Skip to content

We Found The 10 Absolute Best Pizza Places Hidden In Rochester, New York

I love that this city refuses to let pizza get boring, even for a single minute. Thin crusts and thick square slices both have loyal fans here, so every craving gets a fair turn.

One local pizza shop proudly calls itself a garage, which isn’t where I usually go looking for dinner. I’m already curious about what’s cooking under the hood, and I’m guessing it beats motor oil by a mile.

New York gets plenty of pizza bragging rights, but most of that buzz lands on one big city. This smaller upstate city quietly built a pizza lineup that deserves its own spotlight, and then some.

Exploring it block by block, one slice at a time, sounds like a perfect weekend to me. Just check the hours before heading out, since a few kitchens keep surprisingly short schedules each week.

1. Peels On Wheels Pizza Garage

Peels On Wheels Pizza Garage
© Peels On Wheels Pizza Garage

A pizza shop named after a garage sounds like a joke until you see the menu. Peels On Wheels Pizza Garage is a casual takeout counter on Culver Road with serious pie goals.

You get four pizza styles here, New York, Detroit, Sicilian, and Grandma, with different varieties available throughout the week. That means a thin slice fan and a crispy-edge fan can both leave happy.

The crust gets a lot of love for its crunch and its light feel. Toppings come balanced, so the cheese, sauce, and cup and char pepperoni all share the spotlight.

Hungry for something beyond pizza? Arancini and mozzarella fritta sit on the menu, and both are vegetarian.

Plant-based eaters get a real deal too. The shop offers several vegan options alongside its regular pizza menu, giving plant-based eaters some choices at this small counter spot.

Planning matters with this one. The doors open Wednesday through Saturday only, from 11 AM to 8 PM, and Friday evening brings the biggest rush.

Since there’s no table service and no restroom, think of it as a grab-and-go mission. Pick up your pie, then head home or to a nearby park.

Street parking is free, but spaces can be tricky to find. A quick loop around the block might be part of the adventure.

Dogs are allowed, so your four-legged buddy can ride along for pickup. Kids fit right in too.

For a Rochester pizza run that feels like a secret handshake, this garage delivers. Reservations aren’t taken, so just show up hungry and ready.

Address: 1157 Culver Rd, Rochester, NY 14609

2. Squatcho’s

Squatcho's
© Squatcho’s

Bigfoot might be hard to find, but this vegan pizzeria isn’t. Squatcho’s sits right on East Main Street in downtown Rochester.

The entire menu is plant-based, and it doesn’t hold back. You’ll find vegan Italian sausage, vegan pepperoni, and a buffalo chicken pizza made without any chicken.

The crust earns praise for being crunchy and chewy at once. That combo is the real test of any good pie, vegan or not.

Rochester has its famous garbage plate, and Squatcho’s makes a vegan version. Cookies and cream shakes round out the comfort food lineup nicely.

Side orders deserve a look too. Garlic knots, poutine, and a sun-dried tomato and spinach pizza show up as menu highlights.

The specials rotate often and get creative. Flavor pairings here can be ones you’ve never seen on a pizza before, so check what’s new.

Hours are a little unusual, so double-check before you go. Tuesday, Wednesday, and Friday have a lunch window and a dinner window, with a break in between.

Saturday runs from noon to 7 PM. The shop is closed Sunday and Monday, but opens Thursday from 11 AM to 2 PM and again from 4 PM to 7 PM.

You can dine in, take out, or get delivery. The space feels casual and quiet, which makes it a nice stop for a solo lunch.

Downtown parking includes free street spots, paid lots, and metered spaces. Finding one can take a minute, so give yourself some extra time.

Address: 17 E Main St, Rochester, NY 14614

3. Pizza Nota

Pizza Nota
© Pizza Nota

Connecticut’s famous pizza style found a home in Rochester’s Neighborhood of the Arts. Pizza Nota serves New Haven-style thin crust on Anderson Avenue.

A coal-fired oven gives the crust its crispy char. The pies run 16 inches, so bring a friend or plan for leftovers.

Start with the New Haven Tomato Pie if you want the classic experience. It’s vegetarian and puts the sauce front and center.

Other classics include Classic Cheese and Cup and Char. The NOTA Remix section adds options like Enzo and The Brooklyn Serenade.

Chicken cutlets are a big deal here too. You can get them Parm, Buffalo, or a few other house styles.

Snack lovers have plenty to choose from. Garlic NOTA Knots, Pizza Logs, and cheesy fried bites all share the menu.

Dessert gets fun with zeppole. Pizza Nota also teams up with Ridge Donut on a special Apple Fritter.

The room features exposed brick and a big statement oven. It feels relaxed and family-friendly, with outdoor seating as well.

