One pound of corned beef. One pound of pastrami. One pound of turkey, all stacked on a single sandwich with Swiss and Russian dressing.
That monster weighs approximately four and a half pounds, including the meat, cheese, bread, and dressing. Brave eaters get just 30 minutes to finish every bite. Win, and your photo lands on a Wall of Fame.
I love that this lives in New York, just not the city you’d guess. The deli sits far upstate, yet it leans hard into Big Apple deli style. Even the dining room carries a nostalgic New York City theme.
I’d probably just admire the challenge from a safe distance. Then again, the menu holds dozens of other overstuffed sandwiches worth a look. So which would you choose, glory on the wall or a normal-sized lunch?
Three Pounds Of Meat And A Ticking Clock Await You

Thirty minutes. That’s all the time you get to finish the Big Mouth Challenge at Jonny C’s NY Deli and Caterers.
The sandwich packs one pound of corned beef, one pound of pastrami, and one pound of turkey. A quarter pound of Swiss cheese and Russian dressing join the party.
All of it rides on four pieces of rye bread. The full build weighs approximately four and a half pounds, making it an enormous challenge even for experienced eaters.
Finish in time, and the reward list gets sweet. Your meal is free, you score a T-shirt, and your picture goes up on the Wall of Fame.
Fall short, and you simply pay for the sandwich. Honestly, you still walk away with a mountain of leftovers and a great story.
My advice is simple. Skip breakfast that day, pace yourself, and don’t burn time talking between bites.
Bringing a friend to cheer helps too. Someone should record the moment, whether it ends in victory or in a quiet, very full surrender.
Either way, few lunches come with this much drama. That alone makes the trip memorable.
Your Face Could End Up On The Wall Of Fame

Most restaurants hang art on their walls. Jonny C’s NY Deli and Caterers hangs champions.
The Wall of Fame honors people who conquered the Big Mouth Challenge within the time limit. Each winner earns a permanent spot, plus a T-shirt to prove it later.
That shirt might be the most earned piece of clothing you’ll ever own. No store sells it, and no shortcut gets you one.
The wall also works as a fun warning sign for first-timers. One look tells you this sandwich means business.
The challenge has drawn attention from food challenge fans online. Videos of eaters tackling the giant stack have appeared on YouTube.
That gives this New York deli a little celebrity buzz. Still, the real stars are the regular folks pictured on that wall.
If you plan to try, study the rules before you sit down. Knowing the clock and the contents helps you build a strategy.
And if you’d rather watch, that’s fine too. Cheering on a stranger battling three pounds of meat counts as entertainment in my book.
Soup, Breakfast, And Sweets Round Out The Menu

Sandwiches grab the headlines, but the rest of the menu deserves attention. Soups rotate daily, with specials like French Onion, Beef on Weck, and Seafood Bisque.
Classics such as matzo ball, chicken noodle, minestrone, and chili also appear. A bowl of matzo ball soup feels just right in a New York-style deli.
Breakfast runs all day, which is a gift for late risers. Options include breakfast sandwiches and the Hungry Man, loaded with eggs, bacon, sausage, ham, hash browns, and American cheese.
That enormous breakfast sandwich could be its own mini challenge. I’d want a nap right after.
Burgers, salads, wraps, hot entrees, chicken fingers, fries, and rings fill out the lineup. Cobb, Chef, Greek, and Caesar salads offer lighter choices.
Save room for something sweet if you can. Chocolate chip cookies and peanut butter brownies sit on the dessert list.
Weekly rotating treats show up too, like the Nutty Blondie and Snowball Cupcake. With sweets changing often, a second visit always has a fresh surprise waiting.
Dozens Of Overstuffed Sandwiches Make Choosing Tough

Decision paralysis is real here. The menu at Jonny C’s NY Deli and Caterers lists a long lineup of numbered favorite sandwiches and subs.
Names like the #4 Park Avenue, #37 The Hornet, and #41 Pittsburgh show up on the list. There’s even a #60 Soul Stealer, which sounds like it should come with a warning label.
The deli calls its subs and sandwiches over-stuffed. That word fits the whole vibe of a place famous for a three-pound challenge.
Triple Decker options add another layer, literally. You can also build your own sandwich or wrap if the numbered list feels overwhelming.
My tip is to check the menu online before you go. Picking ahead saves you from staring at the board while the line waits.
Classic pastrami on rye fits the New York deli spirit perfectly. A Reuben makes a smart pick too if you love corned beef.
The deli also rolls out a new sandwich special each week. That gives regulars a reason to come back and try something fresh.
A Queens Native Brought The Big Apple Deli Spirit Upstate

