke setup, it’s Hearth and Harvest.

Ovid is a small rural village of about 600 people. It sits on the farm ridge between Seneca and Cayuga lakes.

The shop calls itself a must stop while passing through the heart of the Finger Lakes. Given the location, that claim holds up.

A coffee bar serves Finger Lakes Roasters coffee. It’s a great way to start a back road drive.

Baked goods share shelf space with groceries, ready-to-eat meals, and gifts at this small general store. A loaf of sourdough makes an excellent grilled cheese once you get home.

Ready-to-eat wraps are what the shop is best known for. Side dishes and daily specials make lunch easy to grab and go.

Produce and a small selection of groceries fill out the space. You can stock up for a picnic without a detour to a big store.

Gifts and home decor give you a reason to browse. A small souvenir from upstate New York beats another magnet.

One practical note before you go. There’s no public restroom, so plan your stops.

Hours run Monday through Friday from 8 AM to 5 PM. Saturday wraps up at 2 PM, and Sundays are closed.

Address: 7194 Main St, Ovid, NY 14521

8. 2 cats cakery and sweet treats

2 cats cakery and sweet treats
© 2 cats cakery and sweet treats

Two cats got their name on the sign, and the cakes do the rest of the talking. This Main Street shop in Odessa is built around custom cakes.

Wedding cakes are a specialty. Birthdays and other big moments get plenty of attention too.

Odessa is a village of fewer than 600 people in the Schuyler County hills. It sits just south of Seneca Lake, away from the busier lakeside traffic.

Not planning a party? No problem.

Muffins, pies, and pastries are baked daily. That makes it an easy breakfast stop on a quiet morning drive.

Coffee and cold drinks are available too. Grab a muffin and a cup, and you’re set for the road.

The shop is takeout only. Think of it as fuel for a hike or a scenic drive through the hills.

If you’ve got a celebration coming up, ask about custom orders. A cake from a tiny village bakery makes a sweet story at any party.

Hours are short, so check the calendar before heading out. It’s open Thursday and Friday from 8 AM to 4 PM.

Saturday hours run from 8 AM to 2 PM. The rest of the week, the bakers take a well-earned breather.

Address: 109 East Main St, Odessa, NY 14869

9. Mangus Farms

Mangus Farms
© Mangus Farms

Cinnamon blueberry bread is reason enough to find Burdett on a map. This farm market pairs quality fruit with homemade baked goods.

Burdett is a hillside hamlet of roughly 300 people. It sits along the east side of Seneca Lake in Schuyler County.

Small towns like this often hide the best stops. This one rewards anyone willing to leave the main tourist routes.

Fruit comes first here, and the quality stands out. Grab whatever’s in season for a snack on the drive.

Then turn to the baked goods. Pastries and desserts share space with that famous cinnamon blueberry bread.

Homemade jam is on the shelves too. Pair it with the bread and you’ve got tomorrow’s breakfast handled.

The place has a friendly, local feel. It’s run by folks who clearly care about what they bake.

A stop here works well during a day of exploring the lake’s east side. You’ll pass plenty of farmland and pretty views along the way.

Plan around the hours, which favor weekdays. It’s open Monday through Thursday from 9 AM to 5 PM.

Friday and Saturday hours run from 9 AM to 4 PM. Sundays are closed, so don’t save this one for the end of a long weekend.

Address: 3710 Main St, Burdett, NY 14818

10. Heart’n Hand

Heart'n Hand
© Heart’n Hand

Peach, cherry, and chicken pot pie make a pretty strong opening lineup. This family-owned bakery sits on a rural stretch north of Skaneateles village.

Farmland surrounds the shop, far from the lakefront shops downtown. That’s exactly why plenty of travelers drive right past.

Fruit pies are the main event here. Peach and cherry are standouts, and the shelves change with the seasons.

Keep an eye out for seasonal grape pie. It’s a Finger Lakes classic and well worth the drive.

Savory cravings get attention too. Frozen chicken pot pies make dinner easy once you get home.

Cookies deserve a spot in your bag. Raisin oatmeal, snickerdoodles, and raspberry pillow cookies are all part of the lineup.

Homemade bread is available as well. A cheese spread from the shop pairs nicely with it.

Friendly owners run the place, and it shows in the small details. It’s a great final stop on any New York bakery road trip.

Hours lean toward midweek. The shop opens Wednesday through Friday from 10 AM to 5 PM.

Saturday runs from 10 AM to 3 PM, and there’s a free lot for easy parking. Just leave room in the trunk, because one pie never seems like enough.

Address: 4463 State St, Skaneateles, NY 13152