Hours are limited, so plan ahead. It’s open Monday and Thursday evenings from 4 PM to 8 PM, Friday and Saturday for lunch and dinner, and Sunday from noon to 8 PM.

Tuesday and Wednesday are the restaurant’s regular closing days. Free parking is usually easy to find, which is a nice bonus in this part of town.

Address: 192 Anderson Ave, Rochester, NY 14607

4. Forno Tony

Forno Tony
© Forno Tony

Pizza, gelato, and pastries under one roof sounds like a dream menu. Forno Tony makes it real on University Avenue.

The pizza here is Roman-style, which sets it apart from most Rochester slices. The crust is aged and developed, giving it real depth of flavor.

Want something unusual? The Carbonara Margarita is a menu highlight that blends two Italian favorites into one idea.

The gelato is made from scratch. So is the bakery side, with artisanal pastries ready for your sweet tooth.

Coffee is on the menu too. That makes this a solid stop for a mid-morning snack, not just lunch.

Timing is the trickiest part of a visit. Forno Tony opens Thursday through Saturday only, from 9 AM to 5 PM.

Plan for counter service with quick turnaround. You can eat there or take your order to go, but delivery isn’t offered.

Vegetarians will feel right at home. The shop offers a full vegetarian menu along with its other options.

Catering is available if you want to bring Roman pizza to a party. Picture the office reaction to gelato showing up too.

Parking usually isn’t a headache here. There’s a free lot plus free street parking nearby.

For pizza fans who love Italian bakeries, this is a three-day-a-week treat worth circling on your calendar. Just don’t show up on a Monday and wonder why the lights are off.

Address: 1350 University Ave, Rochester, NY 14607

5. Pizza Wizard

Pizza Wizard
© Pizza Wizard

Magic tricks are optional, but square pizza is the main spell at Pizza Wizard. This casual cafe on South Clinton Avenue cooks its pies in pans.

The Detroit-style square slices get top billing. Expect a thicker crust, a rich red sauce, and generous toppings.

Flavor combos here lean creative. You can also build your own pie with a range of meat and veggie toppings.

Wings come in two forms. There are traditional chicken wings and vegan seitan wings, which keep plant-based eaters in the game.

The menu also covers chicken tenders and a Number One Salad. For dessert, look for Dr Dave’s Cookie Nook.

Drink fans might spot Chinotto, an Italian citrus soda. It’s a fun pairing with a hearty square slice.

Pizza Wizard offers both full vegan and full vegetarian menus. That makes group orders much easier for mixed crowds.

Families get high chairs, and kids are welcome. The vibe stays casual and peaceful, even with college students and groups around.

Hours run Wednesday through Sunday, from 11 AM to 8:30 PM. Monday and Tuesday are days off.

Friday and Saturday evenings get the busiest. A weekday lunch is often calmer if you’d rather skip the crowd.

You can order at the counter, sit inside or outdoors, or get delivery. Street parking can be tight, so a short walk might be in your future.

Address: 760 S Clinton Ave, Rochester, NY 14620

6. The Pizza Stop

The Pizza Stop
© The Pizza Stop

Old New York City decor and slices you can grab fast make State Street feel a little like Manhattan. The Pizza Stop keeps things simple and delicious.

This no-frills counter serves New York-style pizza. You’ll find classic thin-crust slices plus stuffed pies for bigger appetites.

The crust is crunchy outside and chewy inside. Add a strong sauce and lots of topping choices, and you’ve got a classic downtown lunch.

Budget-minded eaters, take note. This is one of the most wallet-friendly stops on the list.

House, Caesar, and Cobb salads give you lighter options alongside the pizza. There’s also a full vegetarian menu and a kids’ menu.

The shop is welcoming to all kinds of guests. It’s known as LGBTQ+ friendly and has a gender-neutral restroom.

Dog owners, here’s good news. Pet dogs are not permitted inside the restaurant under New York State health regulations, although service animals are allowed and outdoor pet policies may vary.

Sports fans can catch a game while they eat. Seating is available inside and out.

Hours stretch across all seven days. Weekdays start at 11 AM, Saturday at noon, and Sunday at 1 PM.

Tuesday and Friday afternoons tend to get busy with the lunch crowd. Evenings are usually quieter, which works well for a calm slice.

Downtown parking options include free street spaces, paid garages, and lots. Delivery is another easy route when you’d rather stay in.

Address: 131 State St #133, Rochester, NY 14614

7. Nino’s Pizzeria

Nino's Pizzeria
© Nino’s Pizzeria

Thick, square, and loaded with cheese, the Sicilian pie is the headliner at Nino’s Pizzeria. The shop sits in compact quarters on Culver Road.

Don’t expect fancy decor. The focus stays on the pizza, and that’s the way it should be.

The crust is crispy on the outside and light inside. A chunky red sauce and plenty of cheese finish the job.