Jon Cohen grew up in Queens, New York. He started working in foodservice at just sixteen years old.
Over the years, he ran numerous delis and restaurants. Then he moved to the Buffalo area and married Colleen, a Buffalo native.
That mix of city roots and Western New York life shaped Jonny C’s NY Deli and Caterers. The deli opened in November 2006.
A city kid bringing pastrami culture upstate makes a pretty good origin story. It explains why the menu feels so committed to classic deli style.
Darcy, the managing co-owner, joined the team in 2008. She became Jon’s business partner in 2017.
That kind of long-term loyalty says a lot about a workplace. It’s nice when someone grows from staff member to owner at the same spot.
Jon’s business interests stretch beyond sandwiches, too. He also owns Pie O Mine and Greens, plus Dande Farms Golf Course.
Clearly, the man likes keeping busy. Lucky for hungry locals, the deli remains a big piece of that story.
New York City Nostalgia Covers The Dining Room

Skyline dreams meet suburban lunch inside this dining room. The eat-in space at Jonny C’s NY Deli and Caterers is decorated with New York City nostalgia.
Photos of NYC help set the mood. You’re hundreds of miles from Manhattan, yet the walls keep nudging you back there.
That theme fits the food perfectly. Eating pastrami under city photos just feels right.
The deli runs on a self-service setup. You order at the counter, then grab a seat when your food is ready.
That style keeps things relaxed and casual. Nobody expects fancy manners when you’re handling a stacked sandwich.
Families can settle at a table without fuss. Solo diners can enjoy a quick lunch break too.
If you plan on attempting the Big Mouth Challenge, eating in is the way to go. The clock and the Wall of Fame both live here, after all.
For regular meals, the dining room gives you space to slow down. A warm bowl of soup tastes better when you aren’t eating it in a car.
Finding The Deli Takes Just One Easy Turn

Transit Road is a main route through the Buffalo suburbs. Jonny C’s NY Deli and Caterers sits right along it, at the corner of Casey Road.
The full address is 9350 Transit Rd, East Amherst, NY 14051. That makes it simple to plug into any map app.
East Amherst lies in Western New York, north of Buffalo. It’s an easy stop if you’re running errands or passing through the area.
Hours run Monday through Saturday from 10 a.m. to 8 p.m. The deli stays closed on Sundays, so plan your cravings accordingly.
That Sunday break catches people off guard sometimes. Nobody wants to arrive dreaming of pastrami and find locked doors.
A 10 a.m. opening works nicely for an all-day breakfast fan. You can show up for eggs or a sub with zero judgment.
For challenge seekers, an earlier visit might be smart. Starting fresh beats tackling three pounds of meat after a long day.
Whatever time you choose, the location keeps things convenient. Good food rarely sits this close to a main road.
Your Couch Counts As A Dining Room Too

Some days call for sweatpants instead of a road trip. Jonny C’s NY Deli and Caterers gets that.
Takeout and delivery are both available. You can order online through the deli’s own website.
DoorDash, GrubHub, and Uber Eats also carry the menu. That gives you plenty of ways to get a stacked sub to your door.
Online ordering helps with the giant menu, too. You can browse slowly without feeling rushed at the counter.
This works great for families with different tastes. One person grabs a burger while another picks soup and a salad.
A quick tip from me: order the bread-heavy items close to mealtime. Subs taste best when they haven’t traveled too long.
Soups and hot entrees can make a cozy dinner on a chilly Western New York evening. Add a brownie, and the night improves fast.
Of course, the Big Mouth Challenge only counts in person. Eating three pounds of meat on your couch earns you a nap, not a spot on the wall.
Big Events Get The Same Big Deli Treatment

Feeding a crowd is stressful, so handing it off sounds smart. Catering is a major part of Jonny C’s NY Deli and Caterers, right there in the name.
Catering services are available for events throughout Western New York, with arrangements made directly through the restaurant. The coverage area stretches from Rochester to Silver Creek in New York.
The event list is wide. It includes corporate gatherings, graduations, weddings, anniversaries, picnics, and BBQs.
The deli also caters Bar Mitzvahs, Shivas, and Kiddush. That range shows real respect for deli traditions and family gatherings.
Box lunches make work meetings much easier. Hot and cold buffets plus breakfast buffets cover nearly any time of day.
Around the holidays, seasonal extras appear too. Thanksgiving trays and pies have been offered, which could save a busy host.
My advice is to reach out early for big events. Popular dates fill fast at any caterer.
Think about it this way. A party built around deli platters from the home of a three-pound sandwich probably won’t leave anyone hungry.