Meat fans should check out the Sicilian Meat Lovers Pizza. It’s one of the menu highlights for good reason.

Feeding a crowd? The Extra Large Cheese and 10 Jumbo Wings combo makes game night much easier.

Nino’s has a laid-back, quiet feel. It’s family-friendly and easygoing, with counter service instead of table service.

Since there’s no restroom, plan for a quick stop. Takeout and delivery are both popular ways to enjoy a pie here.

Hours fit well with dinner plans. Monday through Saturday, it runs from 4 PM to 9 PM.

Sunday opens earlier at 11 AM. That makes it a handy pick for a weekend lunch.

There’s a free lot plus free street parking. Spots can still fill up, so be patient for a minute.

If thin crust isn’t your style, Nino’s offers a hearty change of pace. One square slice might just turn into two.

Address: 1328 Culver Rd, Rochester, NY 14609

8. PizzaPie Pizzeria

PizzaPie Pizzeria
© PizzaPie Pizzeria

Slices this good can catch you off guard on a regular drive down East Avenue. PizzaPie Pizzeria keeps a low profile while turning out crispy thin crust.

The style is classic New York. You’ll find crispy slices plus a lineup of specialty pies.

Side orders keep things easy for families. Mozzarella sticks are vegetarian, and the french fries are vegan.

Kids get their own menu here. It’s a casual, family-friendly spot where little ones are welcome.

The full vegetarian menu adds more choices. That helps when your group has different eating styles.

Parking is one of the easier parts of the visit. There’s an on-site lot plus free street parking, and spaces are usually plentiful.

Dogs are welcome outside. Outdoor seating makes a nice spot for a slice on a sunny day.

Hours change throughout the week, so it pays to look before you go. Tuesday through Friday open at noon, while Saturday, Sunday, and Monday start at 3 PM.

Friday, Saturday, and Sunday stay open until 9 PM. Monday through Thursday, the restaurant closes at 8 PM.

Catering is offered too. A pile of New York-style pies can make any birthday or office lunch a hit.

Delivery and no-contact delivery are both options. Dine-in works well if you’d rather eat your slice fresh from the oven.

Address: 1827 East Ave, Rochester, NY 14610

9. Linda’s New York Pizzeria

Linda's New York Pizzeria
© Linda’s New York Pizzeria

Arcade games and huge thin slices make a pretty great pair. Linda’s New York Pizzeria brings both to Lyell Avenue.

The pizza is authentic New York style. Expect a thin, crisp crust, tasty sauce, and big slices that aren’t greasy.

Curious eaters should check out the Spicy Cherry Pepper Blush Sauce Pizza. It’s vegetarian and brings a little kick.

Linda’s Plate Pizza is another menu highlight. In a city famous for its plates, that name alone sparks curiosity.

Slice options include cheese and buffalo chicken. Half cheese and half Italian sausage pies help settle family debates.

The calzone is vegetarian and makes a filling lunch. Wings round out the lineup for game day orders.

Early birds have a reason to celebrate. Breakfast and brunch are on offer, and coffee is served too.

Daily specials keep regular visits interesting. Kids are welcome, and high chairs are available.

Hours vary across the week. Monday opens at 10 AM, Tuesday, Wednesday, and Friday at 9 AM, and Saturday at 2 PM.

Sunday is closed, but Thursday hours run from 9 AM to 9 PM. Friday mornings and afternoons get the busiest.

Parking is easy with a free lot and free street spaces. Delivery is available if the arcade can wait for another day.

Address: 1219 Lyell Ave, Rochester, NY 14606

10. Fiorella

Fiorella
© Fiorella

Wood-fired pizza inside a public market shed is a twist few cities can claim. Fiorella makes its home at the Rochester Public Market.

The bistro has a minimalist-chic look. Its kitchen focuses on wood-fired pizza and housemade pastas built around local ingredients.

Pizza is the star, but the meatballs get plenty of attention too. Chicken cutlets also earn a spot on the must-try list.

Pasta lovers can go simple with Spaghetti Pomodoro and basil sauce. It’s a vegetarian choice that lets fresh flavors shine.

Save room for dessert. The gelato makes a sweet ending to a pizza night.

Specials change, so each visit can bring something new. Coffee also gets high marks here.

The atmosphere works for date night or a group dinner. Table service and counter service are both available.

Fiorella takes reservations, and dinner reservations are recommended. That’s a smart move for a weekend evening.

Hours run Wednesday through Saturday. Lunch goes from 11:30 AM to 2 PM, and dinner runs from 5 PM to 9 PM.

Outdoor seating adds charm on nice days. Curbside pickup and takeout work if you’d rather eat at home.

Parking at the market is usually easy, with a free lot and free street spaces. Few places in New York pair pizza with a market setting quite this well.

Address: 5 Rochester Public Market, Rochester, NY 14609